View Full Version : Trade Talk (Friday) on SEN
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 06:58
www.sen.com.au If you hear it on sen post it hear, sen will be broadcasting live from optus oval from 12 till 2 today. So if you hear it post it, as you all know it can be hard to get sen, and this way we are all kept up to date. Thanks Steve :)
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 08:18
Talking football on sen at the moment, kevin sheedy on shortly, kangaroos will throw everything at hawks today to secure hay, lappin and houlihan are yet to come to terms with carlton, patrick bowden to richmond, jade rawlings to kangaroos,Bowden and rawlings deals not done yet, these where on sen at 7.30 am
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 08:48
essendon wants campo, sheedy asked why they took pick 51 for pick 55, pick 51 is going to be used for the father son with neagle,cole could play wing or hbf, heffernan might go to essendon in psd,asked about terry daniher as a replacement for robert shaw, but said he didnt think that daniher would be at essendon next year,said he would be at optus oval today to point club officials to the rifgt corridor at 1 min to 2
blumfieldisback
7 Oct 2005, 09:14
in todays paper it say we have to use pick 39 for neagle? Who knows
in todays paper it say we have to use pick 39 for neagle? Who knows
apparently AFL rang in to 3AW last night and confirmed 39 had to be used for F/S
apparently AFL rang in to 3AW last night and confirmed 39 had to be used for F/S
Obviously they forgot to ring and tell Sheeds that.
MrMorris
7 Oct 2005, 09:19
they said on sen that along with a late pic for bowden the doggies will get a cash settlement. Maybe this will be used to pay some of rawlings wages at another club.
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 09:19
in todays paper it say we have to use pick 39 for neagle? Who knows
Ok, well sheedy was just on and he said thats why they done the richards deal that way, pick 51 is in the third round therefor it can be used to take neagle.The rules state that it has to be a 3rd rounder, doesnt say which one of the 3rd picks(if you have more than one) you have to use.
Unwritten_Law
7 Oct 2005, 09:24
Someone just rang in with a good joke.
Hawthorn have traded Jonothan Hay for the Kangaroo's Shannon Watt.
I was in the carpark at Optus Oval this morning and Clarkson hopped out of his car and said Hay, Laidley responded with Watt.
I liked it anyway.
Ok, well sheedy was just on and he said thats why they done the richards deal that way, pick 51 is in the third round therefor it can be used to take neagle.The rules state that it has to be a 3rd rounder, doesnt say which one of the 3rd picks(if you have more than one) you have to use.
think he may have a fight on his hands with this one as the AFL dont agree.
Also didn't they agree to take Neagle prior to trade week and therefore prior to them actually having pick 51 ?
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 09:31
think he may have a fight on his hands with this one as the AFL dont agree.
Also didn't they agree to take Neagle prior to trade week and therefore prior to them actually having pick 51 ?
That sounds logical to me, but we are talking about sheedy.
As for that hay, watts joke , that was very funny.
someone rang it pretty admanent that crawf will be traded for ferguson :o
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 09:44
someone rang it pretty admanent that crawf will be traded for ferguson :o
Yeah just heard that one, very interesting, sounded very confident about it didnt he.
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 10:05
Interested to see what patrick smith has to say about the trades today?
year of the roo
7 Oct 2005, 10:07
Interested to see what patrick smith has to say about the trades today?
No, not really.
Unwritten_Law
7 Oct 2005, 10:08
Sure it's not Robert Walls - "there are going to be some frantic moments between 12 and 1.55"
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 10:12
Sure it's not Robert Walls - "there are going to be some frantic moments between 12 and 1.55"
Its actually greg denham
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 10:17
Pickett and Sewell to toughen up melbourne, green from wc for spandermann, gasper for pick 18, kangaroos may take gasper,rodan wants out over contract dispute.
Fabulous
7 Oct 2005, 10:20
someone rang it pretty admanent that crawf will be traded for ferguson :o
Sewell for Ferguson is on the table not Crawf
Benno From Berwick
7 Oct 2005, 10:22
Ok, well sheedy was just on and he said thats why they done the richards deal that way, pick 51 is in the third round therefor it can be used to take neagle.The rules state that it has to be a 3rd rounder, doesnt say which one of the 3rd picks(if you have more than one) you have to use.
I am sure the rule needs to be changed to ensure it is!
Pickett and Sewell to toughen up melbourne, green from wc for spandermann, gasper for pick 18, kangaroos may take gasper,rodan wants out over contract dispute.
T Gaspar for pick 18 is a great deal if true. As injury prone as Hay and with a much bigger upside. I wouldn't mind if Freo got Gaspar.
Pickett and Sewell to toughen up melbourne, green from wc for spandermann, gasper for pick 18, kangaroos may take gasper,rodan wants out over contract dispute.
Harris and pick 18 for Gaspar and Rodent
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 10:28
Yeah i think that this one has to be clarified, doesnt seem fair that they agreed to neagle with pick 39, and now can use 51, doesnt quiet sound fair.
missionpossible
7 Oct 2005, 10:28
I think you will find essendon have to use there highest third round draft pick.
At this stage 39 not 51 but if they trade away 39 they can use 51. That is my understanding of the rule and no I dont have the rules in front of me to be 100% correct.
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 10:30
T Gaspar for pick 18 is a great deal if true. As injury prone as Hay and with a much bigger upside. I wouldn't mind if Freo got Gaspar.
Didnt think that wc and freo traded as a rule, but gasper would be a great pick up.
year of the roo
7 Oct 2005, 10:36
Harris and pick 18 for Gaspar and Rodent
No.
otis_david
7 Oct 2005, 10:37
I doubt Travis Gaspar will be traded. The club has put alot of time and money into him getting his feet right and next season with a fulll pre season under his belt he will be a good player for us.
Barry Schneider
7 Oct 2005, 10:39
I doubt Travis Gaspar will be traded. The club has put alot of time and money into him getting his feet right and next season with a fulll pre season under his belt he will be a good player for us.
That's what I think but maybe his feet aren't right.If the Eagles wanted to trade him I would be very wary.
andrew_embley
7 Oct 2005, 10:40
couldn't see Gaspar going for 18. In all honesty i cant see clubs rating him that high as he hasnt proved anything at senior level, but has that magic bean word 'potential'. Secondly 18 would be useless to us as the last thing we need is more bloddy draft picks. (although each year at trade time our fetish continues :( ). ) thirdly, it just doesnt seem logical him leaving as i'm sure he doesnt have issues with the club on a personal level, as he was pulled into 2 finals from nowhere by the coaches, and if its a money issue, i cant see him in a logical mind having problems there unless we are only offering 20 bucks a kick and 15% off medication/physio bills.
then again, if we are eyeing off someone big (yet knowing us we'll take the picks) then it may come into pay having 2 1st rounders. and 18 was the pck we gavetme for McConnell.
bradrowe#32
7 Oct 2005, 10:41
Harris and pick 18 for Gaspar and Rodent
Daniel Harris?
roostersgal4eva
7 Oct 2005, 10:42
green from wc for spandermann
where do we sign :p
andrew_embley
7 Oct 2005, 10:44
where do we sign :p
underneath where we have just signed ;)
year of the roo
7 Oct 2005, 10:48
where do we sign :p
Ah, you do realise that Green is utter rubbish?
roostersgal4eva
7 Oct 2005, 10:53
Ah, you do realise that Green is utter rubbish?
he was one of WC better players in the GF IMHO
he will be a better prospect than spandannaman - he had little opportunities with glass & hunter.
you think his rubbish, good for you, your opinion so stick to it id say- but since ive seen every player offered a trade called 'rubbish' or 'hack' in this forum please exept my apologies when i take this comment with a grain of salt
coasting
7 Oct 2005, 10:54
Ah, you do realise that Green is utter rubbish?
What do you think spaanderdud is?
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 10:54
Ah, you do realise that Green is utter rubbish?
Played ok in the grand final, other than that game, ive never really noticed him.
Nightwolf
7 Oct 2005, 10:56
Hands off my man Sewell, Melbourne!
bomberman007
7 Oct 2005, 11:28
Hurry up 2pm. I've had enough of trade week.
bomberman007
7 Oct 2005, 11:29
*whoops wrong thread*
Rooboy 96
7 Oct 2005, 11:34
Daniel Harris?
how do I say this politely....
fucoff!!!!!!!!!
MicknArch
7 Oct 2005, 11:41
Harris and pick 18 for Gaspar and Rodent
What is this obsession Richmond fans have with securing Daniel Harris? For the last two years the ferals on the Punt Road End website have been bleating about this. It's getting rather boring.
Let me make this clear Tigers... Under no circumstances will North Melbourne consider trading Daniel Harris ANYWHERE! The club loves him; The coach loves him; The fans love him; He loves the club.
For chrissake, just get over it!
richcogs
7 Oct 2005, 11:43
Has anyone heard any confirmation about the Bowden deal?????????????
Trade day latest
10:25:01 AM Fri 7 October, 2005
Exclusive to afl.com.au
The final day of the AFL's annual trade week is underway, with officials from several clubs converging on Optus Oval ahead of the 2pm deadline for all trades to be completed.
Officials from Essendon, Richmond, West Coast, Sydney, the Brisbane Lions, Richmond and Collingwood are already on site, although conspicuously absent are the Kangaroos and Hawthorn, whose talks over Hawk full-back Jonathan Hay are considered critical to get several other trades moving.
Traditionally, the remainder of the deals get done after 12 noon, with a real flurry of activity after 1.30pm.
afl.com.au will have FREE live audio from Optus Oval from 1pm. Recently-retired Hawk star Nick Holland will join Damien Mahoney, as the day takes place.
Dons, Tigers, eagles, swans, pies and the lions??? Whose working out a trade with who?
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 11:52
What is this obsession Richmond fans have with securing Daniel Harris? For the last two years the ferals on the Punt Road End website have been bleating about this. It's getting rather boring.
Let me make this clear Tigers... Under no circumstances will North Melbourne consider trading Daniel Harris ANYWHERE! The club loves him; The coach loves him; The fans love him; He loves the club.
For chrissake, just get over it!
Sounds like the tigers supporters who were on yesturday saying how good will our forward line be with fevola, you have to remember these supporters having tasted success in 25 years, they have to sprook about something.
Huddo and some other guy from SEN will be live from Optus Oval from 12-2... giving updates as they come in
tigerdan
7 Oct 2005, 11:59
Dons, Tigers, eagles, swans, pies and the lions??? Whose working out a trade with who?
Warning! There are two lots of Richmond officials there! Look out for imposters!
munsonned
7 Oct 2005, 12:07
Huddo, just confirmed P Bowden (dogs) to tigers for pick 56
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 12:07
Is there any news of trades coming through, as normal i cant get on sen :mad:
dee_molisher
7 Oct 2005, 12:08
Hands off my man Sewell, Melbourne!
You can keep the Sewell mug. Looks a real goat.
bowden to richmond for pick 56
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 12:08
Huddo, just confirmed P Bowden (dogs) to tigers for pick 56
Thats a good pick up.
turtle27
7 Oct 2005, 12:10
What is this obsession Richmond fans have with securing Daniel Harris? For the last two years the ferals on the Punt Road End website have been bleating about this. It's getting rather boring.
Let me make this clear Tigers... Under no circumstances will North Melbourne consider trading Daniel Harris ANYWHERE! The club loves him; The coach loves him; The fans love him; He loves the club.
For chrissake, just get over it!Until this post, I've never heard any tigs fans suggesting they wanted Harris, admittedly, I don't post on PRE
bowden to richmond for pick 56
I don't know if i should laugh or cry.
richcogs
7 Oct 2005, 12:11
Least Bowden wasn't too bad an investment. You paid the price of him with pick 58 and sold him for pick 56.
McLeodMagic
7 Oct 2005, 12:11
Saddington to Blues for pick 52. (Not absolutely confirmed yet)
Source: SEN
turtle27
7 Oct 2005, 12:12
Huddo waiting on confirmation of Saddington to the Blues for pick 52
turtle27
7 Oct 2005, 12:14
Sounds like the tigers supporters who were on yesturday saying how good will our forward line be with fevola, you have to remember these supporters having tasted success in 25 years, they have to sprook about something.And if we had got him, yes it would've been. What's wrong with that?
roostersgal4eva
7 Oct 2005, 12:14
Saddington to Blues for pick 52. (Not absolutely confirmed yet)
Source: SEN
darn :(
smthomson
7 Oct 2005, 12:15
Jason Saddington a Blue for pick no. 52. Waiting for official confirmation.
Oh the BIG NAMES ARE JUST ROLLING OFF THE LIST!!!
MicknArch
7 Oct 2005, 12:19
Until this post, I've never heard any tigs fans suggesting they wanted Harris, admittedly, I don't post on PRE
Go and check it out sometime and look through the archives. It's been relentless for a couple of years now.
irish_setanta
7 Oct 2005, 12:21
Jason Saddington a Blue for pick no. 52. Waiting for official confirmation.
Im happy with that.
DirtyDogTIGERS
7 Oct 2005, 12:23
it's not official until Porthos puts it on his thread (apparently he hasn't paid his ISP bill) :confused:
McLeodMagic
7 Oct 2005, 12:24
Saddington deal has been confirmed for pick 52.
turtle27
7 Oct 2005, 12:25
Go and check it out sometime and look through the archives. It's been relentless for a couple of years now.Then I agree, not sure why, could not ever see North trading him
Huddo also just confriming the Saddington to Carlton for pick 52 deal
Unwritten_Law
7 Oct 2005, 12:28
According to Huddo, Kangaroos only just arrived :eek:
Keeping them keen.....but geez they've got to get the trades done!
Any word on the Hay deal?
it's not official until Porthos puts it on his thread (apparently he hasn't paid his ISP bill) :confused:I'm working on being accurate, not fast.
According to Huddo, Kangaroos only just arrived :eek:
They're looking more and more unprofessional every minute.
They're looking more and more unprofessional every minute.
Idiot. They've been working on the trade with the Hawks!
According to Huddo, Kangaroos only just arrived :eek:
Keeping them keen.....but geez they've got to get the trades done!
They’re building the suspense
heard that hay for mcintosh and pick 18 was offered,
mcintosh is unproven isn't he?
heard that hay for mcintosh and pick 18 was offered,
mcintosh is unproven isn't he?
Oh please god no
According to Huddo, Kangaroos only just arrived :eek:
Keeping them keen.....but geez they've got to get the trades done!
It is not fashionable to be the first to a party, it makes you look desperate. :p
Oh please god no
I seriously doubt we would trade either Hale or McIntosh, given we didn't trade for another ruckman and we re-signed him last year.
This is probably one of the wishful thinking rumors.
windsock
7 Oct 2005, 12:45
They're looking more and more unprofessional every minute.
Yeah, RamMen, they all probably knocked off at 5 yesterday, had a bender last night and just got out of bed at 10.30 to see if they could roll in at around 11.30 to see what happens
KangaFett
7 Oct 2005, 12:45
It is not fashionable to be the first to a party, it makes you look desperate. :p
comment of the week :)
treat em mean, keep em keen!
Yeah, RamMen
Ouch.
That sucked on so many levels.
any new news on the hay-motlop deal...?
Yeah, RamMen, they all probably knocked off at 5 yesterday, had a bender last night and just got out of bed at 10.30 to see if they could roll in at around 11.30 to see what happens
Would laugh my ass off if Motlop accepted a trade to Brisbane or we PSDed Motlop, I'd be happy to pass on Hay and a pick just to give the bird to Port supporters.
But, I expect a trade will be done. :p
Would laugh my ass off if Motlop accepted a trade to Brisbane or we PSDed Motlop, I'd be happy to pass on Hay and a pick just to give the bird to Port supporters.
Give it all ya like, bud. We'll be happy to keep our first rounder and still have a chance to pick up Motlop in the PSD. And if we don't... meh. I'm afraid there's no getting around the fact that you guys are far more deperate for Hay than we are for Motlop.
2 hours to go...
tick... tick.... tick...
Time is running out, Port. Lined up a dud with pick 14 in the draft yet? I can guarantee he won't be half as good as Motlop. ;)
2 hours to go...
no 2 hours and 7 minutes alot can happen in the last 7 mins
Give it all ya like, bud. We'll be happy to keep our first rounder and still have a chance to pick up Motlop in the PSD. And if we don't... meh. I'm afraid there's no getting around the fact that you guys are far more deperate for Hay than we are for Motlop.
That is great, you might recruit another superstar like Salopek.
That is great, you might recruit another superstar like Salopek.
Yup.
1jasonoz
7 Oct 2005, 12:54
Give it all ya like, bud. We'll be happy to keep our first rounder and still have a chance to pick up Motlop in the PSD. And if we don't... meh. I'm afraid there's no getting around the fact that you guys are far more deperate for Hay than we are for Motlop.
No chance at all of Port getting him in the PSD, maybe your should accept that :cool:
magpie_militia
7 Oct 2005, 12:55
tick... tick.... tick...
Time is running out, Port. Lined up a dud with pick 14 in the draft yet? I can guarantee he won't be half as good as Motlop. ;)
Getting a bit nervous Tas? :)
Time is running out, Port.
It is, but not for us. Last I heard our offer was on the table. Your boys hauled their lazy asses out of bed yet?
next_afl_player
7 Oct 2005, 12:55
Is Carlton in any contention to get anything good!
No chance at all of Port getting him in the PSD,
Prove it.
maybe your should accept that :cool:
Maybe my what should accept that?
No chance at all of Port getting him in the PSD, maybe your should accept that :cool:
If he goes into the PSD Brisbane will take him, will never make it to Port.
tick... tick.... tick...
Time is running out, Port. Lined up a dud with pick 14 in the draft yet? I can guarantee he won't be half as good as Motlop. ;)
Yes, I for one will be horribly dissapointed if we miss out on a guy in his mid-20's whose claim to fame is a coupla good wizard cup games. Wink away tiger, but time can run out as quick as it likes...I'll have an 18 year old midfielder in the draft thanks.
If he goes into the PSD Brisbane will take him, will never make it to Port.That is what I am guessing their new discussions with Motlop entail.
1jasonoz
7 Oct 2005, 12:59
Prove it.
Maybe my what should accept that?
So you don't think the Lions a club that has an earlier pick than your lot, was willing to give up pick 9 and a player for, has stated they will pay his salary as requested, will not pick him up?
You aren't the brightest light bulb around here now are you?
1jasonoz
7 Oct 2005, 12:59
If he goes into the PSD Brisbane will take him, will never make it to Port.
Agreed.
Agreed.
Possibly, providing Brisbane can fit him under their shrinking cap - 300k is a fair bit of money - more than you would expect, say Selwood to be on.
Nevertheless, don't think he'd make it to pick 9, one way or another.
So you don't think the Lions a club that has an earlier pick than your lot, was willing to give up pick 9 and a player for, has stated they will pay his salary as requested, will not pick him up?
It's far from a certainty, given the circumstances.
You aren't the brightest light bulb around here now are you?
Around here, mate, I'm freaking Einstein. Not that that's saying much.
That is what I am guessing their new discussions with Motlop entail.
I think Brisbane will talk to him if he gets PSD but Brisbane wouldn't convince someone to go into the PSD from where they finished up.
Still a very good chance one of the bottom four will try and take him.
I still feel a deal will more than likely be done.