PDA

View Full Version : Th king of the dons

Casey
4 Jun 2004, 22:08
who in your opinion is the greateast player/players ever to play at the essendon football club?
Stegelator
5 Jun 2004, 02:04
Reynolds, Coleman, Hird, in that order
windyhill
5 Jun 2004, 09:15
Simon Madden.
**** Reynolds for the effect he had on The Club. And he was a mad carlton fan as a boy, trained with them and was shown the door by them, probably the ultimate **** up by any club of all time. Couldn`t happen to a nicer club.
Bartholin Juice
5 Jun 2004, 12:31
The general concensus seems to be Reynolds, Coleman, Hird.

The best I've seen is Hird, but Simon Madden isn't far behind.
Casey
5 Jun 2004, 17:32
Originally posted by Bartholin Juice
The general concensus seems to be Reynolds, Coleman, Hird.

The best I've seen is Hird, but Simon Madden isn't far behind.

i dont think that Tim watson is that far behind
Cisco Del Prano
5 Jun 2004, 20:24
Bill Duckworth
Stegelator
5 Jun 2004, 21:10
hutchison would rate a mention wouldn't he?
Napier_Street
5 Jun 2004, 21:22
Hird by a mile
pfinn
5 Jun 2004, 22:38
Originally posted by Stegelator
hutchison would rate a mention wouldn't he?

He'd be top 5 easily.
VANDA
5 Jun 2004, 22:57
1. Reynolds
2. Coleman
3. Hutchison
4. Hird
5. Madden