PDA

View Full Version : midfielders to be dropped ?


malcolm
15 Apr 2005, 19:14
From the Age - who is likely to be dropped - James ? Cassisi ? Ebert ? Cochrane ?

Port Adelaide coach Mark Williams has threatened to swing the selection axe through his side's midfield if it did not lift for the crunch AFL match against Carlton at AAMI Stadium on Saturday night.

The Power and the Blues enter the game in strikingly similar situations, with both teams on disappointing 1-2 records and looking to bounce back from embarrassing losses last week - Port against Adelaide and Carlton going down to Collingwood.

Both clubs are also weakened by injuries in their defence.

Port is missing tall defenders Chad Cornes and Matthew Bishop, while Carlton is without first-choice key defenders Bret Thornton and Luke Livingston.

It creates a chance for dangerous Carlton forward trio Brendan Fevola, Lance Whitnall and Adrian Deluca to create havoc, but likewise Port's Warren Tredrea, Brendon Lade and Toby Thurstans loom large.

The formguide suggests Tredrea is the man most likely to prove a matchwinner, given his stunning record against Carlton.

Port has won its past five games against the Blues, with Tredrea missing one of those through injury, but dominating the other four, averaging 16 kicks, 11 marks and four goals.

Williams said Tredrea was ready for a repeat performance, but could not do so unless the Power midfield - which was thrashed by Adelaide last week - provided him with better delivery.

"They have to do a lot better," Williams said.

"They get another chance this week, but there's not too many chances.

"If you're not playing well you get out of the side.

"They know that there is a responsibility, that you put the best guess out there, they have a crack at it, and if it doesn't work after a few weeks you certainly get moved out of the side and other people come in."

Lajon
15 Apr 2005, 19:35
wish we had the luxury of considering dropping the likes of James and Ebert

oporto
15 Apr 2005, 21:29
wish we had the luxury of considering dropping the likes of James and Ebert

James an absolute champion but his body is not taking the battering, well.
Ebo is not a midfielder anyway and ATM is surviving via depleted stocks

deeps
15 Apr 2005, 23:01
and cochrane?

missionpossible
15 Apr 2005, 23:18
pickett and salopek back for cochrane and shattock

surjan for ebert.

bishop for brogan.

cornes for thurstans.

shaun burgoyne for ebert

mahoney for kingsley

something like that. One thing is sure if they were all playing tomorrow night i would be a lot happier

JuniorBurger
16 Apr 2005, 01:32
pickett and salopek back for cochrane and shattock

surjan for ebert.

bishop for brogan.

cornes for thurstans.

shaun burgoyne for ebert

mahoney for kingsley

something like that. One thing is sure if they were all playing tomorrow night i would be a lot happier

Geez MP dunno why you'd wanna drop Ebo he seems too being doing the work of 2 players. ;)
No doubt it would be more comfortable if we had a fuller contingent of midfielders fit and ready. We have too get by as we are ATM and hope that the recovery times of the above mentioned players are as short as possible.

Arsene Wenger
16 Apr 2005, 01:59
I tell u one thing

Id love the surj to be in for cochrane tomo night - bit more pace wouldnt go astray

deeps
16 Apr 2005, 02:15
let shattock be... remember he's still learning our game, he's showed good signs

Ford Fairlane
16 Apr 2005, 10:11
Brett Ebert won a Magarey playing midfield for Port Magpies, regularly racking up 30-40 possessions a game. Let him have a few weeks in the midfield b4 dropping him for not cutting it as a permanent small forward.

johnnypanther
16 Apr 2005, 12:45
it seems to me that when Ports get all their midfielders available and also get game time under their belts (Francou & James) then you'll be back in the position of having one of the premier midfields.

support midfielders such as Shattock, Cochrane etc (if they still get a game ) will perform much better playing alongside the better midfielders instead of having to play the main role

when both Burgoynes,Pickett, Surjan resume and Francou,James & Wilson regain match fitness the Port side will have a plethora of pace,hardness and skill back in the midfield

oporto
16 Apr 2005, 13:09
it seems to me that when Ports get all their midfielders available and also get game time under their belts (Francou & James) then you'll be back in the position of having one of the premier midfields.

support midfielders such as Shattock, Cochrane etc (if they still get a game ) will perform much better playing alongside the better midfielders instead of having to play the main role

when both Burgoynes,Pickett, Surjan resume and Francou,James & Wilson regain match fitness the Port side will have a plethora of pace,hardness and skill back in the midfield

Good comment, agree...

deeps
16 Apr 2005, 18:16
agree with shattock.. swap cochrane for surjan.

Has cochrane ever got double digit possessions? the most useless player in the AFL... easily

PAFC2004
16 Apr 2005, 18:18
agree with shattock.. swap cochrane for surjan.

Has cochrane ever got double digit possessions? the most useless player in the AFL... easily

Of course he has... whilst he has been average lately, he is nowhere near as bad as you make him out to be.