View Full Version : Who is worse?
footynuts99
23 Jul 2006, 17:53
Who is worse - Carlton or Essendon?
DynamoUltra
24 Jul 2006, 00:09
Too close to call. But using the ladder, I suggest Essendon.
MrAaron
24 Jul 2006, 00:15
i'll go for University \o/
Mentallo
24 Jul 2006, 00:24
Your mum!
celtic_pride
24 Jul 2006, 17:55
Who is worse - Carlton or Essendon?
Each club has won more flags than Cabbagewood so come back to us when your club has achieved something meaningful and won something silver.
footynuts99
24 Jul 2006, 18:17
Fair enough mate
PAFC2004
24 Jul 2006, 18:19
Great poll.
Runandhyde
24 Jul 2006, 18:43
Atleast carton has a decent lift of youngsters, which will only by bolstered by this years draft. The bummer has poor older players (with Lloyd and hird being exceptions), poor youngsters, poor coach, poor everything. Enjoy a few years down the bottom bombers supporters.
celtic_pride
28 Jul 2006, 15:53
Atleast carton has a decent lift of youngsters, which will only by bolstered by this years draft. The bummer has poor older players (with Lloyd and hird being exceptions), poor youngsters, poor coach, poor everything. Enjoy a few years down the bottom bombers supporters.
Look i really hate Essendon and love seeing them struggle,but your comment is a bit out of whack. Sheedy has won 4 flags as a coach, some of their youngsters are pretty good (Stanton may win their B&F this year etc) Problem really has been too much of a reliance on Hird and Lloyd over the years, and the drop in form of some of their senior players has been startling.
Also Kep Bradley has been dissapointing this year as has Mcphee, two players the Bombers can hope improve in 06.
It's too early to say whether this year is an aberration, or if they'll be struggling for the next couple of years. I suspect the latter but I could be wrong.
Carlton. They keep kicking it back to the oppo whenever they threaten to play good football.
Inferno
30 Jul 2006, 13:41
Carlton couldnt even beat a Lloydless Bombers team so it has to be them. Bombers were better then Carlton has been all season last night.
Barnsey3150
3 Aug 2006, 16:15
Neither soon enough...Collingwood, Dons & Blues don't deserve to be down the bottom....we are the AFL