Which 5 players would you perfer in your team

[bushranger]

Which 5

[big_sav]

south australia

[Armageddon]

If you are wanting me to compare these guys

Cosgrove >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> White (batting ability) and White >>> Cosgrove (bowling ability)
Warne >>>>>>> Cullen
Dizzy >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Denton
Lehmann >>> Hussey

Can't really compare Hodgey and Rofe, but Cossie IMO beats Hodge already.

[bushranger]

Hodge is the best batter out of the lot.

[ablettjnr]

If you are wanting me to compare these guys

Cosgrove >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> White (batting ability) and White >>> Cosgrove (bowling ability)
Warne >>>>>>> Cullen
Dizzy >>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>>> Denton
Lehmann >>> Hussey

Can't really compare Hodgey and Rofe, but Cossie IMO beats Hodge already.
Compare Cosgrove and Hodge, and White to Rofe. That makes much more sense.

[dan warna]

lehman, dizzy and warne stand out as the class players of that lot.


everyone else is a GOP atm

[Bourky23]

how can you turn down anything with warney in it

[eddiesmith]

Victoria, we got Warney :D

[GoSydneySwans]

Victoria, we got Warney :D
Cosgrove,Cullen,Rofe,Lehman, Dizzy are JUST better than Warney if you add them all together. The other Victorians are irrelevant, so South Australia win.

[usalion]

Victoria, we got Warney :D

Pity for y'all he is only a part time player for Victoria....

[eddiesmith]

Pity for y'all he is only a part time player for Victoria....
Half a season is good enough for me

[eddiesmith]

Cosgrove,Cullen,Rofe,Lehman, Dizzy are JUST better than Warney if you add them all together. The other Victorians are irrelevant, so South Australia win.
Hodge > Cosgrove

We win :)

[bushranger]

cossie is a 1year wonder lets see if he can make runs in england then comeback and see if he can have another good season.

[The Reaper]

cossie is a 1year wonder lets see if he can make runs in england then comeback and see if he can have another good season.

As opposed to the no year wonder in White?

Lets se if White can score runs in Australia

[catcozmo]

Cosgrove V Hussey (id choose Cossie, younger, stacks of talent and is a leftie:D)
Lehman V Hodge (hard battle, if same age then Boof, but Hodge has age on his side so gets the nod.)
Rofe V Denton (havent seen enough of either to really make a call, i think Rofe has been more consistent, but i think Denton, would be a better bowler if both bowled to full abiltiy, but Rofe gets nod)
Dizzy V Warne (Ive stuck these 2 against each other, as they are both the best bowlers at respectie teams, and Warne wins hands down.)
Cullen V White (depends if you want batsmen or bowler, White the bat, Cullen the bowler, White would prob be a better bowler then Cullen is batsmen(if that makes sense) really cant choose, would take either, Cullen is a batter prospect for Australia at current stage though, but if White can either turn himself into a full blooded bat, or improve his bowling to a stage where he is a geniue bowling allrounder then who knows.)

So in conclusion id prob go Vics for the Warne factor, plus out of the 2, the Vics have won and competed in a pura cup final over the recnt years, with this crop, and no Warne, so have prob done more.)

[RoosterLad]

I would like to perfer White and Bushranger in the head.

[RoosterLad]

cossie is a 1year wonder lets see if he can make runs in england then comeback and see if he can have another good season.


One year wonder?? He had a good season last season yeah... but before that was Bradman Young Cricketer Of The Year. That doesnt make him a one year wonder you stupid :D:D:D:D.

White is a 0 year wonder if you want to get stupid.

[eddiesmith]

One year wonder?? He had a good season last season yeah... but before that was Bradman Young Cricketer Of The Year. That doesnt make him a one year wonder you stupid :D:D:D:D.

White is a 0 year wonder if you want to get stupid.
In 2004/05 most South Australians were calling for, and I think he was, dropped from the side for being so s***

[Jaymin]

MacGill, Lee, Clark, Jaques, Clarke.

[bombersno1]

Is this for real? Victoria is s..t- they conceded 900 with those hacks in the Cup final! I'd take South Australia!

[spell_check]

Funny, I thought this poll would be like a multiple choice out of 10:

Hodge
Hodge
Hodge
Hodge
Hodge
White
White
White
White
White

[Sanguinarius]

one player does not amke a side... so south australia

and tait would be above rofe in the pecking order anyway.... so south australia even more

[catcozmo]

Is this for real? Victoria is s..t- they conceded 900 with those hacks in the Cup final! I'd take South Australia!

yeah but they made the final when SA didnt, so wouldnt that make them better by your logic?

[bombersno1]

yeah but they made the final when SA didnt, so wouldnt that make them better by your logic?

Mate if Mitch Johnson can get 10 wickets and Victoria can't bowl QLD out on that pitch something tells me the bowlers are dead s..t! And their batsmen are hopeless as well most of the time. Hodge is ok, but lehmann is better than him anyway.

[Richo83]

One year wonder?? He had a good season last season yeah... but before that was Bradman Young Cricketer Of The Year. That doesnt make him a one year wonder you stupid :D:D:D:D.

White is a 0 year wonder if you want to get stupid.

Rooster, don't give him logical reasonned arguments that prove him wrong. It causes his brain to overheat and explode. Cosgrove has been good for a while now and just hit a century in England so I don't know what he is talking about.

As for Vic V SA? Vic has alot of passengers, like Denton (s***) and White (pile of stinky hopeless s***) Hussey is okay, yet the inferior one. Hodge is good and Warne a genuis.

As for SA, Gillespie very good, Lehmann ditto, Cullen young (Yet better than White lol.) Cosgrove > Denton and Rofe is okay. Personally, Tait > Rofe. I'd pick Warne purely on the Warne factor, however the others are beaaten easily by their SA counterparts.

Jaymin, you forgot McGrath as well. Makes the NSW option even better.

[just maybe]

Hodge is the best batter out of the lot.

Except for Lehmann and Cosgrove.