BF Medal - Voting Thread - W1 NAB Cup [Archive]

Lonie_from_50

25 Feb 2006, 11:44

Fellow voters for the BigFooty Medal, please place your votes for your selected clubs matches in this thread for Week One - NAB Cup - Remember, this is a trial, but you are expected to participate in the trial, just as an indication as of what to expect!

For ALL the details, go to this thread! (http://bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=225876)

Vote away!

Matches
Brisbane Lions v Essendon (Carrara)
W Bulldogs v Melbourne (Marrara)
Kangaroos v Sydney (Manuka)
Hawthorn v Richmond (Telstra Dome)
Carlton v Geelong (Telstra Dome)
Adelaide v Port Adelaide (AAMI)
Collingwood v St Kilda (Telstra Dome)
West Coast v Fremantle (Subiaco)

Lonie_from_50

25 Feb 2006, 11:47

mcphee_is_a_gun
Essendon v Brisbane Lions
5- B Stanton (Ess)
4- M Voss (Bris)
3- J Brennan (Bris)
2- S Harding (Bris)
1- M Mcveigh (Ess)

*Take note, this is the best way to set out the votes :thumbsu:
**These were gathered from a PM. You can PM me votes, but best to place in the voting threads. The reason why this was sent via PM was because a voting thread was not up on the Board.

Bartram_Class

25 Feb 2006, 12:37

Yze_Class
Melbourne v Western Bulldogs
5 - Shannon Motlop (Melb)
4 - Scott West (WB)
3 - Robert Murphy (WB)
2 - Travis Johnstone (Melb)
1 - Jared Rivers (Melb)

Chadwiko

25 Feb 2006, 15:32

Kangaroos v Sydney

5 D Hale (NM)
4 B Harvey (NM)
3 D Wells (NM)
2 R O'Keefe (Syd)
1 J Gibson (NM)

Kangas_Div

25 Feb 2006, 15:44

Kangas_Div
Kangaroos Vs Sydney
5. Daniel Harris (NM)
4. Shannon Grant (NM)
3. Brent Harvey (NM)
2. Joshua Gibson (NM)
1. Ryan O'Keefe (SYD)

dougk

25 Feb 2006, 20:06

Kangaroos Vs Sydney

5. Shannon Grant (NM)
4. Daniel Harris (NM)
3. Joshua Gibson (NM)
2. Ryan O'Keefe (SYD)
1. Brent Harvey (NM)

grimlock

25 Feb 2006, 20:45

Kangaroos v Sydney

5) Daniel Harris (NM)
4) Shannon Grant (NM)
3) Brady Rawlings (NM)
2) Ryan O'Keefe (Syd)
1) Brent Harvey (NM)

irel

25 Feb 2006, 20:59

Essendon v Brisbane Lions

5- M Voss (Bris)
4- B Stanton (Ess)
3- S Harding (Bris)
2- J Brennan (Bris)
1- M Mcveigh (Ess)

philhawk

25 Feb 2006, 21:05

Hawthorn vs Richmond

(5) - Mark Williams (Haw)
(4) - Chance Bateman (Haw)
(3) - Shane Tuck (Rich)
(2) - Brent Guerra (Haw)
(1) - Brett Deledio (Rich)

hilly

25 Feb 2006, 21:10

Kangaroos Vs Sydney

5. Shannon Grant (NM)
4. Daniel Harris (NM)
3. Joshua Gibson (NM)
2. Ryan O'Keefe (SYD)
1. Brent Harvey (NM)

Same for me thanks

Mr.Likeable

25 Feb 2006, 21:27

H v R

5 Jacobs (H)
4 Deledio (R)
3 Tuck (R)
2 Williams (H)
1 Guerra (H)

DBAH0

25 Feb 2006, 21:32

Geelong vs. Carlton

5 Kent Kingsley (G)
4 Matthew Lappin (C)
3 Matthew Scarlett (G)
2 Jimmy Bartel (G)
1 Nick Stevens (C)

Hu$$ey

25 Feb 2006, 21:37

Hu$$ey
Carlton vs Geelong

5. Kent Kingsley (GEEL)
4. Matthew Scarlett (GEEL)
3. Matthew Lappin (CARL)
2. Nick Stevens (CARL)
1. Lance Whitnall (CARL)

XXX KINGS

25 Feb 2006, 21:53

XXX KINGS
Carlton vs Geelong

5 - Kent Kingsley
4 - Matthew Scarlett
3 - Nick Stevens
2 - Lance Whitnall
1 - Brad Fisher

sante

25 Feb 2006, 22:31

sante
Richmond v Hawthorn

5 - Mark Williams (HAW)
4 - Brent Guerra (HAW)
3 - Shane Tuck (RICH)
2 - Brent Hartigan (RICH)
1 - Chance Bateman (HAW)

OldSchool

25 Feb 2006, 22:32

Bulldogs vs Dees

5: S Motlop
4: J Rivers
3: R Murphy
2: R Robertson
1: B Johnson

Helix

25 Feb 2006, 23:10

Essendon v Brisbane Lions

5- M Voss (Bris)
4- B Stanton (Ess)
3- J Brennan (Bris)
2- M McVeigh (Ess)
1- M Clarke (Bris)

stokesy

25 Feb 2006, 23:34

Carlton vs Geelong

5 - Kent Kingley (Geelong)
4 - Matthew Scarlet (Geelong)
3 - Matthew Lappin (Carlton)
2 - Lance Whitnall (Carlton)
1 - Setanta O'Hailpin (Carlton)

Hard Ball Get

25 Feb 2006, 23:44

Melbourne v Western Bulldogs
5. Danial Motlop
4. Danial Giansiracusa
5. Robert Murphy
2. Travis Johnstone
1. Brad Johnson

fugsy

26 Feb 2006, 01:30

Geelong v Carlton

5. M. Scarlett (Geel)
4. K. Kingsley (Geel)
3. M. Lappin (Carl)
2. A. Houlihan (Carl)
1. S. Byrnes (Geel)

Longy413

26 Feb 2006, 08:35

Essendon v Brisbane Lions

5- M Voss (Bris)
4- B Stanton (Ess)
3- J Brennan (Bris)
2- M Mcveigh (Ess)
1- S Harding (Bris)

rizzo

26 Feb 2006, 09:43

Geelong Vrs Carlton

5- Kent Kingsley
4- Mathew Scarlett
3- Nick Stevens
2- James Kelly
1- Mathew Lappin

DaSawx

26 Feb 2006, 10:07

DaSawx
Brisbane v Essendon
5 - M.Voss (Bris)
4 - S.Harding (Bris)
3 - B.Stanton (Ess)
2 - J.Brennan (Bris)
1 - M.McVeigh (Ess)

Funkalicous

26 Feb 2006, 11:48

Funk's votes: :cool:

Geelong vs Carlton

5- Kent-bloody-Kingsley ;) (Geel)
4- Nick Stevens (Carl)
3- Mathew Scarlett (Geel)
2- Brad Fisher (Carl)
1- Mathew Lappin (Carl)

cogs24

26 Feb 2006, 12:09

cogs24
Hawthorn V Richmond
5. Mark Williams
4. Danny Jacobs
3. Brett Deledio
2. Shane Tuck
1. Chance Bateman

Ed_Gein

26 Feb 2006, 12:31

Nth Melbourne v Sydney

5- Daniel Harris (NM)
4- Brady Rawlings (NM)
3- Brent Harvey (NM)
2- Ryan O'Keefe (Syd)
1- Adam Prior (Syd)

Roughie

26 Feb 2006, 15:53

Roughie-Emergency

Hawthorn vs Richmond

(5) - Mark Williams (Haw)
(4) - Shane Tuck (Rich)
(3) - Brent Guerra (Haw)
(2) - Danny Jacobs (Haw)
(1) - Kane Johnson (Rich)

jo172

26 Feb 2006, 15:53

Jo172

Adelaide Vs. Power

5. S. Goodwin (Adel)
4. T. Hentshel (Adel)
3. C. Knights (Adel)
2. S. Salopeck (Paps)
1. B. Burton (Adel)

Bartram_Class

26 Feb 2006, 16:33

Melbourne v Western Bulldogs
5. Danial Motlop
4. Danial Giansiracusa
5. Robert Murphy
2. Travis Johnstone
1. Brad Johnson
Its Shannon mate. ;)

Smokin_Joe

26 Feb 2006, 18:06

Smokin_Joe

Brisbane v Essendon

5.M.Voss(Bris)
4.B.Stanton(Ess)
3.J.Brennan(Bris)
2.M.McVeigh(Ess)
1.S.Harding(Bris)

Kildonan

26 Feb 2006, 18:53

StKildonan
Collingwood v St Kilda

5 S O,Bree Coll
4 P Licuria Coll
3 L Hayes St K
2 L Ball St K
1 B Goddard St K

FIGJAM

26 Feb 2006, 19:41

FIGJAM
Collingwood vs St Kilda

5 - Jason Cloke
4 - Paul Licuria
3 - Luke Ball
2 - Lenny Hayes
1 - Shane O'Bree

Coin_Toss

26 Feb 2006, 19:50

Coin_Toss
Collingwood vs St Kilda

5. Jason Cloke COLL
4. Shane O'Bree COLL
3. Luke Ball STK
2. Paul Licuria COLL
1. Tarkyn Lockyer COLL

Kildonan

26 Feb 2006, 20:22

Coin_Toss
Collingwood vs St Kilda

5. Jason Cloke COLL
4. Shane O'Bree COLL
3. Luke Ball STK
2. Paul Licuria COLL
1. Tarkyn Lockyer COLL

Just an observation - 12 votes (Coll)to 3 votes (St K) in a match decided by a point

Coin_Toss

26 Feb 2006, 20:25

Just an observation - 12 votes (Coll)to 3 votes (St K) in a match decided by a point

Jason Cloke, Shane O'Bree, Paul Licuria and Tarkyn Lockyer all deserved votes, mate.

Macca19

26 Feb 2006, 20:41

Macca19

Adelaide vs Port Adelaide

5. T Hentschel (A)
4. B Burton (A)
3. S Goodwin (A)
2. S Salopek (P)
1. C Knights (A)

Hoggy

26 Feb 2006, 20:47

Hoggy

Wizard Emirates Adidas Magpies vs St.Kilda

5. Jason Cloke (COLL)
4. Brodie Holland (COLL)
3. Luke Ball (STK)
2. Tarkyn Lockyer (COLL)
1. Shane O'Bree (COLL)

Lonie_from_50

26 Feb 2006, 20:47

Collingwood v St Kilda

5. Jason Cloke (COLL)
4. Shane O'Bree (COLL)
3. Paul Licuria (COLL)
2. Brendon Goddard (STK)
1. Luke Ball (STK)

Cloke was clearly BOG, saved the day, was courageous, determined, 1%ers, found the ball, contested ball. O'Bree turned it on and Lica was just a ball magnet, and despite the 1 pt win, they were all the top 3 performers.

Locky

26 Feb 2006, 20:50

West Coast v Fremantle

5. Luke McPharlin (Frem)
4. Byron Shammer (Frem)
3. Peter Bell (Frem)
2. Matt Rosa (WCE)
1. Ben Cousins (WCE)

Kapow!!!

26 Feb 2006, 20:54

Kapow!!!
West Coast Eagles vs Fremantle Dockers

5. Paul Haselby (FRE)
4. Josh Carr (FRE)
3. Byron Schammer (FRE)
2. Ben Cousins (WCE)
1. Luke McPharlin (FRE)

Unlucky Bell, Medhurst, Nicoski, Rosa, M.Carr

Kapow!!!

26 Feb 2006, 20:56

West Coast v Fremantle

5. Luke McPharlin (Frem)
4. Byron Shammer (Frem)
3. Peter Bell (Frem)
2. Matt Rosa (WCE)
1. Ben Cousins (WCE)

Poor Haselby. 29 Possessions. Always there, always picking up and delivering.

Pie 4 Life

26 Feb 2006, 21:31

Pie 4 Life

Collingwood vs St. Kilda

5 Paul Licuria (COLL)
4 Nick Riewoldt (STK)
3 Shane O'Bree (COLL)
2 Jason Cloke (COLL)
1 Brodie Holland (COLL)

Ripper

26 Feb 2006, 22:01

Ripper

5: Haselby (Fremantle)
4: Medhurst (Fremantle)
3: Macpharlan (Fremantle)
2: Schammer (Fremantle)
1: Crowley (Fremantle)

Ben just missed out on a vote because of too many turnovers.

weagles_fan

26 Feb 2006, 22:32

West Coast Eagles vs Fremantle Dockers

5. Josh Carr (FRE)
4. Peter Bell (FRE)
3. Luke McPharlin (FRE)
2. Paul Hasleby (FRE)
1. Matt Rosa (WCE)

wez10000

26 Feb 2006, 22:58

Richmond v Hawthorn

5 - Chance Bateman (Haw)
4 - Shane Tuck (Rich)
3 - Brent Guerra (Haw)
2 - Mark Williams (Haw)
1 - Kane Johnson (Rich)

billybrownless16

26 Feb 2006, 23:10

5. Matthew Scarlett
4. Kent Kingsley
3. Matthew Lappin
2. James Kelly
1. Nick Stevens

And a consolation vote to the Carlton runner for his shepherd, I think it was on Scarlett, beautifully done:thumbsu:

Grendel

26 Feb 2006, 23:29

Hawthorn vs Richmond

5 D.Jacobs (Haw)
4. S.Tuck (Ric)
3. B. Guerra (Haw)
2. B. Deledio (Ric)
1. M. Williams (Haw)

Locky

26 Feb 2006, 23:41

Poor Haselby. 29 Possessions. Always there, always picking up and delivering.
I only listened to it on the radio since it wasnt on Free to Air Tv pretty easy to miss his possies on Radio because he gets it and gets rid of it quickly and effectively

sainter

27 Feb 2006, 01:04

Just an observation - 12 votes (Coll)to 3 votes (St K) in a match decided by a point

We've made some giant strides in the last couple of years and the expectations are a lot greater. Personally I thought the score flattered us. Collingwood were the better team and we got a decent hit out.

Sainter

Collingwood vs St Kilda

5 - Jason Cloke (COLL)
4 - Paul Licuria (COLL)
3 - Lenny Hayes (STK)
2 - Shane O'Bree (COLL)
1 - Nick Riewoldt (STK)

Johnson#26

27 Feb 2006, 05:54

Collingwood vs St.Kilda:
Johnson#26
5: P.Licuria (Coll)
4: J.Cloke (Coll)
3: N.Riewoldt (St.K)
2: S.O'Bree (Coll)
1: L.Hayes (St.K)

portentous

27 Feb 2006, 07:35

Portentous

Port Adelaide vs Adelaide
5. Trent Henschtel (A)
4. Brett Burton (A)
3. Steve Salopek (PA)
2. Chris Knights (A)
1. Simon Goodwin (A)

The Flying Belgian

27 Feb 2006, 08:27

Brisbane vs Essendon

The Flying Belgian

5 - Voss (BL)
4 - McVeigh (E)
3 - Harding (BL)
2 - Stanton (E)
1 - Brennan (BL)

crows98

27 Feb 2006, 09:12

NAB cup round 1 - Crows98

Adelaide Crows Vs. Port Adelaide Power

5) Trent Hentschel
4) Simon Goodwin
3) Ian Perrie
2) Brett Burton
1) Chris Knights.

macca69

27 Feb 2006, 09:44

5 McPharlin
4 Schammer
3 Bell
2 Medhurst
1 Cousins

inferno66

27 Feb 2006, 10:03

Freo vs Eagles

5 Luke Mc Pharlin
4 Paul Haselby
3 Josh Carr
2 Schammer
1 Cousins

Cassius_Clay

27 Feb 2006, 11:39

5 McPharlin
4 Schammer
3 Bell
2 Medhurst
1 Cousins
SCHAMMER!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!! !!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!!

FIGJAM

27 Feb 2006, 11:51

5 S O,Bree Coll
4 P Licuria Coll
3 L Hayes St K
2 L Ball St K
1 B Goddard St K

Just an observation - 12 votes (Coll)to 3 votes (St K) in a match decided by a point
Just an observation, but three out of five players St Kilda players voted for in a flattering scoreline for you, and Brendon Goddard ahead of Jason Cloke? :p

There'll be some bias St Kildonan. Just do your best to avoid it, and it'll make this worthwhile.

Falchoon

27 Feb 2006, 12:46

Collingwood vs St.Kilda:

5: P.Licuria (Coll)
4: J.Cloke (Coll)
3: N.Riewoldt (St.K)
2: T.Lockyer (Coll)
1: L.Hayes (St.K)

HeLMie

27 Feb 2006, 15:14

North v Half the swans side.

5. Harro
4. Harvey
3. O'Keefe
2. Grant
1. Gibbo

Vic Crow

27 Feb 2006, 16:58

Adelaide vs. Port

5: Trent Hentschel (Adel)
4: Chris Knights (Adel)
3: Simon Goodwin (Adel)
2: Brett Burton (Adel)
1: Ian Perrie (Adel)

Don't want to sound biased, but it was a 72 point blowout with Salopek being the pick of the other mob, but not good enough to crack votes in such a big loss.

Cassius_Clay

27 Feb 2006, 17:47

Fremantle V West Coast

5. Paul Hasleby
4. Byron Schammer
3. Luke McPharlin
2. Josh Carr
1. Mark Nicoski

Bockchoy67

27 Feb 2006, 18:01

Adelaide vs Port Adelaide

5. S. Goodwin (Adel)
4. B. Burton (Adel)
3. C. Knights (Adel)
2. T. Hentschel (Adel)
1. S. Salopek (Port)

JeffDunne

27 Feb 2006, 18:10

Collingwood vs St.Kilda

5 - Licuria (Coll)
4 - J.Cloke (Coll)
3 - Riewoldt (StK)
2 - Hayes (StK)
1 - Goddard (StK)

m.diddy

27 Feb 2006, 18:30

Mine are

Pies V Saints
5. Cloke
4. Licuria
3. Riewoldt
2. obree
1. Ball

mad-saint-guy

27 Feb 2006, 18:32

Sorry for being late but..

Collingwood vs St Kilda

5: Licuria (Coll)
4: J.Cloke (Coll)
3: Riewoldt (StK)
2: Ball (StK)
1: Goddard (StK)

macca69

27 Feb 2006, 20:17

Fremantle V West Coast

5. Paul Hasleby
4. Byron Schammer
3. Luke McPharlin
2. Josh Carr
1. Mark Nicoski

thought u could only vote when the team u support was playing.

Lonie_from_50

27 Feb 2006, 20:35

Brilliant Pies has been named a Fremantle voter in the absence of Schammerman#3 ;)....if another Freo supporter steps up then he will be replaced, if not, then it is okay (i guess)

However all participants can have their say on this matter!!!!!!

LukeHodge15

27 Feb 2006, 22:40

cannot comment as yet.

away for the weekend. hoping to catch the replay on some time this week.

Choota

28 Feb 2006, 05:53

5. Bateman
4. Guerra
3. Williams
2. Jacobs
1. Tuck

Lonie_from_50

28 Feb 2006, 08:02

cheers to everyone who voted/replied in this trial. If you did not reply and are a participant, they will be expecting a PM.

Lonie_from_50

28 Feb 2006, 08:30

Funkalicous

28 Feb 2006, 11:53

Results from Trial

Premium voters
53 replied, 27 didn't
Emergency voters
7 replied, 9 didn't
Teams interest (/6)
Adelaide - 4
Brisbane Lions - 3
Carlton - 4
Collingwood - 6
Essendon - 4
Fremantle - 4
Geelong - 4
Hawthorn - 4*
Kangaroos - 4
Melbourne - 1
Port Adelaide - 2
Richmond - 3
St.Kilda - 6
Sydney - 3
West Coast Eagles - 3
W Bulldogs - 2

*Hawks had 2 non-voters vote! :)

That's not a bad result for the first trial. I knew Carlton wouldn't get all six voters this week. TheOldDarkNavy's was on holidays, and Thalidomide has been AWOL for a couple of weeks.

Kildonan

28 Feb 2006, 17:32

Just an observation, but three out of five players St Kilda players voted for in a flattering scoreline for you, and Brendon Goddard ahead of Jason Cloke? :p

There'll be some bias St Kildonan. Just do your best to avoid it, and it'll make this worthwhile.

That was unnecessary FIGJAM, I made an observation when these votes didn't count for anything, to ensure that later votes were as meaningful as possible.

FYI Cloke was playing on a five match veteran, a first timer to CHF - I took this into consideration when deciding my votes, along with stats which I consider telling.

Lonie_from_50

28 Feb 2006, 18:26

Not anything to do with Stkildonan's comment, but Cloke however, will always be underrated by the public!

billybrownless16

28 Feb 2006, 20:17

Did it take you long to tally them up Lonie?

Lonie_from_50

28 Feb 2006, 20:35

Yet to tally results...and probably won't considering it wasn't completed in the necessary way (inconsistent numbers)...I assume it will take a fair time to do, but without myself being given a deadline to place votes onto here (they wont be posted up, read info on Medal thread), things should be alright.

Embers

1 Mar 2006, 15:34

Me forgot, better late then never

Fremantle v West Coast

5. Paul Haselby
4. Luke McPharlin
3. Paul Medhurst
2. Josh Carr
1. Matt Rosa

macca69

1 Mar 2006, 15:43

Me forgot, better late then never

Fremantle v West Coast

5. Matt Rosa
4. Ben Cousins
3. Mark Seaby
2. Daniel Kerr
1. Matthew Priddis

can he do that?

LukeHodge15

1 Mar 2006, 16:18

Me forgot, better late then never

Fremantle v West Coast

5. Matt Rosa
4. Ben Cousins
3. Mark Seaby
2. Daniel Kerr
1. Matthew Priddis

u seriously saying that rosa was best on ground the other night???????

i know he is your love child, but seriously:eek: :rolleyes:

F-U

1 Mar 2006, 17:32

Reading this thread has me very confused, are people supposed to be voting for there team only or do they incorporate both teams in there votes, its quite clear here no one understands the rules of this.

Lonie_from_50

1 Mar 2006, 17:42

Hard Ball Get

1 Mar 2006, 19:57

The rules on the BigFooty Medal thread state everything, and that is, you vote on the game your team played, and you vote on the game votes, not the club votes.

I presume that Embers has voted on the WCE performances only. It is votes towards both teams (unless in his view, all 5 of those players deserved votes ahead of Hasleby, Carr, McPharlin :D)

I'm sure Embers has the rules mistaken. It is a good thing we had this trial run.
No one in their right mind would have had those votes if voting for both teams.

Embers

2 Mar 2006, 10:06

Lonie_from_50

2 Mar 2006, 17:48

Yeah, lol

Rosa was good though :thumbsu:

The Old Dark Navy's

2 Mar 2006, 18:55

Mine would have been:

5. Kingsley (Geel)
4. Scarlett (Geel)
3. Lappin (Carl)
2. Fisher (Carl)
1. French (Carl)

jackson_rules

3 Mar 2006, 21:00

for mine last week.

5. Williams
4. Bateman
3. K.Johnson
2. Croad
1. Deledio

Bartram_Class

4 Mar 2006, 23:32

Are you going to put up a Second Round thread for votes Lonie?

jackson_rules

5 Mar 2006, 12:56

Are you going to put up a Second Round thread for votes Lonie?
i wouldnt mind giving a few votes for the doggies vs tigers game:D

wez10000

5 Mar 2006, 13:27

i wouldnt mind giving a few votes for the doggies vs tigers game:D

5. Andrew Krakouer
4. Chris Hyde
3. Andrew Kellaway
2. Brett Deledio
1. Andrew Raines

and thats going through both teams :D

Thunderstruck

5 Mar 2006, 21:08

Dunno is it's gunna be counted or not but here it is anyways:

Hawthorn V Adelaide:

Thunderstruck:

5) Ladson
4) Mitchell
3) Reilly
2) Hentschel
1) Mcleod

Lonie_from_50

5 Mar 2006, 21:38

not gonna be counted, but everyone always is able to place their NAB votes in here for fun anyway.

Collingwood v Fremantle
5. P.Hasleby (F)
4. J.Farmer (F)
3. C.Tarrant (C)
2. M.Carr (F)
1. J.Carr (F)