PDA

View Full Version : Who is the greatest CHF of the Modern Era?

Mr Crow!
23 Apr 2006, 18:16
Who is the greatest CHF of the Modern Era?
_Ron_
23 Apr 2006, 18:25
You're missing Bernie Quinlan who was before my time but watching the replays was only shaded by Carey and no other.

Just thought i'd add that.

:)
TheGeneral
23 Apr 2006, 18:26
Ian Perrie.
mujii
23 Apr 2006, 20:11
What a stupid question.. You should have just left Carey.
ColDawg
23 Apr 2006, 20:15
Theres going to be an enquiry into the person that voted Neitz and charges will be laid
finrod
24 Apr 2006, 01:57
Neitz a CHF? :eek:
gytre
24 Apr 2006, 11:31
Some very fine players in that lot, but you can't possibly go past Carey.
Richo83
24 Apr 2006, 22:35
Matthew Richardson :D

If Neitz gets in then where is Hall?
The Reaper
24 Apr 2006, 23:55
Mitch White:D
Meshugeh
25 Apr 2006, 01:30
Kelvin Templeton....won a Brownlow as a CHF.

Wayne Carey....could have won a Brownlow, but loved to backchat the umps.

Chris Grant....should have won a Brownlow, but Ian Collins though he was God and overuled 3 field umpires, 2 boundary umpires and 2 goal umpires.
Infamy
25 Apr 2006, 16:18
Carey, but Brown may be better by the time he retires, he's still only 24
melbdocker
25 Apr 2006, 17:24
carey but i have always said if tredrea played for a victorian club he would be on the back page every week he is the best going round atm
Thewlis Dish
25 Apr 2006, 17:40
Carey, but Brown may be better by the time he retires, he's still only 24

Look up what Duck had achieved by the time he was 24.
The Magenius
26 Apr 2006, 04:25
Doesn't matter because Jacko would have beaten all of them .
greenpike
26 Apr 2006, 04:29
Doesn't matter because Jacko would have beaten all of them .

Before the knee went. Afterwards he was just great.
Jabso
26 Apr 2006, 19:25
Carey quite easily.
Quinlan and Templeton are a bit before the modern era.
I think by the nominations the era was early 90s onwards.
Rough_Edges
26 Apr 2006, 22:00
Riewoldt...:)
utility
28 Apr 2006, 20:58
Carey. Roughly 35% of people who have voted are obviously new to the game.
Infamy
29 Apr 2006, 12:36
Look up what Duck had achieved by the time he was 24.
Yes, but his longevity in the game suffered not long afterwards, if Brown can continue his improvement until he's 30 then he has the potential to be better. There aren't many others in the game that you can say that about.
ALwaysNorth
29 Apr 2006, 14:05
You're missing Bernie Quinlan who was before my time but watching the replays was only shaded by Carey and no other.

Just thought i'd add that.

:)

From memory Bernie played down back at Footscray , only a year or two at CHF at Fitzroy before kicking all those goals as a FF at the end of his career so I would call him a FF more than a CHF.

If the modern era begins with the expansion then the Duck has no one close to him . Royce Hart and Barrie Robran would be up there with him if you included the previous era.
AntiX
30 Apr 2006, 20:01
Riewoldt...:)

haha. i can tell you're judging him based on his absolutely sh1thouse performance against freo today.
Southerntakeover
30 Apr 2006, 21:09
Carey.

Enough said.
aza80
2 May 2006, 13:48
Carey.

Enough said. well said, pointless thread
cobba
2 May 2006, 14:11
Duck!!
Mr Crow!
3 May 2006, 18:33
If Wayne Carey is the greatest CHF of the Modern Era... the modern era which is considered professional, elite, etc... therefore, should Carey be considered the best CHF of ALL-TIME?

There was a 'team of the century', named in 1996 I believe. Carey played on further obviously, including some of his best football. Should he be in the best team of all-time?
celtic_pride
4 May 2006, 15:30
Which Numb Nuts voted for Neitz LOL .They have no clue.
Mr Crow!
4 Jun 2006, 14:46
There have been reports in the media lately that Jonathon Brown could be up there with the all time CHF greats of the modern era, and it came from someone reputable... either Carey or Brereton.

How do you think Brown's season so far has affected his career repuation? I think for the better, as he has been dominating and kicking some big bags of goals.
Hello Newman!
6 Jun 2006, 13:17
Carey then Richo
Wonder Years
6 Jun 2006, 13:25
Riewoldt...:)

This is a poll on best Centre-Half-Forwards not glorified Half-Forward-Flankers! As for Garry Lyon surely he has to be the best Centre-Half-Forward to get a ride off, no wonder the poor bastard had a bad back with players taking hangers over him every game!
TheGeneral
6 Jun 2006, 14:02
Other must have been pretty good! :p :rolleyes:
Lonie_from_50
6 Jun 2006, 14:08
Wayne Carey a shoe in. Modern era = After 2000?

Then you have the answer Mr.J Brown
TheGeneral
6 Jun 2006, 14:11
Deluca.