View Full Version : Votes vs Tigers
Dr Moose
26 Aug 2006, 22:47
3 - Hird - for that final qtr goal if nothing else
2 - Stanton - seemed to be everywhere tonight. Wish he'd kicked straighter
3 - NLM - tried his guts out in the first half
Sam the RAMA fan
26 Aug 2006, 23:02
3--Hird
2--Peverill
1--Stanton
AHHHHH!!!
16-17-113 :(
20-9-129
17 BEHINDS to Richmond's 9!!
mcphee_is_a_gun
26 Aug 2006, 23:15
Peveril must go! just not accountable enough anymore and doesnt huirt any teams with his disposals!
Dr Moose
26 Aug 2006, 23:28
Whereas Bolton perfectly assisits opponents with his passes
mcphee_is_a_gun
26 Aug 2006, 23:35
Whereas Bolton perfectly assisits opponents with his passes
at least Bolton plays for the team, can't say the same about Peveril. He's more than happy to run hard when we have the ball but not the other way which he used to be so good at.
The Dustbin
26 Aug 2006, 23:43
3 - Hird
2 - Lovett-Murray
1 - Watson
mcphee_is_a_gun
26 Aug 2006, 23:52
what were peoples thoughts on Johns game? 15 possies 8 marks and a goal.
Longy413
27 Aug 2006, 00:12
what were peoples thoughts on Johns game? 15 possies 8 marks and a goal.
Was pretty good, couple of times he failed to handball to the bloke running past, other than that he was okay.
tockley
27 Aug 2006, 00:19
3.j hird
2.dyson
1.watson
pev wasnt to bad gees your potin him
windyhill
27 Aug 2006, 01:36
3. Pev, in everything
2. Stants.
1. Watson.
Darealrath
27 Aug 2006, 02:04
3. Hird
2. NLM
1. Watson
Dempsey was impressive though not near votes.
Dempsey was impressive though not near votes.Seemed a little over awed by it all at times. A few turn overs and could certainly have done better. He did set up a Lucas goal with a nice handpass though so cant really complain.
3. Pev, in everything
2. Stants.
1. Watson.No Hird?? Did you miss the second quarter where he had like 6 clearances in a row to get us back from a four goal deficit? Shades of Rd 3 2004.
windyhill
27 Aug 2006, 02:38
No Hird?? Did you miss the second quarter where he had like 6 clearances in a row to get us back from a four goal deficit? Shades of Rd 3 2004.
Check his first quarter zafa, loose man in defence picking up too many cheap ones and going straight to a tiger, very sloppy ( have i just shot bambi?)
SydneyBomber
27 Aug 2006, 04:00
3 pev
2 stants
1 jim
I reckon dempsey will be good. yes he looked overawed a couple of times, but just needs the confidence to back himself a bit more and RUN (not jog) and break the lines
dyson is starting to do that, and showing a bit more of what he's capable of.
yes they'll get run-down on occasion, but more often than not they will be faster and able to get away from most players with average footspeed
droppuntkick23
27 Aug 2006, 09:15
3. Cartledgge
2. Cole
1. Bolton;)
keepzitreal
27 Aug 2006, 12:42
3 - Hird
2 - NLM
1 - Stanton
- Good effort by the boys, Fletch would have made all the difference. Bring on that PP pick. Sheeds leaving Keps on Richo was questionable.
Yeah, I thought McPhee could have had a go at least
Check his first quarter zafa, loose man in defence picking up too many cheap ones and going straight to a tiger, very sloppy ( have i just shot bambi?)Admittedly I was at work and missed the first quarter, but I thought he was by far the best in the other three.
5- Peverill
4- Stanton
3- NLM
2- Hird
1- Johns
weak as pi55 - Pettifer, soft, scared of the ball, hangout
3- Hird
2- NLM
1- Watson
Have to say, Dyson looked like T. Watson with his dashes down the middle. I think someone put a cracker up his clacker. Hope to see more of them from him next season.:thumbsu:
Longy413
27 Aug 2006, 14:41
Have to say, Dyson looked like T. Watson with his dashes down the middle. I think someone put a cracker up his clacker. Hope to see more of them from him next season.:thumbsu:
Great to see him take the game on, the odd block from his teammates wouldn't have gone astray, he just has to kick goals. Don't pass when you're 50-60 out Rick, go for home.
Great to see him take the game on, the odd block from his teammates wouldn't have gone astray, he just has to kick goals. Don't pass when you're 50-60 out Rick, go for home.
Also have to note Stanton's engine....in a word 'incredible' Even when the game looked to be gone midway through the final term, he STILL ran hard into our forward 50.
Broady Poker Tour
27 Aug 2006, 16:17
Dyson: We need players like Dyson, Dempsey, Lovett and Licha to break the lines and make the play through the middle. I know Dyson got caught a couple of times yesterday, but I think that he needs to keep backing himself.
Why wasn't Solomon moved to Richo? I thought maybe the ruckman could have gone back to block the hole between the midfield and Richo. Watching Bradley was like watching Zac Dawson, our midfield didn't pressure the kicker anywhere near enough, and we had no-one helping him out at all.
Votes
Hird 3
Stanton 2
Peverill 1
Boris_Bewick
27 Aug 2006, 16:42
Peveril must go! just not accountable enough anymore and doesnt huirt any teams with his disposals!
Geez that's a rough call. He picked up 32 possesions and IMO played one of his best games, did all the hard things.
His disposal was fine tonight also, nothing wrong with it. Just because his kicking looks awkward doesn't mean it is.
And in terms of being delisted, there are plenty more under the guillotine than Pev. He sets a fine example at training for the younger blokes as he is one of the hardest trainers at the club. And his form over the last 5-6 weeks has been top 5 B & F worthy.
Geez that's a rough call. He picked up 32 possesions and IMO played one of his best games, did all the hard things.
His disposal was fine tonight also, nothing wrong with it. Just because his kicking looks awkward doesn't mean it is.
And in terms of being delisted, there are plenty more under the guillotine than Pev. He sets a fine example at training for the younger blokes as he is one of the hardest trainers at the club. And his form over the last 5-6 weeks has been top 5 B & F worthy.
I agree, Ive argued this point before and although I agree he is a one pace player...he puts his head down and pushes hard with what he has. As you said, there are worse rigth now in our side and Im always willing to list him in my best 22. Wouldve preferred Jolley and Leeto Cole and Bolts last night incidently.
Great to see him take the game on, the odd block from his teammates wouldn't have gone astray
Talk from his teammates would also help, he had White covered until he settled back to take another bounce.
he just has to kick goals. Don't pass when you're 50-60 out Rick, go for home.
I wonder if that is a coaching directive, he seems very much pass first these days.
dave_27
27 Aug 2006, 21:25
geez I was hanging for dyson to drill that one from 50m on the run in the first quarter instead he passed and johns dropped it.
Just have a crack when you get in range ricky!
Loved him turning on the pace in congested situations last night, judd style.
He's decision making/kicking was a little wayward though.
3. Cartledgge
2. Cole
1. Bolton;)
Your name suits your intelligence ;)
Dr Moose
27 Aug 2006, 22:57
Why wasn't Solomon moved to Richo? ... Watching Bradley was like watching Zac Dawson, our midfield didn't pressure the kicker anywhere near enough, and we had no-one helping him out at all.
Couldn't agree more. There are times to try teaching Kepler grown-up responsibilities like playing full-back. Bendigo springs to mind. On one of the best FFs in the game at the MCG does not. Kepler is not, and never will be a gun FB. If you're going for development and writing off the game, give Lee the job!
Longy413
28 Aug 2006, 10:38
I wonder if that is a coaching directive, he seems very much pass first these days.
I wouldn't have thought so, Stanton seems to have license. Can't imagine why Dyson wouldn't.
Squeaky
28 Aug 2006, 10:58
There are times to try teaching Kepler grown-up responsibilities like playing full-back. Bendigo springs to mind. On one of the best FFs in the game at the MCG does not. Kepler is not, and never will be a gun FB. If you're going for development and writing off the game, give Lee the job!
I agree entirely!
I agree entirely!
It was good for Kepler to see how fit and strong Richo was, even at 32 years of age, something for Kepler to work on because he could get fitter and stronger
go_the_bombers
28 Aug 2006, 12:47
3. Hird
2. NLM
1. Dyson
I wonder if Sheeds is going to employ the same tactic for our forward line by leaving a huge gap in front of the 50 metre arc and hope for a clearance...might be a little more difficult this time round with West and Cross firing off bullet like handballs. Wouldnt mind seeing Johns on Harris incidently.
kelvin_sheedy
28 Aug 2006, 13:19
Why are people giving Dyson votes? You got to be kidding!
He looked good in patches and it was the first time i thought to myself that this kid could make it and become a very good player.
Hird, Watson, Pev, Staton, NLM.
NLM is becoming a very very good player for us.
stander
28 Aug 2006, 13:31
NLM is becoming a very very good player for us.
Agreed, but needs to improve the round arm before we play freo next year.