View Full Version : Winderlich
I don't know if this is good or bad, but gee he looks like a young Nathan Brown
MrFurious
28 Mar 2004, 14:26
Winderlich looks OK for a 4th gamer.... give him a little time to settle in.
Best young player for the Bombers today has been Watson...showed some fantastic vision in close at times today...
Lets hope the injured regulars make it back VERY soon, so Bolton and Reynolds can get the a$$...
both have been comprehensively towelled up by their opponents at Port...
I don't care what ppl say, Reynolds is not good enuff... fast yes. But skillful, and/or tough...NO... Constantly out-positioned, out manuevered, and generally out-played...
Ditto for Bolton...
Embarrassing first up effort all round, but luckily it IS the first round... 21 weeks to improve Boys....
chasing Amy
28 Mar 2004, 16:13
Not impressed with Licha was not accountable for his man today and always takes the flashy option. Back to the two's for a while yet
I would like to see Darren Walsh get a go (both the same weight)but faster and more direct that Licha.
Both will be good but i'd like to see a bit more of walsh.
As for Jobe watson very very impressed cool head and clean hands if he can stay injury free he will be a permenant fixture by years end.
windyhill
28 Mar 2004, 17:05
Licka, Ok....He`s bloody tiny , he has that cheeky look about him, he`s been given some sort of go, seems out of his depth. That is my initial prognosis. Will never build up, but must not be sacked yet. Will be given more chances, but the clock is ticking.
windyhill
28 Mar 2004, 17:06
sorry, one more thing, comparing him to Nathan Brown is comical.
Stealth bomber
28 Mar 2004, 17:51
And Dean Rioli is the next Michael Voss.
For the love of God, people need to stop making comparisons like this.
winder - back to the gym
jobe - stay in the 1's
richards - hard to decide
stanton - back to the magoos
bradley - back to WA or where ever you came from
LM - Some more time in the magoos
Originally posted by windyhill
sorry, one more thing, comparing him to Nathan Brown is comical.
Sorry, I didn't make myself clear.
He LOOKS like Nathan Brown. Facial structure, thin body, hair coloring etc
http://www.essendonfc.com.au/images/players2004/wind.jpg
anonymous Joe
29 Mar 2004, 13:52
Originally posted by jivey
bradley - back to WA or where ever you came from
PLease don't.
He'll be good.
He holds the ball like Brown, but that's the only comparisn I can think of at the moment.
He was ordinary yesterday. Which was disapointing seeing as though I think that's the most game time he's ever had.
bLuEMoOsE
29 Mar 2004, 21:15
Lets go Pessimism.
Played most of the day in the forward pocket only moved out when the game was over, showed a little.
as for Jivey, a little harsh.
Bradley is 19 199 cm's and 92 kilo's playing his first senior game and his first game as a backmen considering he spent most of his time in the ruck and as a winger in Jnr's, playing on Gorrilla's like Lade and treadrea who are pushing 100 kilos for the same size or smaller of course he was going to get towled.
Secondly the ball was in their forward line that bloody often.
Reynolds is a good kid fast, good head for it had 1 bad game (appaling admitedly) and the player we were all comparing to a young James Hird 3 weeks ago should be dropped and delisted.
Shame Shame Shame. we sound like Saint Kilda supports.
Originally posted by windyhill
Licka, Ok....He`s bloody tiny , he has that cheeky look about him, he`s been given some sort of go, seems out of his depth. That is my initial prognosis. Will never build up, but must not be sacked yet. Will be given more chances, but the clock is ticking.
Oh come on... ticking? He's only just stepped on the field....
I don't think he has ANYTHING to be worried about if his clock is that same brand as Bolts.
Originally posted by jivey
winder - back to the gym
jobe - stay in the 1's
richards - hard to decide
stanton - back to the magoos
bradley - back to WA or where ever you came from
LM - Some more time in the magoos
WTF???? Are you for real?
New recruits take time to come on and build their bodies. Bradley is 17 for crying out loud..... you should consider this post of yours in a couple years when you are screaming out his name.
Originally posted by jivey
bradley - back to WA or where ever you came from
What a stupid bitch!
Stealth bomber
3 Apr 2004, 22:51
Well, Winderlich was pretty ordinary again. I could have counted his disposals on one hand tonight.
Doesn't look confident or comfortable. Isn't accountable at all.
I liked his game a lot from what little we saw of him last year, so I guess maybe I'm expecting too much too soon from him.
I want him to succeed. He's got speed to burn, appears to have good goal sense, and he's got Boris' number.
windyhill
4 Apr 2004, 01:20
No good.
Pure and simple.
No good.