View Full Version : Brett Deledio or Marc Murphy?
Mr Crow!
6 Apr 2006, 02:31
Brett Deledio or Marc Murphy?
TheGeneral
6 Apr 2006, 02:56
Ryan Griffen.
Deledio. Not knocking murphy, he is good - but deledio has the body, height, pace and skills to be an elite player. Murphy is good, but he won't be quite the player.
Fair assessment at this stage
Sammy "Extractor" Mithell
6 Apr 2006, 09:17
I will never respect Deledio. If he was taken at say pick 50, no body would give a rats about him.
the onyl reason everybody knows who he is, is because last year he was on the back page every week for absolutley no reason.
I am not trying to start anybody, but just take a step back and have a look at all the other players who could easily match it with brett, but never get given a go.
dipper86
6 Apr 2006, 10:16
I will never respect Deledio. If he was taken at say pick 50, no body would give a rats about him.
the onyl reason everybody knows who he is, is because last year he was on the back page every week for absolutley no reason.
I am not trying to start anybody, but just take a step back and have a look at all the other players who could easily match it with brett, but never get given a go.
Say NO to drugs!!!!!!!!!!!
AC for PM
6 Apr 2006, 10:31
Brettles.
IM not sure how you can compare the 2. Marc Murphy has played 1 game of AFL.
They are both talented players but I would have to take Delido.
Sanguinarius
6 Apr 2006, 15:14
can we at least wait till they've both played a season?
stupid comparison at the momment.
GRANGE_GSM
6 Apr 2006, 15:59
they are both guns but id haf deledio over murphy and thomas......ud look at deledio at 189cm,runs 20m in 2.80 and then you got murphy whos 179cm n runs 20m in 2.99.....murphy is a gun but id have deledio at geelong b4 both of them together....deledio=gun
I will never respect Deledio. If he was taken at say pick 50, no body would give a rats about him.
the onyl reason everybody knows who he is, is because last year he was on the back page every week for absolutley no reason.
I am not trying to start anybody, but just take a step back and have a look at all the other players who could easily match it with brett, but never get given a go.
Same goes for all #1 picks :rolleyes:
Deledio easily, he's played 23 games and Murphy just the one :rolleyes:
roostertalk
6 Apr 2006, 16:39
I will never respect Deledio. If he was taken at say pick 50, no body would give a rats about him.
the onyl reason everybody knows who he is, is because last year he was on the back page every week for absolutley no reason.
I am not trying to start anybody, but just take a step back and have a look at all the other players who could easily match it with brett, but never get given a go.
nobody will ever ever dispute the fact ur a grade "A" W$nker!
lets not respect the kid because of the herald suns decision to make him a pin up boy. You obviously have no clue about our great game if you cant at least respect somebody who is looking to be a future champion of the leauge..,..... wake up to yourself, im sure brett didnt ring and ask to have the burden and responsibility of being one of the games elite in his second year of footy, its twits like you that make such a position so undesirable.
Marc Murphy looks a freak..... but i cant respect him, the weeks leading up to the draft and after....his head was everywhere.... the nerve of the kid....hope he has a shocker
Mr Crow!
6 Apr 2006, 18:20
Marc Murphy looks a freak..... but i cant respect him, the weeks leading up to the draft and after....his head was everywhere.... the nerve of the kid....hope he has a shocker
What do you mean by this? Of course any player who is "annoited" as the number one draft pick by the media and people like Kevin Sheehan, will get a lot of coverage in the press.
roostertalk
7 Apr 2006, 14:25
What do you mean by this? Of course any player who is "annoited" as the number one draft pick by the media and people like Kevin Sheehan, will get a lot of coverage in the press.
.... my point exactly mr crow, i was merely taking the ******** out of that other idiot. i rate murphy very high and respect him
Stupid, stupid comparison (but I had to be a hypocrite and vote :p). Obviously I voted for Deledio and I don't think Murphy will probably ever match Deledio's class BUT having said that, he had a better debut than Brett ;)
I'm the Juggernaut
7 Apr 2006, 15:46
I will never respect Deledio. If he was taken at say pick 50, no body would give a rats about him.
the onyl reason everybody knows who he is, is because last year he was on the back page every week for absolutley no reason.
I am not trying to start anybody, but just take a step back and have a look at all the other players who could easily match it with brett, but never get given a go.
you sir are a ******** wit
Coughlan
7 Apr 2006, 16:18
I will never respect Deledio. If he was taken at say pick 50, no body would give a rats about him.
the onyl reason everybody knows who he is, is because last year he was on the back page every week for absolutley no reason.
I am not trying to start anybody, but just take a step back and have a look at all the other players who could easily match it with brett, but never get given a go.
would you care to name these "many" players that made their debut last year at 17 years old who could step it up.
correct me if im wrong, but your man Sam Mitchell wasnt even in the AFL when he was 18 was he;) , imagine how good Brett will be when he is Sam's age:rolleyes:
grinspoon
11 Apr 2006, 00:04
Dale Thomas:cool:
DynamoUltra
11 Apr 2006, 00:08
Dale Thomas:cool:
And some people wonder why BigFooty is in the degenerative state that it is. What's wrong with answering the question/poll put forward? Maybe you should go start a www.daisythatsagirlsnamethomas.com.au so all you inbred Magpies can blow your load as much as you want without disrupting others.
As for the original post, I'll stick with the cliche, "it's too early to tell, but to this point I'll have Deledio," line.
Mr Crow!
13 Apr 2006, 15:49
ryan griffen
I haven't really seen much from this kid yet to justify all the hype from the Doggies supporters.
landdownunder
16 Apr 2006, 21:14
IM not sure how you can compare the 2. Marc Murphy has played 1 game of AFL.
They are both talented players but I would have to take Delido.
exactly mate..well said
Mr Crow!
4 Jun 2006, 14:50
So, has any opinion changed after Carlton's 9 games this year?
I would rate them pretty much even, in terms of potential and team contribution.