View Full Version : who's the best out of this lot?
don vito of fitzroy
4 Nov 2005, 20:45
There have been some dull polls here so I'm doing something random. Who's a better footballer from the past on the list given?
billybrownless16
4 Nov 2005, 21:48
They're pretty hard to split but I went for Hall
I went for lewis cause hes the only one ive ever heard of out of them
:::buddy38:::
5 Nov 2005, 10:54
how old are these guys
don vito of fitzroy
5 Nov 2005, 12:32
how old are these guysFrom my guess, they would be in their late 30s or early 40s. These players have played VFL/AFL within the last 20 years.
CarnthePies
5 Nov 2005, 12:53
Where's the "None of the above" button?
don vito of fitzroy
5 Nov 2005, 17:13
Where's the "None of the above" button?It was a random list and you had to pick out of that five. If you don't like it, ignore it.
iameviljez
7 Nov 2005, 00:06
Ross Lyon was actually a fairly good player for the Royboys whilst Lewis had the displeasure of playing in a few very crap teams.
subtle hustle
9 Nov 2005, 17:50
dale lewis is winnign cos he is the most recent olayer and is stuck in peoples mind. but tony hall was a gun forward and would've had an even more brilliant career if not for his knee injuries.
Matty Larkin came third in a brownlow one year I think? Captianed of the Roo boys at one stage....captained carey when his career started. I say Larkin.
Dale Lewis is the biggest dud to play AFL football ever. Worse than Clive Waterhouse.
dale lewis is winnign cos he is the most recent olayer and is stuck in peoples mind. but tony hall was a gun forward and would've had an even more brilliant career if not for his knee injuries.
Correct and correct... Hall may have been the stand out if it wasnt for injuries... And younger people know Lewis.
For me it was between Matty Larkin and Ross Lyon. I went for Lyon, was a great player right throughout his career in a struggling side.
Johnson#26
12 Nov 2005, 20:35
Lewis or Larkin. Del-Rae had a few good seasons from memory...
don vito of fitzroy
12 Nov 2005, 22:15
Matty Larkin came third in a brownlow one year I think? Captianed of the Roo boys at one stage....captained carey when his career started. I say Larkin.
Dale Lewis is the biggest dud to play AFL football ever. Worse than Clive Waterhouse.Larkin came fourth in the 1985 Brownlow with Tim Watson, Brian Royal, Stephen Wallis, Gary Ablett and Greg Williams. Larkin was captain from 1990-92.
If Dale Lewis is the biggest dud, you haven't seen Damien Cupido.
Walsh Bay
17 Nov 2005, 16:28
Jeepers it's Lyon by a mile, I can't believe he's behind.
Dale Lewis is the biggest dud to play AFL football ever. Worse than Clive Waterhouse.
What? Ridiculous comment. Lewie could really play on his day.
Lewis or Hall out of that lot. Hall was a gun at times.