View Full Version : Central Murray FL
The_KNIFE
1 Jun 2007, 16:14
I heard he was offered a skills coaching job at Nyah but decided to help out Arentz with his goal kicking instead. Probably could also make a good fitness coach, he was a fitness freak once. The great Piston best plumber in the Nth Heard he took on a doz Veitmanese Kung Fu experts in Melb once at the Crown. They hid behind a half inch thick plate glass door so he couldnt get to him. He was protecting his mates from them
the red white and black
1 Jun 2007, 17:04
The great Piston best plumber in the Nth Heard he took on a doz Veitmanese Kung Fu experts in Melb once at the Crown. They hid behind a half inch thick plate glass door so he couldnt get to him. He was protecting his mates from them
That sounds like a different bloke than when I knew him a long time ago. These Kung Fu experts weren't Chinese cooks in the Crown Food Court????
Hill Bully
1 Jun 2007, 17:29
That sounds like a different bloke than when I knew him a long time ago. These Kung Fu experts weren't Chinese cooks in the Crown Food Court????
Yeah, could be him. He used to do the "wax on wax off" thing and I have seen him balancing on one leg on a post before. He is probably the most disciplined martial arts man I have seen. Made Billy Sharnock blush one night at the "O" His win-loss record probably doesn't reflect his fighting ability though. Some people call him "The Cougar"
can someone tell me how alwyn davey went when he played for kerang a couple of years ago?? did he win their b & f
Go Cohuna
1 Jun 2007, 20:44
can someone tell me how alwyn davey went when he played for kerang a couple of years ago?? did he win their b & f
No one could catch him.
itchy&scratchy
1 Jun 2007, 21:23
They tell me that SHANE HARVEY from wakool is going 2 BALRANALD Before june the 30th
Not only him but Trent Bartel from lalbert has had enough and is leaving the nest and becoming a rooboy aswell:D :D :D
Hill Bully
2 Jun 2007, 17:55
Not only him but Trent Bartel from lalbert has had enough and is leaving the nest and becoming a rooboy aswell:D :D :D
Mark Norton is on the move too. Do you think Balranald ave enough $$$$$$$ for him. Maybe some one should let Filo know. He played for Hawthorn, what points would he be on???
Not only him but Trent Bartel from lalbert has had enough and is leaving the nest and becoming a rooboy aswell:D :D :D
No loyaity up their, sounds like money is killing clubs sort it out Itchy&scratchy :D :D :D :D
the red white and black
2 Jun 2007, 22:55
Mark Norton is on the move too. Do you think Balranald ave enough $$$$$$$ for him. Maybe some one should let Filo know. He played for Hawthorn, what points would he be on???
Big M little league does not count.
doubting thomas
2 Jun 2007, 23:13
I got to the game at Balranald today and as a neutral observer was very impressed with the dogs. Seemed to be some in house squabling amongst the roos though. Still see Balranald with a top two finish though.
Bobby Rivers
3 Jun 2007, 15:04
Balranald have picked former gun rover Jason Dennis for the remainder of the season apparently luring him back from WA working in the mines. You only go to the mines for big dollars but the roos have even topped that.
Would we be the highest paying comp in the state at the moment and I'm only talking the upper end of the ladder obviously ?
Balranald have picked former gun rover Jason Dennis for the remainder of the season apparently luring him back from WA working in the mines. You only go to the mines for big dollars but the roos have even topped that.
Would we be the highest paying comp in the state at the moment and I'm only talking the upper end of the ladder obviously ?
Doubt they've lured him back, but then again sounds like Balranald is like working in the mines!!!
Can anyone tell me how the 3-4 Wallan boys have been going up at I think Koondrook?
Not only him but Trent Bartel from lalbert has had enough and is leaving the nest and becoming a rooboy aswell:D :D :D
Not sure Balranald would have enough coin for Trent, doesn't he come as a package deal with Robo, after all they are joined at the hip:rolleyes:
Ron_Burgundy
3 Jun 2007, 21:10
seems to be some young talent going around the CMFL such as young Kyle Wilson from Koodrook and Bryden Morrison from kerang! who's paying little odds for rookie of the year?
The_KNIFE
4 Jun 2007, 11:30
Mark Norton is on the move too. Do you think Balranald ave enough $$$$$$$ for him. Maybe some one should let Filo know. He played for Hawthorn, what points would he be on???
He was seen at the Tooley ground a couple of weeks ago doing some sprint work and also practicing his goal kicking with the Banana kick left and right.(he claims he invented the kick and Dacios stole the idea).Also booked into the Le Guier health farm for 2 weeks .
icantgiveuwatihaventgot
4 Jun 2007, 11:52
where are you **** heads that were bagging the mighty doggies a couple of weeks ago and didn't believe the powers that be when they said they knew exactly what they were talking about. i wonder if strevens, **** brain gadsen and noel watson will have anything positive to say now and actually give tyntynder some credit instead of slagging us off
Sockit151
4 Jun 2007, 12:43
where are you **** heads that were bagging the mighty doggies a couple of weeks ago and didn't believe the powers that be when they said they knew exactly what they were talking about. i wonder if strevens, **** brain gadsen and noel watson will have anything positive to say now and actually give tyntynder some credit instead of slagging us off
Well done Dogs, another June flag!!
How many in a row is that since '99 when you last cracked it for a Sept version:D
September
4 Jun 2007, 14:47
can someone tell me how alwyn davey went when he played for kerang a couple of years ago?? did he win their b & f
Was hot and cold, either very good or very ordinary. Didn't finish in top 6
Was only 18 though
where are you **** heads that were bagging the mighty doggies a couple of weeks ago and didn't believe the powers that be when they said they knew exactly what they were talking about. i wonder if strevens, **** brain gadsen and noel watson will have anything positive to say now and actually give tyntynder some credit instead of slagging us off
Fair enough mate. The dogs were slammed and seemed to have some internal trouble. Have bounced back in great style defeating the top 2 picks in successive games. Must have been some 3rd quarter! Balranald had a fair few more scoring shots but good kicking is goos football. Credit where its due doggies!!!!!! Makes the comp more interesting anyway. Dont start me on the radio "personalities" though. Terrible- always have been and always will.
seems to be some young talent going around the CMFL such as young Kyle Wilson from Koodrook and Bryden Morrison from kerang! who's paying little odds for rookie of the year?
Yound Bo Alexander would have to be amongst the favourites if he is eligible. Would be interested to get your thoughts on how young think Bo is travelling Ron. Doing a great job for the undermanned Eagles is the word i am hearing
icantgiveuwatihaventgot
4 Jun 2007, 16:49
Fair enough mate. The dogs were slammed and seemed to have some internal trouble. Have bounced back in great style defeating the top 2 picks in successive games. Must have been some 3rd quarter! Balranald had a fair few more scoring shots but good kicking is goos football. Credit where its due doggies!!!!!! Makes the comp more interesting anyway. Dont start me on the radio "personalities" though. Terrible- always have been and always will.
the 3rd quater was sensational and we played the brand of footy that you talk about playing all the time which put the opposition right off guard. i wouldn't say balranald had more scoring shots but they did have more scores registered due to our miserly defence rushing 40-50% of the balranald behinds. It does make the shaping of the 5 very interesting. With L/G on top without a loss still have to play T/M, Bal & Tyn but only once, Tyn have to play L/G, Bal & T/M again before finals, Bal have to play L/G, T/M & Tyn before finals & T/M have to play L/G, Bal & Tyn before seasons end. Anyone want to go out and have a crack at a top 5?
Sockit151
4 Jun 2007, 17:05
the 3rd quater was sensational and we played the brand of footy that you talk about playing all the time which put the opposition right off guard. i wouldn't say balranald had more scoring shots but they did have more scores registered due to our miserly defence rushing 40-50% of the balranald behinds. It does make the shaping of the 5 very interesting. With L/G on top without a loss still have to play T/M, Bal & Tyn but only once, Tyn have to play L/G, Bal & T/M again before finals, Bal have to play L/G, T/M & Tyn before finals & T/M have to play L/G, Bal & Tyn before seasons end. Anyone want to go out and have a crack at a top 5?
As you rightly state, the Bombers have had a dream draw this year and surely wont miss finals now..
This leave only one spot up for grabs, winner of Kerang vs Swan Hill next round will take 5th in my opinion..
switch the play
4 Jun 2007, 17:07
Bad news for the Raiders in that their long serving clubman Dwayne Guerra may have played his last game as he has purchased a Trailer Park in between Myall and Gannawarra,just north of the Gunny Flats and may not play again as this business will take a lot of his time.Takes over in about 2 weeks i believe.
clifton's lookalike
4 Jun 2007, 17:10
the 3rd quater was sensational and we played the brand of footy that you talk about playing all the time which put the opposition right off guard. i wouldn't say balranald had more scoring shots but they did have more scores registered due to our miserly defence rushing 40-50% of the balranald behinds. It does make the shaping of the 5 very interesting. With L/G on top without a loss still have to play T/M, Bal & Tyn but only once, Tyn have to play L/G, Bal & T/M again before finals, Bal have to play L/G, T/M & Tyn before finals & T/M have to play L/G, Bal & Tyn before seasons end. Anyone want to go out and have a crack at a top 5?
ICGUWIHG ever heard of keeping a lid on things:thumbsd:
Ron_Burgundy
4 Jun 2007, 22:58
Yound Bo Alexander would have to be amongst the favourites if he is eligible. Would be interested to get your thoughts on how young think Bo is travelling Ron. Doing a great job for the undermanned Eagles is the word i am hearing
yes roota, another young name getting around the CMFL.. fortunately for the eagles there is some young talent out that way which plays a big role for their future:thumbsu:
woof woof
4 Jun 2007, 23:05
yes roota, another young name getting around the CMFL.. fortunately for the eagles there is some young talent out that way which plays a big role for their future:thumbsu:
i have started a thread on best players in the colts this year if anyone would like to provide any input. i love watching the young blokes who step up to the seniors and play and think they should be worth zero points if playing seniors while still eligible for colts. encourages clubs to not just go out and recruit big name players but blood the young blokes early so they are ready for senior footy when their colts days are over.
I will take a stab at the top 5.
Tyntynder
Balranald
Tooley/Manang
Leitchville
Swan Hill
the red white and black
5 Jun 2007, 13:00
He was seen at the Tooley ground a couple of weeks ago doing some sprint work and also practicing his goal kicking with the Banana kick left and right.(he claims he invented the kick and Dacios stole the idea).Also booked into the Le Guier health farm for 2 weeks .
Tell him I taught him the banana kick, just like I taught him to bowl leg spin and cover drive.
Tell him I taught him the banana kick, just like I taught him to bowl leg spin and cover drive.
If your the bloke i think u r, u could not kick over a jam tin and i showed u how to bat & bowl:thumbsu:
the red white and black
5 Jun 2007, 20:35
If your the bloke i think u r, u could not kick over a jam tin and i showed u how to bat & bowl:thumbsu:
You might have me onions, Im sick of running. Could somebody up here tell me how Joel Coates is going and maybe the gloved one could tell me how he thinks Joel would go on Mark Norton. Roota, best get back to our thread.
i have started a thread on best players in the colts this year if anyone would like to provide any input. i love watching the young blokes who step up to the seniors and play and think they should be worth zero points if playing seniors while still eligible for colts. encourages clubs to not just go out and recruit big name players but blood the young blokes early so they are ready for senior footy when their colts days are over.
which tyntynder players are still eligible for colts that are playing seniors woof woof?
are there any that are genuine contributors or just making up the numbers?
I notice you blokes get the long weekend off this weekend. How did this come about???
Hill Bully
6 Jun 2007, 22:41
He was seen at the Tooley ground a couple of weeks ago doing some sprint work and also practicing his goal kicking with the Banana kick left and right.(he claims he invented the kick and Dacios stole the idea).Also booked into the Le Guier health farm for 2 weeks .
Is that the same health farm that Greg Coote uses??
the red white and black
6 Jun 2007, 23:36
Is that the same health farm that Greg Coote uses??
I'm assuming Greg Coote is not one of your finer athletes.
woof woof
7 Jun 2007, 10:24
which tyntynder players are still eligible for colts that are playing seniors woof woof?
Bede Mahon is still eligible for Colts, Josh Free, Josh Ewart, Daniel Crowe, Sean Sennar, Nick Willox have all played this year with the first five playing pretty regularly and all played well against T/M. A couple that are not to far away would be Chris Proctor, John Boyle & Trent Storer who are all having good seasons.
What is going on down at koondrook/barham??.
Why have they been so poor for the last few years?.
ARe they spending any money or a they saving it for a rainy day?.
Surely a town that has had a huge property price boom in barham would have some cash to spend on high quality players???.
CHANCE TO WIN A TRIP TO MELBOURNE FOR TWO!
Go to www.lalbertfc.vcfl.com.au (http://www.lalbertfc.vcfl.com.au)
Find the code word and sms it to the number provided.
Winner will be announced at the end of the season!
Appin Vet
8 Jun 2007, 11:43
What is going on down at koondrook/barham??.
Why have they been so poor for the last few years?.
ARe they spending any money or a they saving it for a rainy day?.
Surely a town that has had a huge property price boom in barham would have some cash to spend on high quality players???.
Alot of faith has been shown in the locals which is good to see. Nothing wrong with recruits of course.
lualdeng
8 Jun 2007, 11:46
Bede Mahon is still eligible for Colts, Josh Free, Josh Ewart, Daniel Crowe, Sean Sennar, Nick Willox have all played this year with the first five playing pretty regularly and all played well against T/M. A couple that are not to far away would be Chris Proctor, John Boyle & Trent Storer who are all having good seasons.
bede mahon wont play juniors tho he is just too good and if dropped from the rebels will be straight into the seniors..... daniel crowe should also be playing regular senior games if it wasnt for the shit point system!!
GASTEV GOES BANG
8 Jun 2007, 23:11
Is that the same health farm that Greg Coote uses??
mundra...... looks like a retard holding a beach ball a very big beach ball!
woof woof
11 Jun 2007, 13:58
bede mahon wont play juniors tho he is just too good and if dropped from the rebels will be straight into the seniors..... daniel crowe should also be playing regular senior games if it wasnt for the shit point system!!
Your right bede won't play Colts but I was just stating that he is still eligible. Maybe you should do some research, I am pretty sure Crowie has played every game except 2 in the seniors which is pretty much REGULAR senior footy. The points system is probably why he has played this many games, it isn't stopping him from playing in any way he is a 1 pointer.
ROOTA#6
11 Jun 2007, 22:50
Question for Cliftons, Woof Woof or any bulldog lads. Just wondering how Brock has fitted in the coaching role at the kennel and has there been any noticeable difference in having some one from outside the club doing the job. Results would show he is going well, just interested to get the thoughts of the blokes on the inside
icantgiveuwatihaventgot
12 Jun 2007, 15:13
Question for Cliftons, Woof Woof or any bulldog lads. Just wondering how Brock has fitted in the coaching role at the kennel and has there been any noticeable difference in having some one from outside the club doing the job. Results would show he is going well, just interested to get the thoughts of the blokes on the inside
Brock is fitting in extremely well, has full respect of team and has probably bought some things to the table that blokes from within the club couldn't see which has helped us improve. we are a far better side than last year and it just took us a few weeks to adjust to a little different game plan from previous years. we are going ok now
switch the play
12 Jun 2007, 15:16
Big breaking news at Raiders......
GASTEV GOES BANG
12 Jun 2007, 15:58
Big breaking news at Raiders......
jumbos got hair??
the gloved 1
12 Jun 2007, 16:11
Brock is fitting in extremely well, has full respect of team and has probably bought some things to the table that blokes from within the club couldn't see which has helped us improve. we are a far better side than last year and it just took us a few weeks to adjust to a little different game plan from previous years. we are going ok now
who is hogging the mirror space? carroll, parsons or dance floor dedini
the gloved 1
12 Jun 2007, 16:15
Big breaking news at Raiders......
t. ryan to announce resignation!
Hill Bully
12 Jun 2007, 16:39
mundra...... looks like a retard holding a beach ball a very big beach ball!
Might be the man to take over from ryan, co-coach with m.norton.
Hill Bully
12 Jun 2007, 16:40
Apparently the saints are after a big scalp before clearances close, bet ya can't pick it.
icantgiveuwatihaventgot
12 Jun 2007, 17:07
Apparently the saints are after a big scalp before clearances close, bet ya can't pick it.
wouldn't be the same bloke balranald were supposedly talking to would it? they have already been in breach of their points once surely bringing someone in from outside would have to put strain on them
THE_BEAST
12 Jun 2007, 22:55
have tyntynder got josh jenkins and brock shiels definately. add them two dedinis and adam kelly to previous weeks teams then could be hard to beat if stay discipline
The_KNIFE
13 Jun 2007, 09:26
Is that the same health farm that Greg Coote uses??
Ran the health farm for a while but got the sack when another local ledgen Bozzo went in for a week and came out more out of shape than when he went in and stacked on a few extra kilos.
switch the play
13 Jun 2007, 11:56
t. ryan to announce resignation!
No....The "human blanket"Paul Molin announced at a BBQ on Sunday he is making a comeback!Should make some CMFL defenders very nervous...
Hill Bully
13 Jun 2007, 17:07
Ran the health farm for a while but got the sack when another local ledgen Bozzo went in for a week and came out more out of shape than when he went in and stacked on a few extra kilos.
How would they look at the Nullagong Nudist Camp? Hey Knife, what ever become of Geoff Cole, the man with the biggest eye in footy circles?:confused:
ablett19
14 Jun 2007, 10:25
NO CMFL Superstars in the VCFL Rep side??
What do we think about this, surely some of the Balranald/TM/Tyntynder players should have got a guernsey??!!
http://www.vcfl.com.au/newsitem.asp?id=31524&orgID=2&Oname=WorkSafe+VCFL&O1c=7&O10c=6
we'restreaking
14 Jun 2007, 13:08
How would they look at the Nullagong Nudist Camp? Hey Knife, what ever become of Geoff Cole, the man with the biggest eye in footy circles?:confused:
No word of a lie, the eye was that big the bloke use to piss two streams. Keeps a mean green to Joffa. Where is he now?
we'restreaking
14 Jun 2007, 13:12
How would they look at the Nullagong Nudist Camp? Hey Knife, what ever become of Geoff Cole, the man with the biggest eye in footy circles?:confused:
No word of a lie, the eye was that big the bloke use to piss two streams.. Kept a mean green too did joffa. Where is he now?:D
the gloved 1
14 Jun 2007, 14:57
No word of a lie, the eye was that big the bloke use to piss two streams.. Kept a mean green too did joffa. Where is he now?:D
have you current and ex Tooleybuc/Tooleybuc-Manang people have anything else to talk about? for christs sake open your own thread so you can discuss these idiots you want to post here and remember the good old days about. is it that these people are your idols and the people who are currently involved with your club a bunch of F WHITS
Leigh Riordan and Jason Dennis back to Balranald. Clearances in. Gee the points system is working a treat isn't it! The league might as well scrap it all together. It fails to limit teams at all. Can Balranald justify the amazing spending spree they've gone on for 4 years now? Is it all worth it? Yes they've won a flag (just) but at what cost?
Bobby Rivers
14 Jun 2007, 17:24
Could someone tell me how many points Balranald officially get. Do they get a few extra points due to being an isolated club, which i have no problems with?
Is it also correct that Leitchville/Gunbower get extra points which I do have an issue with as these blokes are in the best recruiting position in the whole league with Echuca, Bendigo and even Melbourne not too far away. Good luck to L/G but this doesn't seem equal.
PJPower
14 Jun 2007, 19:01
Could someone tell me how many points Balranald officially get. Do they get a few extra points due to being an isolated club, which i have no problems with?
Is it also correct that Leitchville/Gunbower get extra points which I do have an issue with as these blokes are in the best recruiting position in the whole league with Echuca, Bendigo and even Melbourne not too far away. Good luck to L/G but this doesn't seem equal.
Balranald Lalbert, Leit/Gun, Too/man are all on 47 pts. S/Hill & Tyntynder on 41 pts, L/boga, kerang & Woorinen 43 pts, Cohuna, Koo/barham & NNW Utd on45 pts
I don,t think distance has much too do with recruiting these days, more too do with the $,s spent & on who?
GASTEV GOES BANG
14 Jun 2007, 20:53
Could someone tell me how many points Balranald officially get. Do they get a few extra points due to being an isolated club, which i have no problems with?
Is it also correct that Leitchville/Gunbower get extra points which I do have an issue with as these blokes are in the best recruiting position in the whole league with Echuca, Bendigo and even Melbourne not too far away. Good luck to L/G but this doesn't seem equal.
yeh agree it seems abit silly maybe the same as the just out of swan hill mob woulb be suitable.... eg. Woora
woof woof
14 Jun 2007, 23:18
Balranald Lalbert, Leit/Gun, Too/man are all on 47 pts. S/Hill & Tyntynder on 41 pts, L/boga, kerang & Woorinen 43 pts, Cohuna, Koo/barham & NNW Utd on45 pts
I don,t think distance has much too do with recruiting these days, more too do with the $,s spent & on who?
i don't think the league is trying to stop recruits from going to these clubs it is to prevent clubs stealing players from a lesser side to a better side. i will use this year as an example jason kruger at nyah getting BOG every week would have to be getting to spoken from clubs within the league about his intentions for next year. he goes to another club in the league who is in top 3-4 and is worth 5 points to them. it is trying to stop wealthy successfull clubs raping the underperforming clubs.
mind you in my opinion every club should have same amount of points. then the club who wants to pay the most $$$ for a bloke or the club who might be able to offer some success or whatever they use to persuade blokes gets him. when the salary cap (i realise it didn't work) was in place everyone had the same amount to spend. those that could spend more and get away with it did so. the regional based clubs didn't get an extra 20k to spend because they were disadvantaged due to location.
what about each club having a sup list or a rookie list where for example 5 players eligible for colts can be put on this list and they are worth 0 points. would see more young kids getting a go
footyhas3sides
15 Jun 2007, 09:41
what about each club having a sup list or a rookie list where for example 5 players eligible for colts can be put on this list and they are worth 0 points. would see more young kids getting a go
Good idea, but like the points system where all ex underage players are worth 1 point regardless of where else they have been, including within the league, this favors the clubs that have the largest number of underage players. i.e. they have better talent due to quantity and the law of averages whilst they can afford to play a couple in the seniors as they are not struggling to put a colts side on the ground.
In future years if the points system stays, the strong clubs will be the ones with the quantity of players in the juniors
Joe Czak
15 Jun 2007, 09:47
what about each club having a sup list or a rookie list where for example 5 players eligible for colts can be put on this list and they are worth 0 points. would see more young kids getting a go
Wouldn't these clubs be getting more points because they have a smaller population base and therefore need to bring recruits in. Blokes football age (18-28) are more likely to move away from towns such as L/G and Balranald (for employment/schooling/etc) than they are from Swan Hill for example.
HavUEvaSeenTheRain
15 Jun 2007, 10:48
i don't think the league is trying to stop recruits from going to these clubs it is to prevent clubs stealing players from a lesser side to a better side. i will use this year as an example jason kruger at nyah getting BOG every week would have to be getting to spoken from clubs within the league about his intentions for next year. he goes to another club in the league who is in top 3-4 and is worth 5 points to them. it is trying to stop wealthy successfull clubs raping the underperforming clubs.
mind you in my opinion every club should have same amount of points. then the club who wants to pay the most $$$ for a bloke or the club who might be able to offer some success or whatever they use to persuade blokes gets him. when the salary cap (i realise it didn't work) was in place everyone had the same amount to spend. those that could spend more and get away with it did so. the regional based clubs didn't get an extra 20k to spend because they were disadvantaged due to location.
We all know where he was going this year if he was allowed. The points for players changing clubs in this league has to go up. The Bucs have got Jacko, Thompson, Brown even Fitzgerald from the two worst teams in the league
Appin Vet
15 Jun 2007, 11:51
Balranald Lalbert, Leit/Gun, Too/man are all on 47 pts. S/Hill & Tyntynder on 41 pts, L/boga, kerang & Woorinen 43 pts, Cohuna, Koo/barham & NNW Utd on45 pts
I don,t think distance has much too do with recruiting these days, more too do with the $,s spent & on who?
Having a location based method doesn't work. How are Nyah are supposed to compete with the T/M's and Balranald's of the world when they have less points to play with (albeit 2pts). I think that a points system could work if it was based on where a particular team finishes on the ladder the previous season.
Eg. 1st - 5th (41 pts)
6th - 9th (44 pts)
10th - 12th (47 pts)
Shoot it down if you wish, but I think that would even the competition up a little. It just seems to me that depth is a major problem of some clubs in the CMFL (hence the lopsided results) and this would help eliminate that problem. Just a thought.
GASTEV GOES BANG
15 Jun 2007, 12:45
what ever the league decides it has to stick with there decision and not get pushed around by the powerhouse clubs. Time for the league to show some balls....
Trueblueroo
15 Jun 2007, 12:51
Can someone enlighten me how my mate Karl Jacka from Balranald is travelling this year?
PJPower
15 Jun 2007, 16:29
Having a location based method doesn't work. How are Nyah are supposed to compete with the T/M's and Balranald's of the world when they have less points to play with (albeit 2pts). I think that a points system could work if it was based on where a particular team finishes on the ladder the previous season.
Eg. 1st - 5th (41 pts)
6th - 9th (44 pts)
10th - 12th (47 pts)
Shoot it down if you wish, but I think that would even the competition up a little. It just seems to me that depth is a major problem of some clubs in the CMFL (hence the lopsided results) and this would help eliminate that problem. Just a thought.
Depth is the problem because adjoining leagues pay big $,s for fringe players that are usually solid reserves players in CMFL too bolster their vastly depleting ranks and yet refuse to go on any type of system to protect their clubs from non existence in the future. That,s what the pts system is all about, protecting our league for the future.
Hill Bully
15 Jun 2007, 17:27
have you current and ex Tooleybuc/Tooleybuc-Manang people have anything else to talk about? for christs sake open your own thread so you can discuss these idiots you want to post here and remember the good old days about. is it that these people are your idols and the people who are currently involved with your club a bunch of F WHITS
If you like you gloved idiot I could arrange for you to meet with these fellas for a beer. It might be the most exciting thing you have ever done, judging by the dull comments that you post.
Hillite
16 Jun 2007, 00:19
The points system in the CML seem to be very different to the approach in Sunraysia. Could someone give us a brief run down.
EG What would the points allocation be if you recruit an established senior player from another CML club.
ROOTA#6
17 Jun 2007, 00:46
The points system in the CML seem to be very different to the approach in Sunraysia. Could someone give us a brief run down.
EG What would the points allocation be if you recruit an established senior player from another CML club.
Hillite you need to read back a bit son. If a CMFL club recruits a player from another CMFL club it is 5 points eg Lance Brown Lalbert to Tooley Tang, Sean Bedggood to Woorinen etc
Hillite
18 Jun 2007, 00:24
Forty points plus whats the point.
In Sunraysia the clubs begin with 22 a couple of clubs get 3 extra for low pop. and isolation. if you come last you get four extra, 3 if you come 2nd.last and so on. The most points a club could have would be 29 made up of 22 basic 3 for isolation and four for coming last. Recruiting a senior player from an SFL team is five points.
Last year premiers would not have reached double figures.
clifton's lookalike
18 Jun 2007, 12:37
The points system in the CML seem to be very different to the approach in Sunraysia. Could someone give us a brief run down.
EG What would the points allocation be if you recruit an established senior player from another CML club.
PLAYER POINTS SYSTEM – New for 2005
With the removal of the salary cap the Central Murray FL Board will implement a player points system for the Senior Competition in 2005. This will be a trial year so no penalties will be applied in 2005. The system, including penalties will be implemented fully in 2006.
In 2005 the number of points available to each club for its senior team will be 40. This will be reviewed in mid 2005 season before a final determination for 2006.
Points system for clubs
The senior team’s total of player points is to be determined on a weekly basis.
The points allocated to a player will be determined by the League or competition from which that player was recruited so that an ex-AFL player who played in a District League in 2004 and was recruited in 2005 would attract 2 points. If he was recruited from directly from an AFL club he would attract 5 points unless he was the senior playing coach where he would only attract 1 point.
Points
Category
Explanation
1
Local player
A player who played in your Colts, or the CMJFL club affiliated with your club, even if they are returning from another club
Or a junior permit player.
2
VCFL District League player
– e.g. Mallee League
3
VCFL Major country league player except from Leagues listed as 4 points
VAFA player
Victorian Metropolitan league players
All other states metro and country league players
State League players
Ballarat League
Amateurs
Diamond Valley, Essendon District etc
VFL, SANFL etc
4
Sunraysia, North Central, Murray, Goulburn Valley and Bendigo League players.
5
AFL or Player transferring from another CMFL Club
· A non playing coach is 0 points
· A playing coach in the seniors is 1 point. Where there are joint playing coaches only one nominated coach fits this criterion.
· 1 point is deducted from each player for each season he plays at that club until he reaches 1 point where he will remain
This was from 2005 i think a few alterations have been made this year.
Hillite
18 Jun 2007, 20:15
The Sunraysia system (22-29 points) is for your total list of senior players. Not just the team as listed on a Saturday.
chalkie
18 Jun 2007, 22:10
Can any Cohuna people confirm that Chris Bounis is heading back to the Sunraysia/Millewa league before clearances close?
Trent the flight Steward
19 Jun 2007, 13:12
Can any Cohuna people confirm that Chris Bounis is heading back to the Sunraysia/Millewa league before clearances close?
Is Chris Belz heading to cohuna before the clearances shut? He has been heard to say that Cohuna is the home of the dykes and that he can turn them also they are impressed with his body but too bad about his face
All this points talk, salary cap etc. How about a radical new system with nothing? Players can play where they want, clubs can spend as much as they want with automatic clearances when no contracts are involved. Then we can get on with it.
Players should be allowed to play football at the club of their choice. If that club wants to pay them.... good on em! What right do clubs and leagues have to decide for whom a bloke plays a game of footy for the year?
Before everyone gets on their high horse answer these first- What has the salary cap or the points system done to even up the comp? Has any system stopped clubs in the CMFL poaching players within? Nothing and No are the answers. Does anyone think Balranald would have done anything differently this year if there was no system? Of course not.
So scrap the lot I say.
kidgorgeous
19 Jun 2007, 16:23
Is Chris Belz heading to cohuna before the clearances shut? He has been heard to say that Cohuna is the home of the dykes and that he can turn them also they are impressed with his body but too bad about his face
Not to mention his moves on the dancefloor Trent. :eek:
footyhas3sides
19 Jun 2007, 16:48
We all know where he was going this year if he was allowed. The points for players changing clubs in this league has to go up. The Bucs have got Jacko, Thompson, Brown even Fitzgerald from the two worst teams in the league
What is your critera for judging the worst teams in the league? Performance over the last couple of seasons or flags won in the last 15? Both Lalbert and United have 2 flags each in this time frame, nil for Tolleytang. Also, what if the players were going to leave no matter what and Tooleytang just kept them in the league rather than going to an outside league, Does that keep the league stronger, as some of them did play inter league, or make it weaker??????
HavUEvaSeenTheRain
19 Jun 2007, 20:08
What is your critera for judging the worst teams in the league? Performance over the last couple of seasons or flags won in the last 15? Both Lalbert and United have 2 flags each in this time frame, nil for Tolleytang. Also, what if the players were going to leave no matter what and Tooleytang just kept them in the league rather than going to an outside league, Does that keep the league stronger, as some of them did play inter league, or make it weaker??????
Fu<ked if i know
Deckchair
20 Jun 2007, 09:43
All this points talk, salary cap etc. How about a radical new system with nothing? Players can play where they want, clubs can spend as much as they want with automatic clearances when no contracts are involved. Then we can get on with it.
Players should be allowed to play football at the club of their choice. If that club wants to pay them.... good on em! What right do clubs and leagues have to decide for whom a bloke plays a game of footy for the year?
Before everyone gets on their high horse answer these first- What has the salary cap or the points system done to even up the comp? Has any system stopped clubs in the CMFL poaching players within? Nothing and No are the answers. Does anyone think Balranald would have done anything differently this year if there was no system? Of course not.
So scrap the lot I say.
Paul Power, could you please answer this!
Hillite
20 Jun 2007, 15:33
I reckon the points system works well in the Sunraysia F L . But then we are more isolated than the CM and on a whole pay less. Your system seems a little generous with the amount of points available.
When the points system has been in operation for few years and clubs don't get the bonus of all the players at the club when the system was introduced it should do more to encourage home grown players and more prudent spending.
Sockit151
20 Jun 2007, 16:01
I reckon the points system works well in the Sunraysia F L . But then we are more isolated than the CM and on a whole pay less. Your system seems a little generous with the amount of points available.
When the points system has been in operation for few years and clubs don't get the bonus of all the players at the club when the system was introduced it should do more to encourage home grown players and more prudent spending.
I'm assuming you have zero as a minimum rating where in the CMFL all players have atleast 1 point, this is probably why we are talking 40's to your 20's for total points.. Would be interested to hear more in detail about the systems though as it is an interesting part of local fotty these days.. Also unsure on why you think ours doesn't encourage home grown players?
Carey and Grant
20 Jun 2007, 18:47
They can have him he's injured and out for the year anyway
Carey and Grant
20 Jun 2007, 18:56
hmm dunno. who would be some players that could give the selectors something to think about?
kidgorgeous
20 Jun 2007, 20:15
Interesting to see Luke Tyrell's name amongst the reserves best. Was he coming back from injury?
ROOTA#6
20 Jun 2007, 21:10
Who are the favourites for the league medal at this stage lads. The usual suspects or are there any bolters???
woof woof
20 Jun 2007, 21:42
carey and grant who the funk are you quoting and talking to, this could be an interesting convo if we knew what you were talking about.
woof woof
20 Jun 2007, 21:44
Interesting to see Luke Tyrell's name amongst the reserves best. Was he coming back from injury?
yes he was i believe he may have had a kidney problem or was it his appendix??? dunno definatley coming back from injury though
woof woof
20 Jun 2007, 21:45
Who are the favourites for the league medal at this stage lads. The usual suspects or are there any bolters???
i would say o'sullivan would be favourite at the moment but to fill the minors i would say it will be very close and maybe a few surprises.
ROOTA#6
20 Jun 2007, 21:50
i would say o'sullivan would be favourite at the moment but to fill the minors i would say it will be very close and maybe a few surprises.
Throw out some names Woof. Anyone from the kennel a chance
Hillite
20 Jun 2007, 21:52
I'm assuming you have zero as a minimum rating where in the CMFL all players have atleast 1 point, this is probably why we are talking 40's to your 20's for total points.. Would be interested to hear more in detail about the systems though as it is an interesting part of local fotty these days.. Also unsure on why you think ours doesn't encourage home grown players?
Maybe I'm just unimpressed with the Balranald approach to success and its clouding my judgement.
Perpas the CM could change the name of the premiers trophy to
" whatever their benefactors name is" Won't it be great for the league when his cash finally dries up. One day the team that they thrashed by fifty goals recently (assuming they're still in the CM) is going to beat them at home.
woof woof
20 Jun 2007, 21:54
Throw out some names Woof. Anyone from the kennel a chance
i would say parsons and o'toole have had great seasons so far but probably stealing votes. atkins from balranald, anthony foot s.h, goldsmith will poll well for woora, its a pity nyah couldn't win a few more games because matt curran would poll very well. there are a few names but i would say majority of teams are pretty even and not relying on 1 or 2 blokes
woof woof
20 Jun 2007, 21:55
Maybe I'm just unimpressed with the Balranald approach to success and its clouding my judgement.
Perpas the CM could change the name of the premiers trophy to
" whatever their benefactors name is" Won't it be great for the league when his cash finally dries up. One day the team that they thrashed by fifty goals recently (assuming they're still in the CM) is going to beat them at home.
his money will be soaking for a few more years unless he has a falling out
ROOTA#6
20 Jun 2007, 21:56
Maybe I'm just unimpressed with the Balranald approach to success and its clouding my judgement.
Perpas the CM could change the name of the premiers trophy to
" whatever their benefactors name is" Won't it be great for the league when his cash finally dries up. One day the team that they thrashed by fifty goals recently (assuming they're still in the CM) is going to beat them at home.
The "Jock Campbell Cup" you recon Hillite. I have heard that te money is a long way from drying up though. I can remember not so long ago beating them up there but i am not sure when it will happen again
Hill Bully
20 Jun 2007, 22:17
i would say parsons and o'toole have had great seasons so far but probably stealing votes. atkins from balranald, anthony foot s.h, goldsmith will poll well for woora, its a pity nyah couldn't win a few more games because matt curran would poll very well. there are a few names but i would say majority of teams are pretty even and not relying on 1 or 2 blokes
Hey woof woof, have you forgotten Mark Norton in that list??