View Full Version : is bate a worthy winner?
footy123
10 Nov 2004, 14:08
just checking if people think bate was a worthy winner of the morrish medal and if not who should have polled more votes and why?
mudshake
10 Nov 2004, 18:31
Absolutely.
SPECIALK
10 Nov 2004, 18:50
Of Course He Is. Dont Waste Peoples Time With These Posts Cause You Have Nothing Better To Do!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!
grugman
10 Nov 2004, 18:55
shut up u breakfast cerial
shut up u breakfast cerial
And/or "party drug"!
footyman
10 Nov 2004, 23:12
Of course Bate is a worthy winner - he had a good year and he picked up the most votes under the voting system as it is.
However, like the Brownlow, the Morrish Medal can sometimes throw up surprising results. Who would have thought Mungara Brown would win last year - general feeling from most was Colin Sylvia was clearly best in the comp. The Morrish hasn't throw up many champions in the past 5 years - Rodan has plateaued at Richmond, Brown went to VFL, Shackleton has been delisted after 2 yrs at Collingwood.
Personally I rate the coaches award more highly, but there is a place for an umpires award as well. Whoever plays fair and square in their eyes gets the trophy.
Longy413
11 Nov 2004, 07:46
Gary Moorcroft the only Morrish Medalist to play in a Premiership side?
tiger14
14 Nov 2004, 22:10
GARY IS ******** MATE......... what did he ever do apart from take a hanger in the goal square :eek:
bLuEMoOsE
15 Nov 2004, 09:20
erm
Kick over 100 goals including hawls of 5, 6, 6. Be one of the most liked players at the club for over 8 years. And still be a vital member of our VFL team.
Longy413
15 Nov 2004, 09:53
GARY IS ******** MATE......... what did he ever do apart from take a hanger in the goal square :eek:
Evidently he won a Morrish Medal and Premiership Medal.