View Full Version : Johnson vs Johnson
Which Johnson is the best player?
Why isnt Kane in there?
oops sorry good call... I want to put him in but I can't work out how to edit the poll :(
Darealrath
27 Mar 2006, 17:50
Or Chris.
I love Mark and Jason to bits so i refuse to vote for anyone else, though Brad is probably the best overall.
Lynch drops a mark
27 Mar 2006, 17:58
Jason for mine
Jean Claude Vas Deferens
27 Mar 2006, 18:23
As much as I like Jason and Chris, it has to be Brad and can I state categorically that I would go that way even if l didn't barrack for the Doggies. He is a sensational footballer!
samthemanlonergan
27 Mar 2006, 18:56
Brad Johnson is the best player.
But we have two so that more than makes up for it :).
Go the Shampoo brothers.
davey_magik
27 Mar 2006, 19:04
Jason by a smidge over Brad thanks.
Steve Johnson could be better than them all.
vinnie_vegas69
27 Mar 2006, 19:09
Brad Johnson is the best of them, but if they were all put in a draft together, I'd be taking Steve, that's for sure.
Coin_Toss
28 Mar 2006, 08:07
No Ben Johnson?
jules101
28 Mar 2006, 12:26
lol i could tell the starter of this poll was a Geelong supporter by looking at the names. David Johnson included????
Boris_Bewick
28 Mar 2006, 15:30
Or Chris.
I love Mark and Jason to bits so i refuse to vote for anyone else, though Brad is probably the best overall.
Me too but have to vote for Brad, easily the in the top 5 most consistant players in the AFL, can play tall, short, or in the midfield. Probably a bit underrated I would say compared to other players.
TheGeneral
28 Mar 2006, 16:28
Brad Johnson by a mile! :thumbsu:
He's a legend and one of the few opposition players I like. :)
Melbourne Lion
28 Mar 2006, 16:35
imo
1.Brad
2.Chris
3.Jason
4.Kane
5.Mark
6.Ben(will finish career a little higher than this)
6.David/Steve
samthemanlonergan
28 Mar 2006, 19:03
Lol, Ben Johnson.
Mr 25 disposals, 18 of which are ineffective.
Darealrath
28 Mar 2006, 20:45
imo
1.Brad
2.Chris
3.Jason
4.Kane
5.Mark
6.Ben(will finish career a little higher than this)
6.David/Steve
If anything Ben will finish lower. Not in the class of the first 5.
Presti_is_god
28 Mar 2006, 21:15
Brad easily.
Raskolnikov
28 Mar 2006, 21:30
As tempted as I am to vote for Jason or Mark I have to say Brad.
Warwick
28 Mar 2006, 22:14
Great idea for a poll - pity you missed 3 of them. :rolleyes:
I noticed you remembered the two Geelong players though.
IMO:
Brad
Chris
Jason
Kane
Steve
Mark
Ben
David
Melbourne Lion
29 Mar 2006, 10:09
If anything Ben will finish lower. Not in the class of the first 5.
Your probably right sometimes I try to over correct my Anti Collingwood opinion to be fair.:D
celtic_pride
31 Mar 2006, 13:37
Lol, Ben Johnson.
Mr 25 disposals, 18 of which are ineffective.
What he said ...
How anyone could say Ben is the best Johnson is a deluded Pies fan, he's disposal has improved, but still pretty woeful.
I nearly voted for JJ, but in the end Brad Johnson's class over the years just swings it for me, although by the end of this year I could see Jason becoming a bettter player as Brad starts to get older.
Cyclops
31 Mar 2006, 15:04
Brad from Kane, both excellent.
Pie 4 Life
31 Mar 2006, 18:01
Jason only just over Brad because of age.
Hard Ball Get
1 Apr 2006, 11:21
Brad by the length of the Flemington straight.
samthemanlonergan
1 Apr 2006, 15:56
Brad by the length of the Flemington straight.
Not quite. Is the best there, but not by a hell of a lot.
Bulldog1954
3 Apr 2006, 18:42
1. Brad
2. Mark
3. Jason
4. Kane
5. Chris
No Contest...
The man with the smile.
Come on, are you serious? Brad Johnson is an absolute superstar, All-Australian who has proven himself over a long period. Brilliantly skilled, quick and an absolute pleasure to watch. Always gives 100% and I can't ever remember him playing a bad game.
Great idea for a poll - pity you missed 3 of them. :rolleyes:
I noticed you remembered the two Geelong players though.
IMO:
Brad
Chris
Jason
Kane
Steve
Mark
Ben
David
Still missing one: Michael Johnson from Freo. The way we are going with Robert Haddrill, he might soon be our FB :eek:
If I had to draft one tomorrow, it would be Brad Johnson whilst Kane Johnson is underrated - I would probably choose him next.
What he said ...
How anyone could say Ben is the best Johnson is a deluded Pies fan, he's disposal has improved, but still pretty woeful.
I nearly voted for JJ, but in the end Brad Johnson's class over the years just swings it for me, although by the end of this year I could see Jason becoming a bettter player as Brad starts to get older.
He may not be the best Johnson but he isn't a turnover king you make him out to be. He is a very effective kick especially long and direct into the forward line
31 possesions on the weekend, 27 kicks and 21 of them effective and only 2 clangers. 10 inside 50s at the very least 6 of them resulting in goals.
Clearly best on ground besides Rocca in round 2.
2005 really mucked him up, whether it was just injury or form, if he continued with his 2004 form he would be held in higher esteem.