PDA

View Full Version : Tale Of The Tape


The Old Dark Navy's
15 Dec 2005, 23:06
* Most of these profiles are a year old so some younger players may have grown.

Adrian De Luca 202cm
Daniel Batson (r) 201cm
Barnaby French 200cm
Aisake O'hAilpin (r) 199cm
Setanta O'hAilpin 198cm
Chris Bryan 197cm
Dylan McLaren 196cm
Josh Kennedy 195.1cm
Adam Hartlett 195cm
----------------------------
Jason Saddington 194cm
Paul Bower 192.3cm
Jarrad Waite 192cm
Brad Fisher 192cm
Luke Livingston 192cm
Bret Thornton 192cm
Ian Prendergast 192cm
Jake Edwards 191.7cm
Anthony Koutoufides 191cm
Brendan Fevola 191cm
Lance Whitnall 190cm
Anthony Raso 190cm
Jordan Bannister 190cm
-----------------------------
Andrew Walker 189cm
Craig Flint (r) 188.5cm
Jordan Russell 188cm
Trent Sporn 188cm
Ryan Jackson (r) 187.7cm
David Teague 187cm
Ryan Houlihan 187cm
Simon Wiggins 187cm
Andrew Carrazzo 187cm
Troy Longmuir 185cm
-----------------------------
Justin Davies 184cm
Callum Chambers 184cm
Adam Bentick 184cm
Jessie D Smith (r) 183cm
Matthew Lappin 182cm
Heath Scotland 182cm
Kade Simpson 182cm
Cory McGrath 181cm
Nick Stevens 180cm
-----------------------------
Marc Murphy 179.1cm
Luke Blackwell 177cm
Eddie Betts 173cm

audas
16 Dec 2005, 00:33
great post ....in order like that sets things up in the minds eye.

First up, actually didnt realise deluca was our tallest,..der.

Second up , WTF, 9 of our top 11 talls have either barely (bryan) played or not at all. Dukes and french aside. Second of all Marc murphy looks like a dot in all the photos we have seen of him,this is because he is always with our other recruits ., but even so he still comes acroos small so being the same height as stevo...choice !!

off topic, .... geez simpson is underated,..this kid is going to be a superstar.

OZBomb
16 Dec 2005, 08:09
off topic, .... geez simpson is underated,..this kid is going to be a superstar.

He's like a courageous unselfish version of Camporeale... Sounds pretty good to me

Kooley
16 Dec 2005, 08:14
He's like a courageous unselfish version of Camporeale... Sounds pretty good to melike to see simmo go from a 15-20 possession getter into a 20-25 next year. :)

XXX KINGS
16 Dec 2005, 11:55
like to see simmo go from a 15-20 possession getter into a 20-25 next year. :)
He even does something with the ball when he gets it too:eek:

I love Simmo:)

Thalidomide
16 Dec 2005, 12:03
Was watching him play against the Pies and all (or pretty much) of his possies were effective. Uses the ball very well.

Also in that game, Bentick had a blinder - spears the ball very well :)

audas
20 Dec 2005, 20:18
Was watching him play against the Pies and all (or pretty much) of his possies were effective. Uses the ball very well.

Also in that game, Bentick had a blinder - spears the ball very well :)

The pies did have some injuries but carlton had been building over the pre-ceeding weeks. But Bentick was kicking like Buckley. the pair of them were out standing. It is performances like these, walker waite and the the top up of one or two other players that says top 8.

Dukes is tall though, didnt realise he was our tallest.

HBF
21 Dec 2005, 07:21
He's like a courageous unselfish version of Camporeale... Sounds pretty good to me

So what you're saying Oz is that he's nothing like Campo.:cool:

Effes
21 Dec 2005, 07:25
Sheik will be happy with those genuine 195cm KP prospects:)

WTTF
21 Dec 2005, 07:47
* Most of these profiles are a year old so some younger players may have grown.

Adrian De Luca 202cm
Daniel Batson (r) 201cm
Barnaby French 200cm
Aisake O'hAilpin (r) 199cm
Setanta O'hAilpin 198cm
Chris Bryan 197cm
Dylan McLaren 196cm
Josh Kennedy 195.1cm
Adam Hartlett 195cm
----------------------------
Jason Saddington 194cm
Paul Bower 192.3cm
Jarrad Waite 192cm
Brad Fisher 192cm
Luke Livingston 192cm
Bret Thornton 192cm
Ian Prendergast 192cm
Jake Edwards 191.7cm
Anthony Koutoufides 191cm
Brendan Fevola 191cm
Lance Whitnall 190cm
Anthony Raso 190cm
Jordan Bannister 190cm
-----------------------------
Andrew Walker 189cm
Craig Flint (r) 188.5cm
Jordan Russell 188cm
Trent Sporn 188cm
Ryan Jackson (r) 187.7cm
David Teague 187cm
Ryan Houlihan 187cm
Simon Wiggins 187cm
Andrew Carrazzo 187cm
Troy Longmuir 185cm
-----------------------------
Justin Davies 184cm
Callum Chambers 184cm
Adam Bentick 184cm
Jessie D Smith (r) 183cm
Matthew Lappin 182cm
Heath Scotland 182cm
Kade Simpson 182cm
Cory McGrath 181cm
Nick Stevens 180cm
-----------------------------
Marc Murphy 179.1cm
Luke Blackwell 177cm
Eddie Betts 173cm

Sone of these "heights" have to taken with a grain of salt I reckon. I seriously question the accuracy of some of them, particularly these ones:

Fevola - more like 188
Teague - more like 185
Houihan - more like 185
Wiggins - more like 185
Carrazzo - more like 180
Livingston - more like 190

Especially Carrazzo having stood next him myself, no way he is 6'2 as listed. He's a fraction under 6'0 at best.