View Full Version : Melbourne Trades/Delistings
superstar_09
7 Sep 2005, 17:56
Following the weekends name the dees need to rebuild.
The following is a list of players i would delist or trade
Steven Armstrong - Hasn't come on at all. Could have value in trading
Clint Bizzel - Passed by Rivers, Fergurson, Carrol. Would be interest in him
Simon Godfrey - His disposal is a joke. Delisting
Chris Heffernen - Cya Later. Delisting
Cameron Hunter - 3 seasons for 2 games. Had long enough. Delisting
Nick Smith - See above
Daniel Ward - Looks lost without his fellow red heads.
melbournemartin
7 Sep 2005, 18:25
smith needs 1 more cos he has been struck down injury
Ragingbull
7 Sep 2005, 20:23
Following the weekends name the dees need to rebuild.
The following is a list of players i would delist or trade
Steven Armstrong - Hasn't come on at all. Could have value in trading
Clint Bizzel - Passed by Rivers, Fergurson, Carrol. Would be interest in him
Simon Godfrey - His disposal is a joke. Delisting
Chris Heffernen - Cya Later. Delisting
Cameron Hunter - 3 seasons for 2 games. Had long enough. Delisting
Nick Smith - See above
Daniel Ward - Looks lost without his fellow red heads.
What about Luke Williams ? Has too be delisted as well surely.
My delistings would be Hunter, Williams, Heffernan, Ward.
Keep Smith and Godfrey. Look at trading Bizzell, Armstrong thats if anyone wants them
JeNnO_powerfreak_21
7 Sep 2005, 20:42
I would delist the whole team pretty much and keep the tough one’s (that shortens it down to like 3, 4) eg. Moloney, Read and Rivers if I missed anyone tough let me no! (highly doubt it)
CowboyFromHell
7 Sep 2005, 20:43
Why is it that these crap Melbourne posters feel the need to put up threads in here on who they believe should go, and who should be traded? Just STFU. It's obvious who should go, and who shouldn't. Nobody cares that you know.
CowboyFromHell
7 Sep 2005, 20:44
I would delist the whole team pretty much and keep the tough one’s (that shortens it down to like 3, 4) eg. Moloney, Read and Rivers if I missed anyone tough let me no! (highly doubt it)
OKAYZ WE WILLZ LET YOUZ LIKE NO WEN WE CAN GURL OMGWTFBBQ
Ragingbull
7 Sep 2005, 20:52
Why is it that these crap Melbourne posters feel the need to put up threads in here on who they believe should go, and who should be traded? Just STFU. It's obvious who should go, and who shouldn't. Nobody cares that you know.
WTF?? I thought this was a discussion board obviously not??.
CowboyFromHell
7 Sep 2005, 20:55
WTF?? I thought this was a discussion board obviously not??.
But at least post something constructive, it's been spoken about so many times already. Use the search function and post in those threads, rather than waste everyone's time.
Xavier Clarke
7 Sep 2005, 21:35
Get rid of green and nietz should retire. injury ridden and useless.
Turbocat
7 Sep 2005, 21:38
What would you want for the Biz, maybe its time to come back to where it started.
LukeHodge15
7 Sep 2005, 21:42
Why is it that these crap Melbourne posters feel the need to put up threads in here on who they believe should go, and who should be traded? Just STFU. It's obvious who should go, and who shouldn't. Nobody cares that you know.
dont like the topic then dont post , seems pretty easy 2 me !!!!!!!!!! :confused:
CowboyFromHell
7 Sep 2005, 21:43
dont like the topic then dont post , seems pretty easy 2 me !!!!!!!!!! :confused:
Yep, thanks for the advice...
Pie 4 Life
7 Sep 2005, 22:18
Armstrong would be slight interest at Collingwood.
monoccular
7 Sep 2005, 22:55
Armstrong - maybe; hasn't been given any sort of a go by ND. IMO he could well come back to haunt us though. Only 21.
Heffernan - go, find a heart
Hunter - underbuilt for AFL
Williams - enough said
Read - ??
Godfrey - no skills
Rigoni _ ? already said he is going.
That's 7 for a start.
Smith I beleive has a further 12 months contract - he will need to star pretty soon in 2006 to get further though.
pinkus maximus
8 Sep 2005, 00:24
If we get Armstrong and delist Andrew Browne I will cut Connollys nuts off
If we get Armstrong and delist Andrew Browne I will cut Connollys nuts off
What about keeping both? Jeez i doubt its one or the other.
pinkus maximus
8 Sep 2005, 00:38
Of course but I was just being hypothetical.Both similar players but I reckon Browne>Armstrong
vinnie_vegas69
8 Sep 2005, 01:12
What would you want for Armstrong?
Swifty_446
8 Sep 2005, 08:49
There was a lot of talk on SEN last night about Melbourne trading Yze.
Johnson#26
8 Sep 2005, 10:49
Bizzell and Ward would get some interest.
Green for Tarrant OR Green and pick for Fev??
Think either of those would be accepted??
Vic Eagles Member
8 Sep 2005, 16:14
Green for Tarrant OR Green and pick for Fev??
Think either of those would be accepted??
Doubt the Pies would do a direct swap like that. I'd be wanting more.
Green for Tarrant OR Green and pick for Fev??
Think either of those would be accepted??
Green would be a lot of help in our team. He would be introduced to Mr Stenglein and Mr K Cornes and struggle to have any influence. He is a very skilled hf flanker who kicks goals. A luxury at good teams but not at poor ones. Will be 25 early next year and over 120 games up says he is unlikely to be able to change his game much.
The sort of player Melb might look to trade for what they need. An in and under midfielder and a tall backman. Bartel and Polak spring to mind who might be available.
harper23
9 Sep 2005, 16:56
Would demons trade Caroll?
Say Caroll to Western Bulldogs for Sam Power or Brad Murphy + 3rd round pick?
Bizzell and Ward would get some interest.
Only for clubs who want old defenders who don't do their jobs. There is a reason Bizzell was playing for Sandy late in the season - that being cause he's :thumbsd:
Would demons trade Caroll?
Say Caroll to Western Bulldogs for Sam Power or Brad Murphy + 3rd round pick?
Wouldn't trade a promising key defender for 2 blokes who'd struggle to get a game. Key defenders arent our strong point as it is.
Would you Melbourne supporters want Whitnall at your club? If so, what deal do you think could happen?
mattyc2422
10 Sep 2005, 16:51
OKAYZ WE WILLZ LET YOUZ LIKE NO WEN WE CAN GURL OMGWTFBBQ
:D
BBQ ;) .
deelited
10 Sep 2005, 18:24
Green would be a lot of help in our team. He would be introduced to Mr Stenglein and Mr K Cornes and struggle to have any influence. He is a very skilled hf flanker who kicks goals. A luxury at good teams but not at poor ones. Will be 25 early next year and over 120 games up says he is unlikely to be able to change his game much.
The sort of player Melb might look to trade for what they need. An in and under midfielder and a tall backman. Bartel and Polak spring to mind who might be available.
I don't know if Carlton would want Yze, but I believe he will be gone from the club by the end of the year. I don't know about Bartel, but we certainly need another in and under player. I have no mail on this, but I wonder if Carlton would do a direct swap of Whitnall for Ferguson and Armstrong.
StingaArmstrong
10 Sep 2005, 23:48
I don't know if Carlton would want Yze, but I believe he will be gone from the club by the end of the year. I don't know about Bartel, but we certainly need another in and under player. I have no mail on this, but I wonder if Carlton would do a direct swap of Whitnall for Ferguson and Armstrong.
Carlton wouldn't go for that trade and I'd rather keep Ferguson regardless, he won't be traded anyway, with a bit of bulk he is the backman we've been looking for.
superstar_09
11 Sep 2005, 14:07
Would demons trade Caroll?
Say Caroll to Western Bulldogs for Sam Power or Brad Murphy + 3rd round pick?
Power for Caroll. Sounds like a good trade.
Power for Caroll. Sounds like a good trade.
Melbourne would not trade Carroll. He showed plenty at the end of the season and would be in there future plans. At worst he has Bizzells spot on the third tall.
BulldogMike
11 Sep 2005, 20:58
Steven Armstrong - Done very little. He's from WA i think so could be a possible option for Fremantle. Very little trade value and if anything worth a late draft pick.
Clint Bizzell - If Melbourne want to trade him then there would easily be teams willing to take him from the Dees hands and try kick start his career.
Simon Godfrey - Might be kept because he appears to be the Dees only youngish tagger. Other than that is not one of the teams best midfielders and would be worth very little at the trade table. Could be one of those delisting/success stories at another club though he will probably be having to contend with the pressure of waiting to hear his name called out on draft day. With Port looking for midfielders you never know what could happen.
Chris Heffernen - I could see another club trying to get him to produce good football. Will most likely be traded and if nothing can be arranged will more than likely be delisted. Little value though a side will take him i think.
Cameron Hunter - Wasting a perfectly good spot on the list. Passenger to the max. Delist.
Nick Smith - Sitting on the list doing nothing. Worth jack all and deserves a delisting.
Daniel Ward - Spare parts player. With his long kicking might be able to find himself a new home. I think he'll be traded and if nothing comes of it another delisting.
Luke Williams. Surprising he has been retained for so many years. Useless player. Delist. Doubtful the Dees could give him away.
Shannon Motlop. Trade - If nothing can be arranged the Dees would keep him. If they are serious about a flag then passengers like him must be forced of the list to improve overall competitiveness in the side.
Clint Bizzell - If Melbourne want to trade him then there would easily be teams willing to take him from the Dees hands and try kick start his career.
Kick start his career... haha the guys 30 - i think it's a bit late to kick start a player's career!!!
Following the weekends name the dees need to rebuild.
The following is a list of players i would delist or trade
Steven Armstrong - Hasn't come on at all. Could have value in trading
Clint Bizzel - Passed by Rivers, Fergurson, Carrol. Would be interest in him
Simon Godfrey - His disposal is a joke. Delisting
Chris Heffernen - Cya Later. Delisting
Cameron Hunter - 3 seasons for 2 games. Had long enough. Delisting
Nick Smith - See above
Daniel Ward - Looks lost without his fellow red heads.
Worthy of discussion.
Steven Armstrong - For some reason Daniher doesn't play him, I think he could do very well at the right club but sadly it's not Melbourne
Clint Bizzel - Should never have given him a 3 year contract, this could hurt
Simon Godfrey - Godders is ok, problem is you can only afford onr of these types of players at once. Our last final we have Godders, Heffernan and Read
Chris Heffernen - See Godders
Cameron Hunter - Gone
Nick Smith - Was given an extension to his contract early this year (or late last year), he's never been able to train for more than a couple of months without getting injured. Next year last chance.
Daniel Ward - Wanted to go last year but no one was willing to trade.
Who you missed:
Read
Rigoni
Nicholson
McDonald
Holland