View Full Version : Peter Riccardi v Stuart Maxfield
rampantswan
3 May 2005, 11:28
Both long kicking left footed wingman ithroughout their careers. Both have good foot skills, both had great pace, both tough players who have magnificant finishinf abilities.
I vote RICCO (no surpirise though).
Barry Schneider
3 May 2005, 11:33
Christ you haven't seen Sydney play for a while.Maxfield's kicking is atrocious and he looks like he is runing up and down on the one spot.His only redeeming feature at the moment is that he is trying to take blokes out which I encourage him to keep doing.
I should add that he is a shadow of his former self.He has been a great servant of the club but his time is almost up.
Dasher39
3 May 2005, 11:37
Riccardi's goal on the weekend, when he dodged and weaced players was simply awesome! Was like watching the Riccardi of old!
SonOfReep
3 May 2005, 11:38
I vote Riccardi as his 1990s Vince-Colosimo-in-The-Wog-Boy permed mullet totally outclassed Maxfield's puny feathered blonde 'do.
Both long kicking left footed wingman ithroughout their careers. Both have good foot skills, both had great pace, both tough players who have magnificant finishinf abilities.
I vote RICCO (no surpirise though).
Considering that you believe that Kingsley is better then Tarrant, me thinks you might have a slight credibility problem!
rampantswan
3 May 2005, 11:46
Considering that you believe that Kingsley is better then Tarrant, me thinks you might have a slight credibility problem!
;)
So you vote Maxfield??
rampantswan
3 May 2005, 11:47
I vote Riccardi as his 1990s Vince-Colosimo-in-The-Wog-Boy permed mullet totally outclassed Maxfield's puny feathered blonde 'do.
Just remember is lightning runs down the wing and kicking goals from outside 50. From what you are telling me he has declined in the last year or two?
Both similar type players though, would you agree?
donkster
3 May 2005, 11:51
Listening to SEN this morning the topic of Maxfield was brought up, due to personal issues Maxfield now lives in Melbourne, being their captain I would think it be best that he is around the club all week...
Riccardi's new role as a burst player is working beatifully, I stated back in Round two against WC that we missed Riccardi, could have done with him in the thrid when the game could have gone either way, and to get someone on the ground to hit a target boosting confidence. I love the way he has taken to his new role.
LongBomb
3 May 2005, 12:16
Considering that you believe that Kingsley is better then Tarrant, me thinks you might have a slight credibility problem!
Kinglsey averages more goals than Tarrant.
Hoola Hoops
4 May 2005, 09:30
No contest, Go Ricco!!
Kinglsey averages more goals than Tarrant.
Pike has more premierships than the entire GFC senior list.
mocaholic
4 May 2005, 09:33
Christ you haven't seen Sydney play for a while.Maxfield's kicking is atrocious and he looks like he is runing up and down on the one spot.His only redeeming feature at the moment is that he is trying to take blokes out which I encourage him to keep doing.
I should add that he is a shadow of his former self.He has been a great servant of the club but his time is almost up.
Good assessment. Sad but true.
Hoola Hoops
4 May 2005, 09:34
Pike has more premierships than the entire GFC senior list.
SO? And the Bulldogs, Collingwood, Richmond etc..
What is your point??
SO? And the Bulldogs, Collingwood, Richmond etc..
What is your point??
There needs to be a point? :eek: