PDA

View Full Version : Another farcical incident in the DVFL.


localfootyguru
17 May 2006, 13:48
Surely this couldnt of happened? Oh, it was in the Diamond Valley FL where nothing ceases to amaze. Article below is from todays Herald Sun.


Probe into umpires' fight
Sam Edmund, sports affairs reporter
17may06

TWO umpires exchanged punches in a bizarre ending to a suburban football match.

The men in white had just finished umpiring a Diamond Valley Football League game when they began fighting.
The Herald Sun has learned the pair became involved in a heated argument as they left Epping football ground after the home side beat Heidelberg by 44 points at the weekend.

Tempers boiled over after they entered the umpires' rooms.

"Two senior umpires punched on in the rooms after the game," a source said.

"The umpiring was disgraceful all day and as they were walking off the ground they were having a heated discussion about some of the decisions the other one was paying.

"They just got in the room and started throwing punches.

"Apparently the goal umpire walked in between them to break them up and he copped one in the face as well.

"The Diamond Valley is a joke, let me tell you."

Heidelberg football manager Robin "Polly" Perkins said he was unaware of the incident, but admitted the umpiring was so bad the club was considering sending a letter of complaint.

"We're very disappointed at the standard of umpiring," Mr Perkins said.

"I saw a decision I've never seen before. The umpire paid a 50m penalty against us because one of our supporters, who was well behind the fence, called him a cabbage.

"I've never seen that in my life."

Epping president John Mason said: "I wasn't aware of the fight.

"If I knew it was happening I would have bought tickets.

"I would have had a ball, don't you worry."

DVFL secretary Peter Floyd said the league would investigate the incident.

Heidelberg president Trevor Barrett could not be contacted yesterday.

EDFL MAN
17 May 2006, 13:52
Surely this couldnt of happened? Oh, it was in the Diamond Valley FL where nothing ceases to amaze. Article below is from todays Herald Sun.


Probe into umpires' fight
Sam Edmund, sports affairs reporter
17may06

TWO umpires exchanged punches in a bizarre ending to a suburban football match.

The men in white had just finished umpiring a Diamond Valley Football League game when they began fighting.
The Herald Sun has learned the pair became involved in a heated argument as they left Epping football ground after the home side beat Heidelberg by 44 points at the weekend.

Tempers boiled over after they entered the umpires' rooms.

"Two senior umpires punched on in the rooms after the game," a source said.

"The umpiring was disgraceful all day and as they were walking off the ground they were having a heated discussion about some of the decisions the other one was paying.

"They just got in the room and started throwing punches.

"Apparently the goal umpire walked in between them to break them up and he copped one in the face as well.

"The Diamond Valley is a joke, let me tell you."

Heidelberg football manager Robin "Polly" Perkins said he was unaware of the incident, but admitted the umpiring was so bad the club was considering sending a letter of complaint.

"We're very disappointed at the standard of umpiring," Mr Perkins said.

"I saw a decision I've never seen before. The umpire paid a 50m penalty against us because one of our supporters, who was well behind the fence, called him a cabbage.

"I've never seen that in my life."

Epping president John Mason said: "I wasn't aware of the fight.

"If I knew it was happening I would have bought tickets.

"I would have had a ball, don't you worry."

DVFL secretary Peter Floyd said the league would investigate the incident.

Heidelberg president Trevor Barrett could not be contacted yesterday.

A great comp that has gone to water! :thumbsd:

T.Perry
17 May 2006, 14:15
Has anything action been taken against any of those involved in the Diamond Creek V Nth Heidelberg brawl? Haven't heard anything about it for a couple of days..

So, from what I can gather from reading big footy, in the past 3 weeks there has been a severely injured player (though accidentally), who got heckled by opposition supporters, and the club doing the heckling was fined (?), at the same venue, there were reports that the ambulance had great difficulty getting the injured player off the ground, there has been a sizeable brawl between opposition supporters, and then a punch up between 2 umpires?? :eek:

Doesn't go a long way in improving the reputation of the league..that, coupled with bad playing facilities, and it's no wonder that blokes like Grainger, Saad, Jansz, Reid, Pemberton, Adamson, Amad, Hooper, Penn, Taylor, Gibson, McBrien, Clarke, Clayton (X2), Haberman, Colbert, etc, who all live in a suburb housing a DV side, have opted to travel up bush instead..

And that's not necessarily having a pot at the DV, but there is obviously a fair amount of work to be done, and has needed to be done for years, yet nothing seems to have changed...

ifyoucandodgeawrench
17 May 2006, 14:22
http://www.dvfooty.com/news/news0468.htm

mitch_fc
17 May 2006, 16:02
http://www.dvfooty.com/news/news0468.htm
i wish i was there. can someone tell me which umpires were invoved?

mitch_fc
17 May 2006, 16:04
1 was Elworthy. he has a fair reputation in the Valley, especially amingst cricket clubs....

melbdocker
17 May 2006, 18:09
is that elworthy guy who played cricket at greensborough dist rangers a few yrs back there?

mitch_fc
18 May 2006, 15:04
is that elworthy guy who played cricket at greensborough dist rangers a few yrs back there?
i think so.

he hosts the DVCA radio program on plenty valley fm i think. from my dealing with him at Eltham, he was a good bloke, but i have heard some bizzre stories.

sross
20 May 2006, 10:51
I notice thee has been no mention of the Div 2 umpire who has been suspended indefinitely. Left the escorts and other umpires on the way off the ground to attack a spectator.