View Full Version : Scott thompson or.. Brent moloney
crowsarethebest
10th May 2005, 22:18
Who would you choose?
Bentleigh
10th May 2005, 22:21
Who would you choose?
Who cares?
BulldogMike
10th May 2005, 22:36
Brent Moloney is a harder player with about the same skill level as Thompson so i would pick him.
Brent Moloney is a harder player with about the same skill level as Thompson so i would pick him.
I would say Thompson is harder.
tigerT
10th May 2005, 23:05
moloney, love his thumping kick, both are quality though..
celtic_pride
12th May 2005, 14:46
Moloney Melbourne must be rapt in that deal with geelong.
Never understood why Geelong had to give him in order to get Ottens but still hopefully the trade will work out for both clubs.
bluecrow
12th May 2005, 14:49
Thommo :)
afc9798
12th May 2005, 15:57
Who cares?
Coming from someone who thinks Deledio=Judd, your opinion wouldn't be worth having anyway.
For the record, Thommo and Moloney are a very close match, but I would take Thommo on the basis of hardness at the contest. Not much in it though.
rick James
12th May 2005, 15:58
Coming from someone who thinks Deledio=Judd, your opinion wouldn't be worth having anyway.
For the record, Thommo and Moloney are a very close match, but I would take Thommo on the basis of hardness at the contest. Not much in it though.
bingo, I'd also say Beamer is a better kick and more damaging, but Thommo is harder at the ball (Beamer harder at the man though :D)
Adrian1
12th May 2005, 16:07
I love both to be honest but reckon that Moloney will be better in long term as I think that Thommo has some long term injury problems that he will find hard to get over.
I think with all the injuries he has had in the past (cracked knee cap, shin splints etc) that he will always need to be nursed through and you will never get a full season out of him.
Havbing said that I was more disappointed when Thommo left than when either Woey or Powell left Melb
Trav 20
12th May 2005, 16:08
The same Crows fans know doubt thought Thommo was crap at Melbourne.
It's amazing what the colour of a jumper can do.
Demonheart
12th May 2005, 16:18
I'd love to have both of them....in the same team.
Two great young players, both of which will get AA selections at some stage in their careers.
Moloney, only because he now plays for us as Thommo was my favourite.
Ricketts
13th May 2005, 16:28
Thompson has had a much better season so far.
davey_magik
15th May 2005, 18:59
Thompson has had a much better season so far.
I beg to differ, but I am in the same position as Demonheart, as Thommo was my favourite but now Moloney is because he plays the game tough and kicks it long. Also he doesn't take any sh*t i.e Lance Franklin's poor attempt to clean him up in the last quarter on Saturday.
demon21
15th May 2005, 22:41
Thompson easy.
skywalk750
16th May 2005, 17:41
I would want a player that can pick out a man and pass to him.
Sylvia Saint
16th May 2005, 17:43
It's amazing what the colour of a jumper can do.
Yep, it really doesn't surprise me that jealous Geelong supporters are voting for Thompson.
JUBJUB
16th May 2005, 19:16
Yep, it really doesn't surprise me that jealous Geelong supporters are voting for Thompson.
Huh ???
So we have to vote for Tweek do we ?
If he was at Geelong I'd still go Thompson.
That's nothing against Moloney.It's just that Thompson is a bit better.
Sylvia Saint
16th May 2005, 20:16
Huh ???
So we have to vote for Tweek do we ?
If he was at Geelong I'd still go Thompson.
That's nothing against Moloney.It's just that Thompson is a bit better.
haha, unlikely.
Ricketts
17th May 2005, 13:18
Yep, it really doesn't surprise me that jealous Melbourne supporters are voting for Moloney.
davey_magik
17th May 2005, 16:51
Yep, it really doesn't surprise me that jealous Melbourne supporters are voting for Moloney.
We are happy with the trade. However I don't think you will be in 5 years time.
JUBJUB
17th May 2005, 19:10
We are happy with the trade. However I don't think you will be in 5 years time.
and we're also happy with the trade.
So let's all be happy. :)
mcphee_is_a_gun
17th May 2005, 20:39
Thompson although both are going to be great players.
Awesome_Wells
17th May 2005, 22:03
Moloney
Stiffy_18
19th May 2005, 18:40
Thommo
Brent Moloney is a harder player with about the same skill level as Thompson so i would pick him.
your only saying this because you dislike adelaide
melbournemartin
19th May 2005, 21:31
moloney is a much better kick and is tougher at the ball
both will be star midfielders in the year to come so both clubs will be happy
geelong wont be though :P
Bockchoy67
19th May 2005, 21:52
moloney is a much better kick and is tougher at the ball
both will be star midfielders in the year to come so both clubs will be happy
geelong wont be though :P
You reckon?
Anyway, obviously being an Crows fan people would expect me to jump on the Thommo train and ride away, but that's not the case. I love Moloney's long-kicking, full steam ahead running game and there's little better than his 55m goals on the run. He will be star midfielder if he keep going like this.
Thompson is a great tackler, in-your-face player that we really needed. Has a real touch of class about him, gets plenty of the ball, is able to weave his way out of trouble, knows how to position himself on the field as is a good finisher in front of goal.
Has obviously had the better year so far but in 2 years I reckon they'll be pretty much equal. That is to say, they will be equal as stars of the competition. :)
JUBJUB
19th May 2005, 23:17
moloney is a much better kick and is tougher at the ball
both will be star midfielders in the year to come so both clubs will be happy
geelong wont be though :P
Yep,we're really struggling without him. :rolleyes:
Get over it twit.It's a win-win-win for all 3 clubs.
pol06
17th March 2007, 17:48
thompson by a mile