View Full Version : Most Overrated Players From APS
We've all praised our first XVIII's with their draft hopes and best players, dream teams etc.
But who do we think get ridiculous credit and plaudits and end up being consitently ordinary?
tarrant. i cant believe some people still think he's any good, even after 5 rounds.
demondavey
7 Jun 2005, 20:26
Darvell from Xav,soft as
ghetto blasters
7 Jun 2005, 20:27
i think ellis, eddy, hawkins overrated. moussi is easily the best player running around in the aps at the moment
i think ellis, eddy, hawkins overrated. moussi is easily the best player running around in the aps at the moment
one word.
FOOL!
dirtycat23
7 Jun 2005, 20:51
tarrant, darvell
dirty_cat44
7 Jun 2005, 21:12
Tarrant and darvell are rubbish
Muir from brighton is a joke, how did he make the Vic squad, looks like a rat aswell
Syd Kennets
7 Jun 2005, 21:46
I rekon everyone hates Moussi.
alex1fun
7 Jun 2005, 22:08
Cody
i think ellis, eddy, hawkins overrated. moussi is easily the best player running around in the aps at the moment
That could be one of the funniest things I have ever heard! Moussi is so bad it's not funny wouldn't get looked at in the 10A team at SC, MGS, HC.
Rossi Boys
7 Jun 2005, 22:48
SA school comp has the edge on the aps league anyway. There is class everywhere in SA. By the way seen Mousii play= flashy, arrogant and pretty av. Who do you reckon would win the combined schools association SA v VIC???
i think ellis, eddy, hawkins overrated. moussi is easily the best player running around in the aps at the moment
OMFG!! i hope you dont mean xavier ellis, ais academy, top 10 this year haha. julien moussi is clearly not the most dominant player in the aps. looks at people such as nick smith and andrew ainger, ainger will get drafted this year. moussi got cut from the oakleigh list this year. get your facts straight before you start calling people overrated
johnodicko
8 Jun 2005, 11:29
I cant believe moussi gets the attention he does, he is so overated its not funny. There are at least 4 players in front of him at Skevvies, all of which dont get the credit they deserve.
Cain has hardly played, but his potential is enormous, so gets his reputation solely on his attachment to Chargers.
Keely is an outstanding footballer and cricketer. I dont see him mentioned. Dixon is very solid and deserves more credit. Durham makes huge impacts on each game. keogh works very hard without being a superstar.
Re: Most Overrated Players From APS
How about all private school footballers.
Re: Most Overrated Players From APS
How about all private school footballers.
You Have No Idea What You Are Talking About Mate!
St. Kevins will slowly move back down the ladder from every game from now on they have had the bye and have played no quality teams other than Geelong College
Most over rated footballer in the A.P.S is Michael Rockefeller number 13 for GC can't believe people even rate him; he shouldn't have even played falcons he is now injured thank god! Now college might have a chance of winning!
Mate you don't have a clue what your talking about, i bet your a hockey player, rocka has been a freak for college this year. Overated footballlers from college may include Banjanin who has not played a full game all year. Huw Flanagan and Reece Cordy are also overrated.
Koutafindamedes
9 Jun 2005, 14:31
i think ellis, eddy, hawkins overrated. moussi is easily the best player running around in the aps at the moment
ARe you serious that guy moussi is no good
i think ellis, eddy, hawkins overrated. moussi is easily the best player running around in the aps at the moment
Either your are the mousey or where lucky enough to be bunked (bonked) with him on a trip to SA. The guy is a dead set idiot, and that is his good point, if he is the best aps has running around maybe you should get the RVIB to stop doing your match reports.
I see better in the under age comp never mind 1st XVIII which does have a number of very talented players
superstar_09
9 Jun 2005, 15:47
In all honesty i don't think moose would get a game for haileybury
i think ... hawkins overrated.
It's hard to dominate a game when you have two men playing on you. In the Melbourne Grammar vs. Xavier Game, Hawkins had two men playing on him for the majority of the game.
Mate you don't have a clue what your talking about, i bet your a hockey player, rocka has been a freak for college this year. Overated footballlers from college may include Banjanin who has not played a full game all year. Huw Flanagan and Reece Cordy are also overrated.
Mate, i don't know what your talking about huw flanagan is a freak i have watched him play 43 times this year he's very rarely drops a contested mark and reece cordy moves every well for a big man also!
MR O'Keefe
9 Jun 2005, 18:17
Muir is the most overated player in the aps and i have no idea how he got in the metro squad, an absolute joke!
meat cleaver
9 Jun 2005, 19:22
flanagan- talented? please. i was watching him play against GGS in a praccy match on the hols and he may have taken some pretty decent overheads ill give him that but give him a chance to run and he'll be caught in a instant. tried to have a run, had no peripheral and got pinged by a bloke who now plays 3rds- is that talent?
kangacasino
10 Jun 2005, 10:54
True ELLIS is overated and looks like a drowned rat but Sandy Robinson from Purnim is just about the most athletic, skillful and imposing bloke going around.
P.S. Timmy Davis (doolan, cration, flexion) is making is way to the top
Cody
You tool
Cody won the Best and fairest in year 11, and most people didn't have in their aps dream team.
Cody
You tool
Cody won the Xavier Best and fairest in year 11, and most people didn't have in their aps dream team.
CAPPERisGOD
23 Jun 2005, 17:42
In all honesty i don't think moose would get a game for haileybury
Yeh i agree, his a big dud
egan's ego
24 Jun 2005, 03:37
huw flanagan is a grade A dudski.
also ive heard he is lacking in the buldge too.
headovathepill
24 Jun 2005, 17:34
Did Flanagen get a screening day last year? I don't think he has played a game yet this year for the falcons.