PDA

View Full Version : wisbey comment on missy


stefoid
16 Dec 2005, 15:31
from extreme black and white website: sounds a bit like guido to me. Does mention somewhere else that higgins is more of a 'first dibs' type of player who gets roughly 1/3rd of his stats through a hardball. Sounds like a good footsoldier in the midfield, but I guess it just depends on how far he goes with this style of play - wont be complaining if he gets to scott west or simon black status.

answer is in response to where wisbey ranked higgins in the list of draftees. note that his rankings are a bit different to the way the draft went - he had marc murphy at #9, and shannon hurn at #1, for instance.
------

In the end I settled on #35. He went #11 and I know a number of other clubs who would have considered him for around pick 11.

I would sum up Higgins' game as "Simon Black style. Read, get, dispose quickly (usually short)and reliably with good vision."

That is significant and he does it very well but my query was whether he has enough strings to his bow, given his so-so pace (especially off the mark) and a few other concerns.

Had a good year and certainly his first half of his U18 Champs game in particular looked serious AFL. I didn't take much notice of his late season TAC form as he appeared to be struggling fitness-wise, probably with a calf complaint. He will definitely play AFL but every year there are a handful of kids I (as with everyone in recruiting) really struggle to confidently nail and he is one with whom I struggled this year.

AFL-wise there is probably a 60/40 split of things I see in him that I like or that concern me (in terms of AFL potential).

Mofra
16 Dec 2005, 15:54
If anything, it shows how even the draft was - some had Higgins as higher than #11, obviosly a few would have had him lower.

Interesting to note it is from a Collingwood source - their need for speed in the midfiled would have no doubt had some influence on the way they rate players IMO, as the abundance of pace on the Bulldog list may have influenced our rankings.

stefoid
16 Dec 2005, 16:04
If anything, it shows how even the draft was - some had Higgins as higher than #11, obviosly a few would have had him lower.

Interesting to note it is from a Collingwood source - their need for speed in the midfiled would have no doubt had some influence on the way they rate players IMO, as the abundance of pace on the Bulldog list may have influenced our rankings.

Wisbey barrakcs for collingwood, but it doesnt affect his ratings of players - note he had shannon hurn as his #1 pick, and he wasnt drafted by collingwood, nor is he a quick player.

wisbey tends to like players that are hard at the ball and show good intensity and skills - if the player in question more of a reciever, he marks them down unless they have a very high hurt factor with their disposals.

Seems like higgins is a bit of an extractor, and works very hard and accumulates posessions - although insome other brief I saw on him, it says he rarely goes to ground... so, you might say the master of that type of play is robert harvey. I dont think you can go too far wrong with a smart, hardworking, inside midfielder, can you?

Captain Sensible
16 Dec 2005, 20:32
Seems like higgins is a bit of an extractor, and works very hard and accumulates posessions - although insome other brief I saw on him, it says he rarely goes to ground...


Theres two good signs. Staying on your feet is so important it gets you involved in so many more contests.

Dog Town
18 Dec 2005, 08:49
Theres two good signs. Staying on your feet is so important it gets you involved in so many more contests.I love Wisbeys profiles but I take more notice of who he compares there style to and there signature plays than where he actually ranks them because he is frighteningly accurate with how he describes there style of play.He ranks players on how he rates them as opposed to what draft pick he would use.For example I think he rated McEntee the ruckmen at 8 but he didn't even get picked up.Could have used pick 60 on him.

Higgins manager compared him to Dal Santo from memory.

Gilbo_Fan
18 Dec 2005, 09:59
Higgins manager compared him to Dal Santo from memory.


Nice work by his manager - but then again I compare myself to a combination of Leon Cameron and Brian Royal!

FrediKanoute
20 Dec 2005, 00:55
Is there a link to Wiseby's rating of Higgins???

scooter600x
20 Dec 2005, 08:29
Is there a link to Wiseby's rating of Higgins???
He hasn't put it up yet and he said he had promised a lot of others first.