View Full Version : Votes Vs Richmond
Stiffy_18
20 May 2006, 23:31
This week its tough for all the wrong reasons :(
Player of the year
5. Andrew McLeod - Clearly BOG today. He was just about the only player who dared to play on and do something other than chipping it around. He tried to lead but others didn't follow.
4. Tyson Edwards - Our only midfielder than won his position today. Just your usual Edwards game.
3. Michael Doughty - He is continuing his good form. Got the ball well he generally used it well especially under pressure. Most of his team-mates didn't.
2. Ben Rutten - I thought he played a great game on Richo. He didn't give him a sniff today. Sure Richo got a couple of shots on goal (from VERY acute angles) and took some marks but they were further up the ground where the damage was minimal. He loves playing on big strong forward.
1. Graham Johncock - At least he tried to create something from back half. Not a great game by his standards but he was servicable.
Best Team Man
3. Ben Rutten - See above
2. Tyson Edwards - See above
1. Andrew McLeod - See above
Rookie
None this week I am afraid :(
maccas_no1
20 May 2006, 23:48
5 Mcleod
4 Doughty
3 Goodwin
2 Edwards
1 Rutten
Still really disapointed about today:thumbsd:
macca23
20 May 2006, 23:55
This week its tough for all the wrong reasons :(
Player of the year
5. Andrew McLeod - Clearly BOG today. He was just about the only player who dared to play on and do something other than chipping it around. He tried to lead but others didn't follow.
4. Tyson Edwards - Our only midfielder than won his position today. Just your usual Edwards game.
3. Michael Doughty - He is continuing his good form. Got the ball well he generally used it well especially under pressure. Most of his team-mates didn't.
2. Ben Rutten - I thought he played a gat game on Richo. He didn't give him a sniff today. Sure Richo got a couple of shots on goal (from VERY acute angles) and took some marks but they were further up the ground where the damage was minimal. He loves playing on big strong forward.
1. Graham Johncock - At least he tried to create something from back half. Not a great game by his standards but he was servicable.
Best Team Man
3. Ben Rutten - See above
2. Tyson Edwards - See above
1. Andrew McLeod - See above
Rookie
None this week I am afraid :(
These will do me fine - I'm too depressed to do anything else.
I do genuinely agree with them though. :thumbsu:
These will do me fine - I'm too depressed to do anything else.
I do genuinely agree with them though. :thumbsu:
Disappointing there were no rookies out there today.:( :( :(
We need a balance between hard edged experience and the natural exuberance of youth.
Mad Dog
21 May 2006, 10:40
POTY.......those who sucked least....:(
5 - Tyson Edwards - continued AA form
4 - Andrew McLeod - plenty of rebound off the backline......got caught a few times which really underlines where he is at in his career
3 - Scott Thompson - unlucky to give away that down ground free I thought
2 - Graham Johncock
1 - Ben Rutten - turned Richo into a Tredrea clone...:D
BTM
3 - Edwards
2 - Rutten
1 - Massie
ROTY
pass - VB - 43 minutes...WTF is with that?...:thumbsd:
crows98
21 May 2006, 10:55
Adelaide vs. Richmond
Round 8
Best on Ground
5) Andrew Mcleod
4) Tyson Edwards
3) Graham Johncock
2) Ben Rutten
1) Martin Mattner
Best team Man
3) Andrew Mcleod
2) Ben Rutten
1) Nathan Bassett
Rookie
Pass
tomthetiger
21 May 2006, 10:56
I dont think Mcleod was Adelaides best. I admired the way he tried to change the game, and run the lines, carry the ball etc etc. But I can't think of too many times where this was really effective. Id say Edwards was Adelaides best.
Mad Dog
21 May 2006, 11:02
I dont think Mcleod was Adelaides best. I admired the way he tried to change the game, and run the lines, carry the ball etc etc. But I can't think of too many times where this was really effective. Id say Edwards was Adelaides best.
so post your votes
5: Edwards
4: Mcleod
3: -
2: -
1: Reilly, thought he at least managed to intercept the ball a bit and disrupt Richmonds style of play in the first half.
5: Edwards
4: Mcleod
3: -
2: -
1: Reilly, thought he at least managed to intercept the ball a bit and disrupt Richmonds style of play in the first half.
I'll go with Eggzoi. :thumbsu:
Vic Crow
21 May 2006, 13:35
POTY
5 - McLeod
4 - Edwards
3 - Rutten
2 - Massie
1 - Doughty
BTM
3 - Rutten
2 - Bassett
1 - Massie
Rookie
Pass - not that VB did much wrong, just didn't get the game time to earn a vote
AJ_No.4
21 May 2006, 17:01
This week its tough for all the wrong reasons :(
Player of the year
5. Andrew McLeod - Clearly BOG today. He was just about the only player who dared to play on and do something other than chipping it around. He tried to lead but others didn't follow.
4. Tyson Edwards - Our only midfielder than won his position today. Just your usual Edwards game.
3. Michael Doughty - He is continuing his good form. Got the ball well he generally used it well especially under pressure. Most of his team-mates didn't.
2. Ben Rutten - I thought he played a great game on Richo. He didn't give him a sniff today. Sure Richo got a couple of shots on goal (from VERY acute angles) and took some marks but they were further up the ground where the damage was minimal. He loves playing on big strong forward.
1. Graham Johncock - At least he tried to create something from back half. Not a great game by his standards but he was servicable.
Best Team Man
3. Ben Rutten - See above
2. Tyson Edwards - See above
1. Andrew McLeod - See above
Rookie
None this week I am afraid :(
Same for me, I think Stiffy got them spot on.
topjars
22 May 2006, 08:04
BOG
5 McLeod
4 Edwards
3 Rutten
2 Massie
1 Doughty
BTM
3 Edwards
2 Bassett
1 Massie
ROTY
sfa
Markthirtytwo
22 May 2006, 09:34
BOG
5 McLeod
4 Edwards
3 Rutten
2 Johncock
1 Doughty
BTM
3 Edwards
2 Massie
1 Johncock
ROTY
Abstain.
POTY
5 McLeod
4 Johncock
3 Goodwin
2 Rutten
1 Mattner
BTM
3 Reilly
2 McLeod
1 Rutten
ROTY
1 Van Berlo
A bit short on voters this week.
POTY:
McLeod 57
Edwards 45
Rutten 21
Doughty 16
Johncock 14
__________
(abstain 10)
Goodwin 6
Massie 4
Thompson 3
Mattner 2
Reilly 2
Total 180 (12 voted)
BTM:
(abstain 18)
Rutten 17
Edwards 15
__________
McLeod 8
Massie 5
Bassett 5
Reilly 3
Johncock 1
Total 72
ROTY
(abstain 35)
Van Berlo 1
Total 36