PDA

View Full Version : West Football Department


Croydon
7 Jun 2004, 03:06
Is The West Australian's football department, and sport's department in general, in for a shake-up.
The arrival of Steve Butler from the paper's general section has certainly ruffled some feathers. He has replaced John McGrath as an AFL writer.
Talking about egos. What has caused some concerns among his colleagues was last Thursday's article (including a photo and contact phone number). Has that ever happened before? Certainly, for the appointment of a new sports editor, yes, but not for a sports writer.
But there is more . . . . One would think that the sports editor would have written the announcement. But no . . . . Butler wrote it himself, presumably with the editor's blessing. However, about three quarters of the article was cut. One staff member tells me it was extremely boastful.
To end this report, there are concerns that Butler is angling for the sports editor's job when Ray Wilson is expected to give the sports editor's job away after the Olympics.
Very interesting. There is an enormous display of egos on display there.

Streaker
7 Jun 2004, 04:06
It would be nice if they actually watched the games once in a while. Peter Ker had Ashley Hansen kicking a goal with his first kick in AFL football. Maybe they need to tape the game rather than relying on flawed memory.

Croydon
10 Jun 2004, 02:16
Yes, there are a few problems regarding accuracy.

mick ryan
10 Jun 2004, 11:38
Originally posted by Croydon
Yes, there are a few problems regarding accuracy.

That is clearly an understatement!

You seem to have a very keen interest Croydon in the goings on at the West. Do you work for them?

Croydon
11 Jun 2004, 01:05
Originally posted by mick ryan
That is clearly an understatement!

You seem to have a very keen interest Croydon in the goings on at the West. Do you work for them?
No. But I have a couple of friends who work there. I have a keen interest in a strong, accurate and viable media. Without that, society is the poorer. The tripe we get on tv is hopeless. The "West" used to be a good rag under Mooner Murray's days as editor. Unfortunately it has since lost direction and constantly is error-ridden.

mick ryan
11 Jun 2004, 17:35
Originally posted by Croydon
No. But I have a couple of friends who work there. I have a keen interest in a strong, accurate and viable media. Without that, society is the poorer. The tripe we get on tv is hopeless. The "West" used to be a good rag under Mooner Murray's days as editor. Unfortunately it has since lost direction and constantly is error-ridden.



And when you haven't got any opposition you can virtually do what you like.


Where does David Reed fit in the overall scheme of things?

Croydon
12 Jun 2004, 22:39
Originally posted by mick ryan
And when you haven't got any opposition you can virtually do what you like.


Where does David Reed fit in the overall scheme of things?

I don't know Reed, though I have seen his byline from Melbourne.