View Full Version : Most under rated player..
hoshmen1985
18 Nov 2004, 14:11
Hey everybody,
Just wanted to get your thought on who was the most under rated player at Richmond.
I havent heard anything about hiim since he done his knee and when he was playing I thought he was a star (my favorite player when I was a kid) I think Scott Turner was a gun..
Post who u think.
Tough question hoshmen, considering we tend to rate players as soon as they show they can get one disposal per quarter in a seniors match.
Of the current crop our most underrated player is probably Kyle Archibald, and I haven't even seen him play a match! lol, Simply for the reason that he doesn't get the wraps everyone else does.
hoshmen1985
18 Nov 2004, 16:46
Tough question hoshmen, considering we tend to rate players as soon as they show they can get one disposal per quarter in a seniors match.
Our most underrated player is probably Kyle Archibald, and I haven't even seen him play a match! lol, Simply for the reason that he doesn't get the wraps everyone else does.
Going to be interesting to see if he gets a senior game this season and what he is cappable of? Heard some good things about him out of Coburg....
at the beggining of the season hartigan would have been for sure underated with him being selected late in the draft... but now he is rated by many.... most underated at the mo would be schultz..... maybe? i dunno.... tell me if you think im wrong!
This is going to upset some people but going by the fierce attacks and hatred many on here have of him - i would have to say Wayne Campbell.
1980GFVideo
18 Nov 2004, 19:13
This is going to upset some people but going by the fierce attacks and hatred many on here have of him - i would have to say Wayne Campbell.
Ill cop the abuse with you on that one peejay. Cant stand seeing duds elevated above him.
Paul Broderick.
What a champion.
Great attitude,took responsibility for his actions and worked as hard as he had to while he went about his bizness.
Champion.
i would say Richo..........he is a star and loves the club more than anyone but consistently gets trashed
Richo underrated?
The guy has been built up to be a god the last ten years.
Brad-clare
18 Nov 2004, 21:01
Paul Broderick.
What a champion.
Great attitude,took responsibility for his actions and worked as hard as he had to while he went about his bizness.
Champion.
Excellent servant of the club,our best recruit for years.
Richo gets bagged every week for his performances.
Tormented Tiger
18 Nov 2004, 21:52
Paul Broderick.
What a champion.
Great attitude,took responsibility for his actions and worked as hard as he had to while he went about his bizness.
Champion.
And a top bloke to boot. Been to a couple of family days and he is the only one who has stopped and said more than hi.
I agree sante2003, but ppl dont know what they've got till it's gone. Should be made Capt.
And a top bloke to boot. Been to a couple of family days and he is the only one who has stopped and said more than hi.
I agree sante2003, but ppl dont know what they've got till it's gone. Should be made Capt.
I totally agree. When he retired the rot started. I would also add Benny Gale. Improved with age. Probably had another season left him.
Harvey Leadpipe
19 Nov 2004, 13:08
Broderick and Gale were good servants to the club. Gale had a couple left IMO.
But don't know about Campbell being underrated. He was made our captain, albeit probably the worst captain in the clubs history, and (headshakingly) has won about a dozen Jack Dyer medals. Someone obviously rates this pretender, it ain't me though.
hoshmen1985
19 Nov 2004, 20:53
And a top bloke to boot. Been to a couple of family days and he is the only one who has stopped and said more than hi.
I agree sante2003, but ppl dont know what they've got till it's gone. Should be made Capt.
Your actualy right.... I've been to a few myslef and he talks to you like he's known you for years. Top bloke..