which team would win?

[Broadbridge_20]

team a

c.johnson Scarlett t.edwards
rivers maguire m.lappin
n.lappin ling k.johnson
pavlich Brown b.harvey
b.johnson lloyd akermanis
white hird ricciuto
darcy leppitsch farmer whelan


team b

B: L.Gilbee - M.Michael - J.Clement
HB: L.Hodge - L.McPharlin - C.Cornes
C: C.Bruce - C.Judd - T.Johnstone
HF: N.Brown - N.Riewoldt - A.Yze
F: M.Williams - W.Tredrea - F.Gehrig
R: P.Everitt - B.Cousins - N.Dal Santo
I/C: D.Cox - A.Embley - S.Black - G.Archer


think and choose carefully.

[dees_best]

Team B comfortably.

Although they lack hardness in the midfield and rucks they ooze class and would be too much for the plodders of Team A.

Team A's backline couldn't cope with the scoring power of Team B either.

No midfield depth in Team A and this is shown by a bench of two KPPs, a crumber and a small defender.

[crazy_big_al]

team b

[saintmatt23]

team b would win hands down

[tomatoes]

Is stenglein or chris johnson going to play on gehrig?

[The Majestic]

Team B.

[Ricketts]

B looks more classy.

[saintmatt23]

Is stenglein or chris johnson going to play on gehrig?
the g train is in form this year

[weagles_fan]

B will rape A

[X_box_X]

Team A would struggle to beat Team C, let alone Team B.

[Leg_Spinning_Sensation]

Team B by 60 points, the only thing getting a closer is J Brown.

[Pie 4 Life]

Team B by so much it ain't funny. :cool:

[Leg_Spinning_Sensation]

team a
Mismatches-
c.johnson Scarlett t.edwards
rivers maguire m.lappin
n.lappin ling k.johnson
pavlich Brown b.harvey
b.johnson lloyd akermanis
white hird ricciuto
darcy leppitsch farmer whelan


team b

B: L.Gilbee - M.Michael - J.Clement
HB: L.Hodge - L.McPharlin - C.Cornes
C: C.Bruce - C.Judd - T.Johnstone
HF: N.Brown - N.Riewoldt - A.Yze
F: M.Williams - W.Tredrea - F.Gehrig
R: P.Everitt - B.Cousins - N.Dal Santo
I/C: D.Cox - A.Embley - S.Black - G.Archer


think and choose carefully.
Team A's match ups
1. Chris Johnsona dn Tyson Edwards vs FRaser Gehrig?
2. Rivers on Nathan Brown (too quick)
3. Hird should be half forward swapping with brent harvey

Team B's matchups
No obvious flaws.
Bench a vs Bench b
Team A with the bench of Darcy, Leppa, Farmer and Whelan vs
Team b with the bench of Cox, Archer, Black and Embley.
Team B while Darcy and Cox are very even, Farmer on any one of the team B's men would get beaten unless on his great day.

Verdict- Team B by 66 points in the dry and 50 points in the wet

[Pie 4 Life]

Team A's match ups
1. Chris Johnsona dn Tyson Edwards vs FRaser Gehrig?
2. Rivers on Nathan Brown (too quick)
3. Hird should be half forward swapping with brent harvey

Team B's matchups
No obvious flaws.
Bench a vs Bench b
Team A with the bench of Darcy, Leppa, Farmer and Whelan vs
Team b with the bench of Cox, Archer, Black and Embley.
Team B while Darcy and Cox are very even, Farmer on any one of the team B's men would get beaten unless on his great day.

Verdict- Team B by 66 points in the dry and 50 points in the wet
Nah, swap Hird with Brad Johnson. :)

[The Magenius]

team c

[Broadbridge_20]

i reckon team a

too strong in all areas. too much experience, too strong, too hard, too good in the air, too many goalkicking options and more balanced.

team b will be frightened

their defence is not defensive enough and their forwards if they decide to play them all at once will collide.

the beauty of team a is its versatility. lloyd, brown, pavlich, hird, ricciuto, harvey, b.johnson, m.lappin, edwards, maguire, leppitsch, darcy farmer can all play forward, take a mark and kick goals

18/22 players from team a can play through the midfield compared to 14 from team b despite lack of midfield options on the i/c


matchups in team a's defence-

gehrig vs scarlett
riewoldt vs rivers
tredrea vs leppitsch/maguire
williams vs edwards
brown vs c.johnson/whelan

pavlich can drift back if needed

who is going to pick up j.brown, lloyd, pavlich, hird, ricciuto, farmer, akermanis, b.johnson, b.harvey, m.lappin, leppitsch, darcy in team a's forward line
mcpharlin, michael and clement will have their hands full.

team b can use the ball through the middle but will be unable to get their hands on it with the likes of ricciuto, hird, b.johnson, ling, n.lappin, akermanis, pavlich, j.brown, b.harvey, k.johnson, edwards lingering.

verdict - team a by 48pts

[BW]

^^^

That guys a knobhead!!!

Bigfooty has spoken.

[Smokin_Joe]

^^^

That guys a knobhead!!!

Bigfooty has spoken.

I think he has good points and your the knob jockey !