View Full Version : Carlton Board MVP Round 20 vs Richmond
Mentallo
21 Aug 2006, 23:56
This does not get any easier does it?
3.Whitnall
2.Bannister (again)
1.Thornton (for playing FB in a team whose midfield couldn't get a kick in a stampede)
Hono mentions to Carlos for having a fair dinkum crack and playing every game like it could be his last.
Does anyone deserve it from that game?
If pushed,
3 Whitnall - two goals from CHB wasn't bad, even if he did get towelled up by Stafford
2. Simpson - played a great first quarter, which is one quarter more than the rest of our midfield
1. O'Hailpin - cos he's fun to watch and tried hard
3. Kouta
2. Whitnall
1. Thornton
Felt Bannister and Carlos could also have received votes
3. bannister - by far our best player
2. simpson
1. walker
3. Me for turning up to watch that tripe.
2. Lovely young richmond lass who was sporting a nice slinky singlet
1. Beer. Nice and cold and livened a dull day up
bluegal1983
22 Aug 2006, 13:48
3. Walker
2. O'Hailpin
1. Kouta
3 - Thornton, for always giving it his best when we know he's out of what should be his position.
2 - Walker, grab that captaincy son!
1 - Smith, for rapping on the door hard enough to get elevated. I feel this deserves recognition with a vote.
mike ockerts
22 Aug 2006, 14:40
3 walker
2 kouta
1 lance
whippety boy
22 Aug 2006, 14:56
3. Jordan Bannister
2. Brett Thornton
1. Andrew Walker
3 - Thornton
2 - Whitnall
1 - Setanta
really like sentanta but can not believe people are putting him in for a vote. talk about patronising.
igt22265
22 Aug 2006, 16:20
3. Thornton
2. Walker
1. Bannister
Went to the game and saw nothing outstanding
Beer was nice.
Not the sausage rolls.
marcmurphy3
22 Aug 2006, 17:08
3. Whitnall
2. Walker
1. Simpson
blues4flag
22 Aug 2006, 17:12
3. Whitnall
2. Bannister
1. Simpson
Thought Walker and Lappin were also good - special mention to O'hailpin who continues to improve.
Blah Blah Blue
22 Aug 2006, 17:27
1. Walker - good all day.
2. Bannister
3. Whitnall
Eddie - thought he tried hard, chased, tacked hard again.
Barnaby - particularly early, but tried all day
Carlos - just tries so hard and that run and pass to AW showed that with perserverance he will just keep improving.
really like sentanta but can not believe people are putting him in for a vote. talk about patronising.
don't forget it's most valuable, not best. Considering our backline weakness, this make him very valuable.
Free Willy
22 Aug 2006, 18:31
Whitnall
Simpson
Thornton
mediumsizered
22 Aug 2006, 22:32
After a game where no Carlton players performed for 4 quarters, I eventually came up with the following:
3. Whitnall
2. Walker
1. Thornton
Blues_Man
22 Aug 2006, 23:17
3: Kouta
2: Walker
1: Big Red
Stafford678
22 Aug 2006, 23:32
Intersting that most have whitnal in the best 3 players, from a tigers point of view, id say your 3 best where
3.Bannister
2. Walker
1.Kouta or French take your pick
Whitnall ended up with 3 goal and a a fair few touches but he had a goal kicked on him right at the start by schulz, whitnall was no where near the contest i think he was actually in the center when it went down to schulz, then he was moved to stafford and stafford kicked 2- maybe 3 on him from memory and they where all basicly because lance had run off and wouldnt play anywhere near staff, and then i remember lance having the ball on the back flank and chipping it sideways only be to be intercepted by tambling and it ended up in a richmond goal.
Good signs for the blues though, walker is going to be a star, sentanta is showing some signs, fisher and waite look like they will become very good players, eddie betts has a red hot dip somthing stevens should take note of , simpson will be a gun.
WalkerTexasRanger
23 Aug 2006, 06:46
3. Walker
2. Walker
1. Walker
:p
Intersting that most have whitnal in the best 3 players, from a tigers point of view, id say your 3 best where
3.Bannister
2. Walker
1.Kouta or French take your pick
Whitnall ended up with 3 goal and a a fair few touches but he had a goal kicked on him right at the start by schulz, whitnall was no where near the contest i think he was actually in the center when it went down to schulz, then he was moved to stafford and stafford kicked 2- maybe 3 on him from memory and they where all basicly because lance had run off and wouldnt play anywhere near staff, and then i remember lance having the ball on the back flank and chipping it sideways only be to be intercepted by tambling and it ended up in a richmond goal.
Good signs for the blues though, walker is going to be a star, sentanta is showing some signs, fisher and waite look like they will become very good players, eddie betts has a red hot dip somthing stevens should take note of , simpson will be a gun.
Good observations Stafford,
I noticed this also with Lance. I think from a Cartlon perspective Lance should be played either forward or across half back. Last line of defence is crazy imo. He does play wide and with his lack of pace will get caught out often in the last line.
Cartlon supporters do love him though as he has so much skill and does at least make contests. I feel that in an overall weak Carlton performance Lance did come back strongly in the second half to be one of our best 3-5.
Just Waite
23 Aug 2006, 09:12
3. Walker
2. Whitnall
1. Koutoufides
Mentions: Betts, French, Setenta and Houlihan
BlueWorld
23 Aug 2006, 12:34
3. Matthew Lappin
2. Ryan Houlihan
1. Anthony Koutoufides
The Old Dark Navy's
23 Aug 2006, 12:50
I abstain ...
bluegal1983
23 Aug 2006, 14:21
Intersting that most have whitnal in the best 3 players, from a tigers point of view, id say your 3 best where
3.Bannister
2. Walker
1.Kouta or French take your pick
Whitnall ended up with 3 goal and a a fair few touches but he had a goal kicked on him right at the start by schulz, whitnall was no where near the contest i think he was actually in the center when it went down to schulz, then he was moved to stafford and stafford kicked 2- maybe 3 on him from memory and they where all basicly because lance had run off and wouldnt play anywhere near staff, and then i remember lance having the ball on the back flank and chipping it sideways only be to be intercepted by tambling and it ended up in a richmond goal.
Good signs for the blues though, walker is going to be a star, sentanta is showing some signs, fisher and waite look like they will become very good players, eddie betts has a red hot dip somthing stevens should take note of , simpson will be a gun.
I am just wondering how you managed to come up with French in the top 4 Carlton players...? Is that because he tapped the ball straight to your guys all day?
Johnny_3
23 Aug 2006, 18:42
I was at the game and i would have to say one of our 3 worst games for the season. We were horrible coming out of defense and into attack and were unaccountable all over the fround. Skills were TERRIBLE.
Other than that
Whitnall: 3
Carrazzo:2
Bannister: 1
I thought other good players were sentanta, betts tackled well, and scotland
mrs.fisher
23 Aug 2006, 22:48
i go
3. brad fisher
2. chris bryan
1. kade simpson
thats what i think for this match
kouta 4 president
24 Aug 2006, 00:19
3. Walker
2. Walker
1. Walker
:p
Have to agree. Was worth more points than anyone else. Congrats to Lappin on having a fairly decent game and Setanta for those retarded bounces
Mentallo
27 Aug 2006, 00:33
MVP standings updated.