Milne of 2002 or Williams of 04? [Archive]

Alphabet Man

14th May 2005, 19:53

yer title speaks for its self

hank_bulger

14th May 2005, 20:05

I'll take the shotgun without hesitation.

scout

14th May 2005, 20:16

Bang Bang

Alphabet Man

14th May 2005, 20:29

oops, the title should be Williams of 05

imo, id go with Milney of 02 just cos he was so unpredictable, and he hardly missed a goal that year, although Wlliams is a good player, i dont think he is as Milne, not much between them imo, Milne of 02 and Williams of 05 are times when both clubs did not have full forwards.....

catfan

14th May 2005, 22:33

Williams of 05

BulldogMike

15th May 2005, 01:05

Williams of 05 is the easy choice. His 8 goals today was a remarkable personal achievement.

Bentleigh

15th May 2005, 01:39

Two biggest twats in AFL history?

kangaroo19

15th May 2005, 02:08

Both similar looking players (stature anyway... small forwards). However, one is a pesty, crumbing goal-sneak. The other is a fast leading forward who is much more hard-working leading the Coleman race. Williams anyday.

Marklar_33

15th May 2005, 20:58

I like Milne of 2002, if I was to pick a player based on one season...

Williams doesnt have the variety that Milne had in 2002, he is a more basic leading forward... but as of now it would be Williams....

bettsie

15th May 2005, 21:12

Two biggest twats in AFL history?
shutup u fool.

cschreuder61

15th May 2005, 21:31

oops, the title should be Williams of 05

imo, id go with Milney of 02 just cos he was so unpredictable, and he hardly missed a goal that year, although Wlliams is a good player, i dont think he is as Milne, not much between them imo, Milne of 02 and Williams of 05 are times when both clubs did not have full forwards.....
willo hardly misses a goal, in fact he's leading the coleman medal. I don't think we would have milne as our only forward target... in fact i'm sure of it.
Therefore Williams > Milne .

cschreuder61

15th May 2005, 21:32

I like Milne of 2002, if I was to pick a player based on one season...

Williams doesnt have the variety that Milne had in 2002, he is a more basic leading forward... but as of now it would be Williams....
a basic leading forward...??

Munga

15th May 2005, 23:45

Pretty pointless, most people won't remember 2002.

bozza1980

16th May 2005, 16:54

Milne was good for us in 02, ofcourse it is only Rd 8, but at this stage assuming his form continues Williams has been unbelieavible!!

Pie 4 Life

16th May 2005, 17:42

Shotgun Williams.

diehard pie

16th May 2005, 20:30

Two different types of small forwards so hard to compare.
The double barrel goes on the lead while works his magic