View Full Version : Which of these players hold the most importance to the club?
Richmondfan#1
4 Oct 2001, 21:53
The salary cap isn't going to let us keep all our players as they are at the moment (from what i gather!).
Out of these blokes, who would you rather stay and who is the most important at the club (who do we need the most?)?
Richmondfan#1
4 Oct 2001, 21:57
A bit of bias here but I'd have to say Campbell. Being the captain of the club, he shows more leadership at the club than Holland and Hilton. He has been a key role in our game and to lose him would hurt us.
Yep, I reckon we should definitely keep Campbell and Hilton.
Let Holland go to Adelaide. ;)
I would say Campbell is the most important to keep at the club.
I would then say Hilton because he can play effectively in so many different positions, such as on ball half forward or half back
Originally posted by ant
Yep, I reckon we should definitely keep Campbell and Hilton.
Let Holland go to Adelaide. ;)
Im with Ant on this one, we have some good players in defence like Chaffey and that bloke that punches everyone...Hall
I think its time for Benny to head home you are no longer needed at punt road anymore ;)
THE GURU
6 Oct 2001, 11:32
Campbell is an expeirenced footballer and should be kept.I like Hilton too.
Its a pity someone has to go.
rfctigerarmy
7 Oct 2001, 20:30
This is a hard one, I think Holland is the new star in the 10 ten and same with Hilton. Campbell is good but I dont think he should be captin. You might Disagree but thats what i think. Out of them, i dont think any of them should go. Daffy, Burke, Rogers and Chaffey i Think should leave.
Go to My Tigers Site http://rfctigerarmy.ipfox.com
sandeano
7 Oct 2001, 23:59
Isn't it time Aaron James found a nice, permanent place in the VFL?
Oh, yeah...and I don't mean like he did with Coburg this year.
Originally posted by rfctigerarmy
This is a hard one, I think Holland is the new star in the 10 ten and same with Hilton. Campbell is good but I dont think he should be captin. You might Disagree but thats what i think. Out of them, i dont think any of them should go. Daffy, Burke, Rogers and Chaffey i Think should leave.
Go to My Tigers Site http://rfctigerarmy.ipfox.com
I don't think we should get rid of Chaffey personally i thought he had a fairly solid stellar season.
I agree with you though having to get rid of bourke and Daffy and maybe Rogers if we need to offload someone due to the salary cap.
rfctigerarmy
10 Oct 2001, 15:48
Now i have though about it i dont think we should get rid off Chaff.
Now that trading is over delist James and Proctor.
Go Tigers Cant stop laughing Daffy and Bourke for Huddo and Staff
http://rfctigerarmy.ipfox.com - one of the 1st Tiger Sites to get Updated As news comes in!
RichmondEmma
18 Oct 2001, 17:24
Wayne Campbell but all 3 are very inporten to the club
Beausgirl43
30 Oct 2001, 17:19
Ben Holland.
cheers... :)
You've really got to admit that making Campbell captain has been a revelation. I was worried at the start of the season that he was not up to it or could not replace Knights but I think in is mentally tougher and more captain like than Knights.
I think that everyone would have been willing to trade Holland for just about anything until he moved into the back line this year, finally he has found his spot in the side and he's not just clogging up the forward line.
Campbell is the most valuable at the moment out of the three but I think that Otto is the most valuable at the club (including Richo).