View Full Version : T.Cloke vs B.Fisher
Charlie Beagle
13 Oct 2005, 19:52
Which young foward would you rather have in your team
Pie 4 Life
14 Oct 2005, 19:30
Travis Cloke comfortably but Fisher will still be a shining star in the future.
ManWithNoName
14 Oct 2005, 19:45
Definetly Travis Cloke, he looks like a very good young kid.
Funkalicous
14 Oct 2005, 21:24
Seeing as we're all duplicating post from other threads, I'll do the same :cool:
Cloke's a bigger size and a thumping kick, but Fisher has it over him in every other department.
If you had to choose only one, it depends on which way you looked at it. Fisher would be the safer option, as he's basically proved himself as a consistent performer and looks set to become a star. Cloke on the other hand has the X-factor. His two main attributes I mentioned are probably the most dangerous combination an AFL player can have. If he establishes himself, he'll dominate. Probably more so than Fisher.
Lonie_from_50
14 Oct 2005, 21:40
The main fact is...the pole is T Cloke 1 - 0 B Fisher...from all evidence, there is only one neutral supporter who has polled....that is Jarryd_S
Charlie Beagle
14 Oct 2005, 21:47
The main fact is...the pole is T Cloke 1 - 0 B Fisher...from all evidence, there is only one neutral supporter who has polled....that is Jarryd_S
how do you know?
there could be 15 neutral supporters who have voted
Johnson#26
15 Oct 2005, 22:03
As if Fisher will be a better player. He will be a good player, of that there is no doubt. I like watching him play, but C3 will be a very, very good player for the Pies over the next ten years.
Cassius_Clay
15 Oct 2005, 22:51
Fisher will be a GUN!
Charlie Beagle
16 Oct 2005, 01:23
As if Fisher will be a better player. He will be a good player, of that there is no doubt. I like watching him play, but C3 will be a very, very good player for the Pies over the next ten years.
Collingwood is constantly overrating there players.....thats why there no good
Johnson#26
16 Oct 2005, 11:37
Really. Then what is Carlton doing keeping Ian Prendergast on its list?
But seriously, Travis Cloke will be a star. Fisher may be too, but Cloke will be better.
gandaal
16 Oct 2005, 17:16
Really. Then what is Carlton doing keeping Ian Prendergast on its list?
But seriously, Travis Cloke will be a star. Fisher may be too, but Cloke will be better.
No Carlton supporters actually rate Prendergast so I don't know how he can be overrated, but if a player who wasn't rated by anyone could possibly be overrated that player would have to be Ian Prendergast.
CaptainObvious
16 Oct 2005, 22:01
Cloke
Talented Player
16 Oct 2005, 23:34
Brad Fisher
brad fisher even though travis cloke is tall .. brad fisher is much more expirienced and if fisher didnt get injured no-one would have even voted for cloke because fisher would have proved how good he was and when he returned from injury he was kicking 2-3 goals a game !
EagleEye
21 Oct 2005, 18:41
Fish for me..
bluesforever
23 Oct 2005, 13:48
No idea, if I had to pick one ofcourse I'd go Fisher, he's shown what he's capable of more than Cloke, who has only played a few good games. Who knows, Cloke could turn out to be a star, but so could Fish.... no idea.
dave_27
23 Oct 2005, 16:27
probably travis cloke.
fisher has been injured the last couple of years though hasnt he?
Jeremias
23 Oct 2005, 16:38
fisher for me, but having sad that cloke will b a very good player. expect them both to be 200+ gamers for their respective clubs
Funkalicous
23 Oct 2005, 17:57
probably travis cloke.
fisher has been injured the last couple of years though hasnt he?
Had a knee reco, but came back a better player. Go figure...