PDA

View Full Version : Best for Demons?

goal sneak
8 Aug 2006, 09:48
Which of these players likely to be leaving there clubs at seasons end would be the best player for Melbourne?
The Great Gabsby
8 Aug 2006, 13:51
Where's the none of the above option?:cool:
Bartram_Class
8 Aug 2006, 14:28
In terms of value for money, im going to say Nick Davis.

Brisbane will want too much for Aker and he would want a fair salary, Davis couldnt demand as high a wage and with his career on the line at his 3rd club, he could be a real pick up.
rick James
8 Aug 2006, 14:33
I voted Aker - but if we could get Everritt we'd be unstoppable I reckon.
Bartram_Class
8 Aug 2006, 14:57
Yeh but RJ, that doesnt do much for PJ and the Russians development.

We've already lost 2 decent ruckman to other clubs, one has a premiership, one will be AA this year.
AllStar7
8 Aug 2006, 15:37
Polak. Would cost us the least, is the youngest and has the greatest upside.
Bartram_Class
8 Aug 2006, 15:41
They dont call him Polhack for no reason, apparently hes gone backwards since being drafted.
Canna7
9 Aug 2006, 18:27
Gardiner is a spud. Hasn't played a good match in years and would be beaten convincingly by Nicho and Dutchy in an agility test.

Medhurst is inconsistant and hasn't proved much up to this point of his career.

Polak - see above.

Davis is a sook and has always had problems at his clubs, so he would be a distraction.

Everitt is old, injury-prone and not needed in our ruck division.

There is only one player we need:

AKER

A superstar, Brownlow Medallist, 3 time Premiership player, multiple All-Australian and Best & Fairest winner, an experienced match-winner who still has five years left in him easily!
goal sneak
15 Aug 2006, 22:19
Looks like AKER will be a tiger next year. With Jamar struggling would anyone want Micky Gardiner at the club for nothing?
Theseventhhamster
16 Aug 2006, 00:08
Aker for me. I like Polak's potential but he has other issues that are a worry.
Canna7
16 Aug 2006, 11:35
Jamar will be right. As will PJ when he returns next year.

Both are better prospects than Gardiner.
turtz
16 Aug 2006, 11:45
Jamar will be right. As will PJ when he returns next year.

Both are better prospects than Gardiner.

PJ will be good for many years for us. Next year will see some big things from him.

Aker is the only one of that bunch i would even consider.
Bartram_Class
16 Aug 2006, 12:39
Looks like AKER will be a tiger next year. With Jamar struggling would anyone want Micky Gardiner at the club for nothing?
Jamars shown enough, hes only 21 or 22 remember.

And PJ will be back next year.
torpedo9
16 Aug 2006, 14:29
I think Canna7 is spot on.

Gardiner and Everitt are broken down has-beens. Our ruck division is fine, if anything we need to develop another young ruckman to lead the charge in the post-White era.

Davis is trouble.

Polak may benefit from getting out of Freo.

However Aker is the money man - get him on board!!