View Full Version : Seaby
weagles_fan
17 Jun 2006, 23:16
I'm sick of this guy. Gets killed in the ruck and is absolutely useless around the ground. Yes he is young but the team can't carry him like it has all year going into the finals.
Thoughts?
Got to say that I'd hoped he would of come along a lot quicker given his promising start to his career but lately he seems to have hit a wall in terms of his form.And I must add that his marking is absolutley deplorable atm.
I too hope that is only a confidence 'thing' but time will tell.Perhaps a stint with Cardies at WAFL level might just be the trick :thumbsu:
eagleskickass
17 Jun 2006, 23:33
as much as it pains me to say...I think it is time for a stint in the WAFL for the big fella. I know he feels very bad about how he is playing, he is really struggling to come to terms with only playing very small amounts of the game. Time for an extended run in the WAFL playing a full match to get some confidence back up. He is a talent but something is wrong atm.
daddy_4_eyes
17 Jun 2006, 23:53
If Gardy performs well in the WAFL over the next couple of weeks, Seaby could well get dropped after the break. Was very ordinary today, and the momentum really swung away from the eagles when Cox was rested and Seaby had to go up against Lade/Brogan in the ruck.
A WAFL stint is nothing bad though. Talls take longer to develop, and Seaby has plenty of time to get his act together. A few games in the WAFL will see him rucking more, getting more of the ball, and hopefully regaining his touch.
TheReason
18 Jun 2006, 00:15
If Gardy performs well in the WAFL over the next couple of weeks, Seaby could well get dropped after the break. Was very ordinary today, and the momentum really swung away from the eagles when Cox was rested and Seaby had to go up against Lade/Brogan in the ruck.
Cox's tap work since he had that injury scare some 6 weeks ago, has not been the same either.
Agree on Seaby.... it no longer seems if, but when Gardiner will return.
jorel6669
18 Jun 2006, 00:19
The problem is that Cox needs more rest, and Seaby isn't carrying the load. As much as I though I'd never the see the man in a West Coast jumper again, I think Gardiner's got to be given a run sooner rather than later. Seaby can get match confidence up in the WAFL and push for selection again.
Lynch drops a mark
18 Jun 2006, 00:28
R13 Ins & Outs
Out: Seaby Hurn Priddis
In: Judd Gardiner Sampi
a few AA's Brownlow's and 300 odd games of experience
Cox to have a rest as back up ruck and Gardiner to show what he's made of and go back to #1 ruck until Cox is back to his best
TheReason
18 Jun 2006, 00:44
R13 Ins & Outs
Out: Seaby Hurn Priddis
In: Judd Gardiner Sampi
a few AA's Brownlow's and 300 odd games of experience
Cox to have a rest as back up ruck and Gardiner to show what he's made of and go back to #1 ruck until Cox is back to his best
:thumbsu:
I like, I like a lot.
I'm sick of this guy. Gets killed in the ruck and is absolutely useless around the ground. Yes he is young but the team can't carry him like it has all year going into the finals.
Thoughts?
Like I said last week, thanks for the memories Seabs......
Only injury will keep Gardy out next time....
Eagles 4 Mine
18 Jun 2006, 00:56
Sampi what:confused:
TheReason
18 Jun 2006, 01:03
Sampi what:confused:
We don't have any crumbers....
If we don't manufacture some soon or get Sampi into form by the finals.......
Chick has given stirling service in his absence due to his bolloking work in the fwd line.... but we still need a natural / instinctive crumber.
sdb4884
18 Jun 2006, 01:04
I had nothing against Hurn and Priddis's game today. Seaby for Gardiner and Judd for someone else. RoJo?
Honestly, he just doesn't look good at all over the last month or so. Gardiner needs to come in.
And for god sakes RoJo, learn how to kick straight. Don't like bagging our players but he really annoys me with his disposal, and he's a horrible kick for goal.
bassmanx
18 Jun 2006, 02:21
R13 Ins & Outs
Out: Seaby Hurn Priddis
In: Judd Gardiner Sampi
a few AA's Brownlow's and 300 odd games of experience
Cox to have a rest as back up ruck and Gardiner to show what he's made of and go back to #1 ruck until Cox is back to his best
We are gonna have to give Morton a run before Sampi.
I couldn't agree more with a rest for Seaby. He copped a hiding all day.
94_Eagles
18 Jun 2006, 05:24
Honestly, he just doesn't look good at all over the last month or so. Gardiner needs to come in.
And for god sakes RoJo, learn how to kick straight. Don't like bagging our players but he really annoys me with his disposal, and he's a horrible kick for goal.
Agree. He's just a really unclassy finisher.
But so is our whole team, except for Graham.
Eagles 4 Mine
18 Jun 2006, 13:20
We don't have any crumbers....
If we don't manufacture some soon or get Sampi into form by the finals.......
Chick has given stirling service in his absence due to his bolloking work in the fwd line.... but we still need a natural / instinctive crumber.
I agree with the fact that we have to get him back into form that is what the WAFL is for , we can't carry any players that is what I was really on about.