View Full Version : Round 10 votes v Carlton
BOG
5. Goodwin - ran and provided for us all day
4. Torney - superb across half back with those safe chest marks and was a contributor pushing up the ground too
3. Bassett - always the saviour down back
2. Shirley - won the important disposals at the stoppages
1. Ricciuto - our best early on
BTM
3. Hudson - continued his fine season in the ruck
2. Bassett
1. Shirley
Rookie
Abstain
Leaping Lindner
29 May 2005, 17:26
BOG
5. Goodwin - Far and away our best probably a 9 out of 5 today!
4. Riccutio - Faded later in the game but got the hard ones when needed
3. Bassett - Another great game in what has been his best year for us
2. Bock - 2 goals from CHB has got to be worth something
1. Doughty - For sheer guts if nothing else.
BTM
3. Hudson
2. Shirley
1. Burton
Rookie
We have rookies??????
PS - Congratulations for yesterday Dave :rolleyes:
topjars
29 May 2005, 17:46
BOG
5. Goodwin
4. Shirley
3. Hudson
2. Bock
1. Hart
BTM
3. Hudson
2. Ricciuto
1. Thomson
Rookie
Neh!
Shocking game to watch but its 4 points we could quite easily have let slip.
:)
PS - Congratulations for yesterday Dave :rolleyes:
Look forward to watching it Tuesday evening. :cool:
just maybe
29 May 2005, 19:01
Rutten's weakness against quick-leading forwards was unfortunately exposed in this game. He would have been better suited to Whitnall.
AJ_No.4
29 May 2005, 19:02
BOG
5. Goodwin
4. Bock
3. Doughty
2. Shirley
1. Bassett
BTM
3. Bassett
2. Goodwin
1. Hart
Rookie
no comment
just maybe
29 May 2005, 19:32
OK...afl.com.au put Rutten in Adelaide's best players...wtf?
His stats certainly don't suggest best player material, if they're basing it on that, and Fevola gave him a bath...what are they talking about?
POTY
5. Goodwin
4. Shirley
3. Mattner
2. Bock
1. Hudson
BTM
3. Hudson
2. Shiley
1. Hart
Rookie
Pfft
Mad Dog
29 May 2005, 21:30
Very hard to give votes today
POTY
5 - Simon Goodwin - plenty of ball, and great disposal
4 - Mark Riccuito
3 - Ben Hudson - got his hand to the ball first all day, but midfielders didn't take advantage
2 - Nathan Bock - well done - 2 goals from HB
1 - Martin Mattner - breaks the lines
BTM
3 - Ben Hudon - works very hard
2 - Nathan Bassett
1 - Jason Torney - continuously mops up other people's shyte.... :cool:
ROTY
pass
POTY
5 - Goodwin
4 - Torney
3 - Ricciuto
2 - Doughty
1 - Bock
BTM
3 - Bassett
2 - Doughty
1 - Huddo
ROTY
Like Ita Buttrose, I choose to abstain.
Stiffy_18
29 May 2005, 21:51
POTY
5 - Simon Goodwin
4 - Mark Ricciuto
3 - Martin Mattner
2 - Robert Shirley
1 - Jason Torney
BTM
3 - Ben Hudson
2 - Nathan Bassett
1 - Nathan Bock
Rookie
None
dyertribe
29 May 2005, 22:04
POTY
5: Shirley
4: Goodwin
3: Bock
2: Ricciuto
1: Torney
BTM
3: Shirley
2: Bassett
1: Bock
Rookie
1: Abstain
macca23
29 May 2005, 22:14
POTY
5. Goodwin - Standout for BOG. Got plenty of it and ran the lines well. Usage of the ball was generally good too. Will give our B&F a big shake this year.
4. Shirley - really like the way he won the hard ball today. The best of the in close mid-fielders.
3. Ricciuto - thank god we have the skipper. Won some hard balls from the centre when it was really needed.
2. Bock - stepping up beautifully at CHB and capped it off with 2 good goals.
1. Mattner - one of the successes of the season. Wins the hard ball, takes the opposition on and uses the ball well.
Best Team Man
3. Hudson - best ruckman on the ground by the proverbial mile and always gives 100%
2. Bassett - worked hard to be the twine that held the backlines together, always helping out fellow defenders.
1. Doughty - certainly showing a lot more courage these days and fully committed today. Unlucky to miss the best players.
ROOKIE
None today.
musha_13
29 May 2005, 22:30
POTY
5: Goodwin
4: Bock
3: Shirley
2: Torney
1: Hudson
BTM
3: Hudson
2: Bassett
1: Shirley
Rookie
1: None Today
McLeodMagic
29 May 2005, 22:36
POTY
5 - Simon Goodwin
4 - Robert Shirley
3 - Mark Ricciuto
2 - Nathan Bock
1 - Martin Mattner
BTM
3 - Ben Hudson
2 - Jason Torney
1 - Michael Doughty
ROTY
Pass
Bockchoy67
29 May 2005, 22:46
Player of the Year
5. Goodwin - Continued his great form with another outstanding performance. Ran, ran and ran and used the ball beautifully compared to many others.
4. Shirley - Was excellent in the clearences, got the hard ball and fed it out super well. Is having a great season so far.
3. Riccuito - Not a super game but a great first quarter. When we needed his attack on the ball he was our saviour as always.
2. Bock - Once again had a great game. Is playing really well with his run off half back, neat disposal and his accountability. Nice goals too.
1. Torney - Awesome in the backlinep patchy early but ran and carried the ball with rocket boots.
Serious apologies to Mattner, Doughty, Bassett and Hudson.
Best Team Man
3. Hudson - Once again dominated the ruck and game 100.1%
2. Bassett - Courage personified and was always there to help his teamates.
1. Doughty - Had to put him somewhere. Showed some much improved courage and was fantastic as the link-man.
Rookie of the Year
Abstain - Rutten was well beaten today.
crows98
29 May 2005, 22:54
Best player votes vs. Carlton Round 10
5) Mark Ricciuto
4) Simon Goodwin
3) Nathan Bock
2) Ben Hudson
1) Scott Welsh
Best Team Votes
3) Ben Hudson
2) Nathan Bock
1) Ben Hart
Rookie
Nathan Bock
Vic Crow
30 May 2005, 00:18
POTY
5 - Goodwin
4 - Bock
3 - Torney
2 - Shirley
1 - Mattner
BTM
3 - Torney
2 - Bassett
1 - Hudson
Rookie
Abstain
Vic Crow
30 May 2005, 00:21
Rookie
Nathan Bock
Bock is too old for this. To see a list of elligible rookies go to the POTY progressive votes thread. Jericho and Rutten were our only two rookies in today's game and not one is yet to get a vote today...rightly so. Not a good day for Rutten and Jericho had limited game time.
drakeyv2
30 May 2005, 10:13
POTY
5- Goodwin
4- Welsh (I know he only played 15 min. but was difference between win & loss)
3 - Bock
2 - Roo
1 - Shirley
BTM
3 - Hudson
2 - Torney
1 - Bassett
Rookie
N/A
POTY
5 - Goodwin
4 - Bock
3 - Torney
2 - Shirley
1 - Ricciuto
BTM
3 - Hudson
2 - Bassett
1 - Welsh (for his last 10 min of the game)
Rookie
Nil
Jars458
30 May 2005, 11:20
5 Bock - terrific game in defence and kicked two goals. Never thought he had it in him.
4 Shirely - very good at the hard stuff. Nice goal too.
3 Goodwin - broke the lines won the ball and he didn't make as many mistakes as others
2 Welsh - made the differencei n the last quarter after a quiet day
1 Torney - been terrifc all year
unlucky Burton Mattner Doughty Skipworth (except for one super weak effort on our half forward line for which he was dragged)
Team Man
Shirley
Bock
Torney
Rookie
Jericho
Our disposal was awful today. That's the worst I have seen us play, even including the Brisbane game.
Lozza71
30 May 2005, 11:42
Best player
5) Ricciuto
4) Goodwin
3) Bock
2) Torney
1) Mattner
BTM
3) Bassett
2) Hart
1) Hudson
Rookie
Pass
The Toolman
30 May 2005, 12:01
POTY
5) Bobby Shirley - tough in the clinches, distributes well to team mates and is a good finisher. Has played well all year and has definitely taken the next step.
4) Jason Torney - Mr consistency was never in trouble all day and is always there to mop up and help out.
3) Simon Goodwin - playing as well as ever. Most reliable kick into 50. Just a fine player.
2) Mark Ricciuto - probably picked up another vote or two from the umps. Don't be surprised if he goes close to another Charlie this year.
1) Nathan Bock - never rated this guy. Still don't! However, he has played two very good games in a row. A few more and I'll have to reassess!!
BTM
3) Ben Hudson
2) Ben Hart
1) Nathan Bassett
relapse
30 May 2005, 12:13
Rutten's weakness against quick-leading forwards was unfortunately exposed in this game. He would have been better suited to Whitnall.
I thought that all the way through the game that Rutten would have been much better on Whitnall and maybe Fred or Bock on Fev. Rutten got a towelling, but he just isnt suited to play on him.
Dogga_Style
30 May 2005, 12:34
BOG
5. Goodwin
4. Ricciuto
3. Doughty
2. Bock
1. Shirley
BTM
3. Bassett
2. Hart
1. Doughty
Rookie
meh!
GoSarge
30 May 2005, 12:58
POTY
5 - Goodwin (I want a thorough explanation from anyone who didnt think he was BOG)
4 - Shirley
3 - Torney
2 - Doughty
1 - Bock
BTM
3 - Hudson - Ruck work was excellent
2 - Mattner
1 - Bassett
Rookie
Bock if he is eligible (did we clear this up?), otherwise abstain.
Vic Crow
30 May 2005, 13:56
This is our list of players elligible for the rookie voting. Bock was 22 before the start of the year.
Chad Gibson 18 0
Luke Jericho 20 15
Chris Knights 18 0
Joshua Krueger 21 0
Ivan Maric 19 0
John Meesen 18 0
Ben Rutten 21 11
Jacob Schuback 21 7
Matthew Smith 21 0
Nathan Van Berlo 18 0
Fergus Watts 19 5
Rowan Andrews* 19 0
Jonathon Griffin* 19 0
John Hinge* 18 0
Ryan Nye* 18 0
Nige_Bix
30 May 2005, 17:34
5. Simon Goodwin - put his hand up all day and set a terrific example - tried so hard a couple of times he fumbled the ball though!
4. Rob Shirley - solid in the clinches, excellent goal when we needed it
3. Mark Riccuito - excellent early and kept at it all day - was hoping he could repar that T/D goal on a couple of occasions - but seemed unable to yesterday!
2. Nathan Bock - actually looked like he belonged out there - a good sign - and 2 goals to boot!
1. Nathan Bassett - did some nice work - tried really hard to provide drive and back up from defence all day
apols to Torney and Mattner
TM
3. Michael Doughty - put in harder than I have seen including a couple of really strong efforts when we needed them
2. Ben Hudson - great to have a player like this in the side
1. Scott Welsh - great last 1/4 influence on the game - and could have got a few frees during the game.
R
0 the field!
Jars458
30 May 2005, 18:19
POTY
5 - Goodwin (I want a thorough explanation from anyone who didnt think he was BOG)
As a team leader he has to live up to higher standards for 5 votes than do Bock or Shirley who I had ahead of him.
He also tired in the last quarter and let his opponent get the footy at vital moments.
johnnypanther
31 May 2005, 16:30
Poty:
5 Goodwin
4 Bock
3 Ricciuto
2 Mattner
1 Doughty
Btm:
3 Hudson
2 Bassett
1 Torney
Rookie:
Nil
As a team leader he has to live up to higher standards for 5 votes than do Bock or Shirley who I had ahead of him.
He also tired in the last quarter and let his opponent get the footy at vital moments.
That's ok dude, It was just a poor attempt at humour. Everyone's entitled to their opinion and don't need to explain themselves.
Final tallied votes for R10:
BOG:
Goodwin 113 (+5)
Shirley 58 (+4)
Bock 56 (+3)
Ricciuto 52 (+2)
Torney 29 (+1)
Mattner 13
Doughty 12
Hudson 10
Bassett 8
Welsh 7
Hart 2
Total 360
BTM:
Hudson 53 (+3)
Bassett 35 (+2)
Shirley 12 (+1)
Torney 10
Doughty 9
Hart 9
Bock 6
Welsh 2
Mattner 2
Ricciuto 2
Goodwin 2
Burton 1
Thompson 1
Total 144
ROTY
Abstain 26 (+1)
26 voted.