View Full Version : BigFootys Offical Richmond Starting 22 - Ruck
wez10000
9 Feb 2006, 16:47
Who will get your vote?
Current Side
B: Brent Hartigan - Darren Gaspar - Will Thursfield
HB: Joel Bowden - Jay Schulz - Chris Newman
C: Brett Deledio - Mark Coughlan - Chris Hyde
HF: Kayne Pettifer - Matthew Richardson - Patrick Bowden
F: Nathan Brown - Greg Stafford
FOL:
INT:
EMR:
wez10000
9 Feb 2006, 16:48
Troy Simmonds
tigerdan
9 Feb 2006, 18:09
Surely everyone is going to agree on this one!
Darth_Tiger
9 Feb 2006, 21:16
just close the poll already. troy is the boy.
Simmonds!
OMG How can someone vote Knobel over Simmonds? Who is voting in these polls :rolleyes:
Richo83
10 Feb 2006, 19:34
Simmonds!
OMG How can someone vote Knobel over Simmonds? Who is voting in these polls :rolleyes:
This is a democracy, so people are entitled to their opinion.
I just thought that Simmonds is more suited to the CHF role and Knobel is suited to the rucking role, who is the better ruckman (Just look at the hitouts last year, Troy 304 hitouts from 22 games, Knobel 298 from 18). I realise that Richo is now our CHF :mad: but I think Knobel is a better ruck option.
yeh after seeing those stats i would say Knobel as he played 4 less games and got more hitouts and when we were winning wasnt Knobel rucking most of the time or am i wrong i Vote knobel
Richo83
11 Feb 2006, 14:12
yeh after seeing those stats i would say Knobel as he played 4 less games and got more hitouts and when we were winning wasnt Knobel rucking most of the time or am i wrong i Vote knobel
You are correct. It seemed that Knobel's palming to our midfielders in the first 7 matches helped us win alot of out games.