View Full Version : BF Medal - Rnd 4 - Carlton vs Hawthorn
Lonie_from_50
21 Apr 2006, 10:17
Voting Thread
http://img60.imageshack.us/img60/7126/carlton7dv.png Vs http://img227.imageshack.us/img227/1403/hawthorn3ca.png
Round 4 - 2006 - Telstra Dome
Designated voters
Funkalicious
Hu$$ey
stokesy
The Old Dark Navy's
mojo31
XXX KINGS
cschreuder61
dipper86
Grendel
LukeHodge15
philhawk
Roughie
Voting details, rules and new announcements (http://bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=230997)
philhawk
22 Apr 2006, 01:21
Great win,
5. Luke Hodge
4. Trent Croad
3. Shane Crawford
2. Sam Mitchell
1. Lance Whitnall
Unlucky,
Danny Jacobs and Andrew Walker
Grendel
22 Apr 2006, 07:33
5 - Croad (Haw)
4 - Whitnall (Carl)
3 - Stevens (Carl)
2 - Hodge (Haw)
1 - Sewell (Haw)
The Old Dark Navy's
22 Apr 2006, 07:52
5. Hodge (Haw) - Sublime skills, great vision
4. Croad (Haw) - Set the tone early
3. Whitnall (Carl) - One man band up forward
2. Walker (Carl) - Stemmed the tide, plenty of dash
1. Crawford (Haw) - Found the right options, knows when to go and when not to
Mitchell Madness
22 Apr 2006, 11:10
5. Hodge-superb play, held the midfield together
4. Croad-Held the forward line together
3. Whitnall-only carlton player to make a contest
2. Crawford-stuck in there all night and was best player for hawthorn in the first half
1. Dawson-great game, plenty of 1 percenters everyone forgets about, constantly out of position and managed to spoil, and recover, few mistakes, but was still good.
would have given Nick Stevens the one vote, but i was at the game, and over half his posessions were uncontested, or in 3-on-1 contests where the only opponent was behind a wall of Carlton players.
Funkalicous
22 Apr 2006, 11:44
Funk's Votes: :cool:
5- L.Whitnall
4- S.Crawford
3- T.Croad
2- L.Hodge
1- R.Houlihan
5. Croad
4. Whitnall
3. Hodge
2. Walker
1. Crawford
stokesy
23 Apr 2006, 17:41
5. Trent Croad - took David Parkin medal, kicked a bag.
4. Lance Whitnall - if he had of kicked more goals, he would of been BOG.
3. Luke Hodge - played beautifully.
2. Andrew Walker - one of his best efforts.
1. Shane Crawford - touched the ball many times.
XXX KINGS
23 Apr 2006, 20:14
5. T Croad
4. L Whitnall
3. L Hodge
2. A Walker
1. S Mitchell
Roughie
23 Apr 2006, 20:59
5. Croad
4. Hodge
3. Whitnall
2. Walker
1. Crawford
LukeHodge15
23 Apr 2006, 21:50
5. Trent Croad-best forward on the ground-virtually won the hawks the match in the first quarter
4. Luke Hodge-this guy is clearly top 10 in the league and rising fast
3. Lance Whitnal-whatta a game after the towelling he had in the 1st quarter, unbelievable......pagan gotta leave him forward ?
2. Brad Sewell-great game down back for the hawks, never put a foot wrong, wanna see him rotated through the midfield
1. Nick Stevens-about 5 players coulda had the 1 vote, eneded up going with stevens
5) Trent Croad
4) Luke Hodge
3) Lance Whitnall
2) Shane Crawford
1) Andrew Walker
Hawthorn used the ball better and have more class, composure and skill. Carlton are about at the level Hawthorn were at least year. Competitive and trying hard but not able to finish off there work and lack of conversion in front of goal looks like aproblem for the Blues based on the 4 games already.
Hawthorn are 1 quality KPP away from being a good side.
Lonie_from_50
25 Apr 2006, 21:13
Well done Blues, waiting on dippers and schreuds, if they don't submit there votes by tomorrow, MM's votes will be counted I guess.
cschreuder61
26 Apr 2006, 20:10
sorry for the late votes
5. Trent Croad.
4. Lance Whitnall
3. Luke Hodge.
2. Brad Sewell
1. S. Crawford
dipper86
30 Apr 2006, 21:01
5. Croad
4. Hodge
3.whitnall
2.Walker.
1.Crawford.