View Full Version : VOTES: Round 14 v Fremantle
I probably had these decided by about halfway thru the third quarter as hardly anyone wearing Crows colours performed impressively from that point on.
Best on Ground
5. McLeod - just a joy to watch in this sort of form, provided plenty of run and never wasted a kick
4. Edwards - ball magnet, probably his best game for about two months
3. Perrie - took his marks and kicked accurately, keeps the baggers like me quiet for another week
2. Ricciuto - always the cool head in the midfield
1. Goodwin - continued his fine season, his delivery into the forward fifty was superb
Best Team Man
3. Mattner - his spoiling was a feature
2. Thompson - not his most polished performance but the hard work was evident
1. Shirley - another hard worker
Rookie
1. Van Berlo - by far the most impressive performance of his young career, some of kicks were exceptional
POTY
5. Edwards
4. McLeod
3. Burton
2. Ricciuto
1. Goodwin
BTM
3. Mattner
2. Perrie
1. Rielly
ROTY
3. Van Berlo
just maybe
3 Jul 2005, 18:02
POTY
5. Edwards - saved our arse so many times and pushed forward
4. McLeod - gave Farmer an absolute shameful bath and provided plenty of drive, that goal was awesome
3. Perrie - the glove had given Perrie the confidence he needs, marking everything, providing a dominant target, he's revelling in having McGregor up there. Loved to see him going down to take Pavlich when Bock drifted off him, great team play. And having McPharlin moved down back onto him was a great sign of respect.
2. Goodwin - continued his great form
1. Burton - very impressed with him today, was very good
BTM
3. Thompson - the enforcer, was always in it or going to the defense of his teammates
2. Mattner - some great desperate work
1. Shirley - continues to be a great negater while adding some attacking flair to his game.
Rookie
Van Berlo - Rutten was his usual solid self, but Van Berlo was fantastic - with some gametime, I was incredibly impressed with his hardness and some fantastic direct, well-balanced passing. Definitely got some nice footskills.
And wow, we need Pavlich. I thought was inevitable after Dyertribe rubbished Pavlich for having only kicked as many goals as Perrie, he'd absolutely maul us. 8.1 says it all, and shows Bock he has a lot to work on. Wow what an awesome team we'd be with him down there...and shows Connolly the advantages of playing the big lump closer to goal - I think his goal output is of greater value than losing the benefits of his aerobic capacity further up the field.
POTY
5. Edwards
4. Goodwin
3. Perrie
2. Reilly
1. Mcleod
BTM
3. Shirley
2. Mattner
1. Hudson
ROTY
1. Van Berlo
just maybe
3 Jul 2005, 18:12
POTY
2. Reilly
Interesting. :confused:
Lucky, very bloody lucky. :(
POTY
5. Goodwin
4. Edwards
3. Mcleod
2. Bassett
1. Mattner
BTM
3. Shirley
2. Hart
1. Perrie
Rookie
1. Van Berlo, if Torney comes back next week this kid does not deserve to be dropped
Kane McGoodwin
3 Jul 2005, 18:39
3. Mattner - his spoiling was a feature
Also, awesome tackle on the wing in a 2:1 situation that should have resulted in a Perrie goal (but ended up a point).
McLeodMagic
3 Jul 2005, 18:53
POTY
5. Edwards
4. McLeod
3. Goodwin
2. Perrie
1. Hart
BTM
3. Shirley
2. Mattner
1. Bassett
ROTY
1. Van Berlo
Stiffy_18
3 Jul 2005, 20:26
POTY
5 - Tyson Edwards
4 - Simon Goodwin
3 - Andrew MCleod
2 - Ian Perrie
1 - Mark Ricciuto
BTM
3 - Scott Thompson
2 - Nathan Bassett
1 - Ben Hart
Rookie
Van Berlo
Hmmm a lot of different people in and out all game.
5.Edwards.... just got it only blemish OOF
4.McLeod ... very good Jeff didnt know what to do.
3.Perrie .. should have gone to the glove 5 years ago. ( I wonder if it is part of a positive reinforcement tactic by CW)
2.Mattner .. does a lot quietly
1.Ricuitto... good captains game
BTM
3.Thompson... the more I see the more I like
2.Shirley..bobbed up enough to hurt Fremantle
1.Bock.. His first half was good enough to keep Pav quiet and to help set up a strong lead. He did fade but he wasnt an orphan
Rookie
Huh? Theres someone elses name here instead of Rutten?
1.Van Berlo
POTY
5. Edwards. Had to be him. Worked his arse off around the packs and the ground, and was the best of our on-ballers.
4. McLeod. Also thought he had to be next. plenty of the old Macca magic on display today - showed Farmer up for the hack that he really is.
3. Perrie. Good on ya Sarge. Gave us something to aim at up forward.
2. Bassett. Another faultless display in the BP. Would be unfair if he's not seriously in AA considerations.
1. Goodwin. Not quite as dangerous to day but still had a good impact on our on-ball drive.
Best Team Man
3. Mattner. Developing nicely into a hard-working wingman with a dash of class.
2. Ricciuto. Steadied the ship when it needed to be - a great skipper.
1. Shirley. Honest as the day is long and adds grunt to the mid-field.
Rookie
Van Berlo. Great effort from the youngster today. He has the goods.
AdelUniCrowFan
3 Jul 2005, 22:44
POTY
5. Goodwin
4. Edwards
3. Perrie
2. Rutten
1. McLeod
BTM
3. Thompson - flew the flag
2. Goodwin
1. Mattner
ROTY
Van Berlo
dyertribe
3 Jul 2005, 23:46
I thought was inevitable after Dyertribe rubbished Pavlich for having only kicked as many goals as Perrie
"Rubbished"?
Dramatisation at its finest.
Regardless, I actually had a feeling Pav would have a day out (posted elsewhere) so it all evens out in the end. ;)
dyertribe
3 Jul 2005, 23:56
POTY
5: EDWARDS, Tyson
4: McLEOD, Andrew
3: PERRIE, Ian
2: BURTON, Brett
1: GOODWIN, Simon
BTM
3: MATTNER, Martin
2: SHIRLEY, Robert
1: BASSETT, Nathan
Rookie
1: VAN BERLO, Nathan
Nige_Bix
4 Jul 2005, 00:33
POTY
5. Tyson Edwards - best game he 's played for a while - great to see
4. Andrew McLeod - ditto I guess
3. Ian Perrie - those hands are looking glueier each week - if there is such a word -maybe its what's on that glove
2. Simon Goodwin - just hope dont start taking this guy for granted!
1. Ben Hart - top effort - Just ahead of Basset, Roo and Burton
BTM
3. Rob Shirley
2. Marty Mattner
1. Nathan Bassett
ROTY
1. Van Berlo - just ahead of the Truck who did well
"Rubbished"?
Dramatisation at its finest.
Regardless, I actually had a feeling Pav would have a day out (posted elsewhere) so it all evens out in the end. ;)
Did you shag his gf or something DT ? Seems to not like you too much.
POTY
5. Edwards 29 touches, thought he was our best
4. Mcleod 19 touches 6 marks 1 goal. Farmer 10 touches, 3 marks 0 goals. Enough said.
3. Goodwin 23 touches. Has played better games, but still thought he was ok.
2. Sarge 16 touches, 9 marks. presented well for us. Preferred he kicked straighter though
1. Bassett. Excellent game in defence.
BTM
3 Mattner. 16 touches, 5 quality tackles and a sh|t load of 1 per centers.
2 Bassett. 14 touches and 7 marks. Some of those running with the flight of the ball marks were outstanding.
1 Mcleod. Sacrificed his game for the sake of the team. Destroyed Farmer.
Rookie.
VB.- 16 touches, a few clangers, but did enough to impress and get himself a vote.
POTY
5 - Tyson Edwards
4 - Simon Goodwin
3 - Andrew McLeod
2 - Martin Mattner
1 - Ian Perrie
BTM
3 - Martin Mattner
2 - Scott Thompson
1 - Robert Shirley
ROTY
1- Nathan Van Berlo.
The Toolman
4 Jul 2005, 09:51
POTY
5) Tyson Edwards - best game for the year
4) Andy McLeod - looks relaxed and in control
3) Ian Perrie - The Dispenser is in the middle of a purple patch.
2) Robert Shirley - did everything that was asked of him and chimed in for goals as well
1) Simon Goodwin - The Darkhorse for the Charlie!
BTM
3) Nathan Basset - puts his body on the line for the team each week.
2) Martin Mattner - his tackling alone is inspirational
1) Ken McGregor - played well up fowd and then had to cover for the Bock.
Rookie
Count Van Berlo - best game for the club.
Best player votes vs. the Fremantle Dockers
5) Andrew McLeod
4) Ian Perrie
3) Tyson Edwards
2) Brett Burton
1) Ben Hart
Best team man votes
3) Martin Mattner
2) Nathan Bassett
1) Ben Rutten
Rookie
Nathan Van Berlo
drakeyv2
4 Jul 2005, 10:30
POTY
5. Edwards
4. McLeod
3. Perrie
2. Goodwin
1. Bassett
BTM
3. McGregor
2. Thompson
1. Ricciutto
Rookie
VB
I tended to favour those who actually bothered to play after 3/4 time.
POTY
5 - Tyson Edwards - burnt a bit of ball - but also got us out of trouble on numerous occasions
4 - Simon Goodwin - another great game
3 - Robert Shirley - very industrious - 2 great goals.
2 - Ian Perrie - 9 marks and 5 pings at goal....a good effort
1 - Mark Ricciuto - good late.....would like to see him kick more rather than handball - and spend more time on the ground.
BTM
3 - Robert Shirley
2 - Scott Thompson - the force is strong in that one.
1 - Nathan Bassett - very bloody important in the last qtr
apols to Bennard Hart
Rookie
1 - Nathan Van Berlo.....(aka The Count)....... :)
just maybe
4 Jul 2005, 11:34
"Rubbished"?
Dramatisation at its finest.
I'd say underrating Pavlich's season because he's 'only kicked as many goals as Perrie' is rubbishing. :p
snakebite01
4 Jul 2005, 13:11
POTY
5 - Andrew McLeod - So important for him to shut down Farmer today as he has been the catalyst for their away wins over Melbourne and Geelong. Loved his 5-minute cameo in the midfield, going to be unleashed in the finals.
4 - Tyson Edwards - Haven't put him in the votes for a while, good to see him back up the top.
3 - Rocket Rob Shirley - Another great tough game.
2 - Ian Perrie - Presented well, kicked OK for goal, looking good with the glove.
1 - Ben Hart - Solid at the back, rarely let us down except for the missed spoil on Polak.
BTM
3 - Rob Shirley
2 - Martin Mattner
1 - Nathan Bassett
ROTY
1 - Nathan Van Berlo
Bockchoy67
4 Jul 2005, 17:27
Player of the Year
5. Tyson Edwards
4. Andrew McLeod
3. Simon Goodwin
2. Ian Perrie
1. Robert Shirley
Best Team Man
3. Scott Thompson
2. Nathan Bassett
1. Mark Riccuito
Rookie of the Year
The Count - 16 disposals and for most of them his great skills were truly evident. Didn't look out of place despite weighing about 12kg.
5. Tyson Edwards - everywhere in the first half
4. Nathan Bassett - some couragous marks and clever spoils
3. Andrew McLeod - made the gimp Farmer look third rate, and what a goal
2. Ian Perrie - excellent forward option
1. Robert Shirley - improving all the time, two very nice goals
Unlucky - Goodwin Hart and Burton
Best Team Man
3. Nathan Bassett
2. Ben Rutten - spanked McPharlin
1. Thompson - agro city
Rookie of the Year
Van Berlo - good game apart from a couple of poor disposals under pressure on his wrong foot and the out of bounds.
POTY
5. Edwards
4. Goodwin
3. Mcleod
2. Hart
1. Bassett
BTM
3. Bassett
2. Mattner
1. Thompson
ROTY
1. Van Berlo
Running Total after Lozza71
POTY
5 - Edwards 104
4 Mcleod 76
3 Goodwin 50
2 Perrie 49
1 Bassett 11
Shirley 10
Burton 8
Roo 7
Hart 6
Mattner 5
Reilly 2
Rutten 2
BTM
3 Mattner 36
2 Shirley 26
1 Thompson 25
Bassett 22
Roo 4
McGregor 4
Rutten 3
Hart 3
Perrie 2
Goodwin 2
Mcleod 1
Reilly 1
Hudson 1
Bock 1
Rookie
1 VB 22
Kane McGoodwin
5 Jul 2005, 20:33
BOG
5. Edwards - best of our midfielders & kicked a couple of handy majors.
4. McLeod - delight to see him back to his best, silencing Farmer & kicking the goal of the day.
3. Goodwin - good 4 quarter effort.
2. Bassett - solid all day & couragous as always (what a mark in the last quarter).
1. Perrie - good target up forward & would have been higher had he not sprayed a few shots at goal.
BTM
3. Mattner - inspirational tackle on the wing.
2. Shirley - tough in the clinches.
1. Bassett as above.
Rookie
1. Van Berlo - mostly showed poise when disposing of the ball. Looks to have a bright future.
Markthirtytwo
7 Jul 2005, 00:02
POTY
5. Edwards
4. Goodwin
3. Mcleod
2. Mattner
1. Bassett
BTM
3. Bassett
2. Hart
1. Thompson
ROTY
1. Van Berlo
GoSarge's tally plus the last two sets of votes...
POTY
5 - Edwards 114
4 Mcleod 83
3 Goodwin 57
2 Perrie 50
1 Bassett 14
Shirley 10
Burton 8
Mattner 7
Roo 7
Hart 6
Reilly 2
Rutten 2
Total 360
BTM
3 Mattner 39
2 Shirley 28
.5 Thompson 26
.5 - Bassett 26
Hart 5
Roo 4
McGregor 4
Rutten 3
Perrie 3
Goodwin 2
Mcleod 1
Reilly 1
Hudson 1
Bock 1
Total 144
Rookie
1 VB 24
Will check the BTM tally later as it may affect the final vote.