Best and Fairest Competition

[SIR SAINT HOTDOG]

my top 10 prediction for saints:

1: Riewoldt
2: S Fisher
3: R Harvey
4: B Goddard
5: Dal Santo
6: Gram
7: Montagna
8: Hudghton
9: Ball
10: Gehrig

[Bourky23]

my top 10 prediction for saints:

1: Riewoldt
2: S Fisher
3: R Harvey
4: B Goddard
5: Dal Santo
6: Gram
7: Montagna
8: Hudghton
9: Ball
10: Gehrig

haha i rekon lenny will still prob finish top 10... your list seems pretty spot on though

[Kildonan]

This thread is a good idea for a competition.

The first poster who gets the nearest to or exactly the official best and fairest top 10 as decided by the club shall win

I'll try and get the Chief to commit a year's membership as a prize.

Confirmed! Our benevolent Chief has kindly agreed to sponsor this competition.

The winner to receive a free membership for 12 months

I believe the B & F is on Oct 03 2006

[Axcellence]

1. Sam Fisher
2. Riewoldt
3. Robert Harvey
4. Nick Dal Santo
5. Max Hudgton
7. Luke Ball
8. Fraser Gehrig
9. Brendon Goddard
10. Jason Gram


Although, I'd reserve this for finals... where it's likely Riewoldt may jump past sam fisher. Out of sake of curiosity, where do you guys think Lenny Hayes will finish? He was playing in brownlow winning form b4 he went down.

[Emmo]

Gram would have to be higher than that wouldnt he???:confused:

As for lenny dunno he will still go alright maybe just 13th at a stab

[mad-saint-guy]

1: Nick Riewoldt
2: Sam Fisher
3: Max Hudghton
4: Robert Harvey
5: Brendon Goddard
6: Jason Gram
7: Nick Dal Santo
8: Luke Ball
9: Steven Baker
10: Fraser Gehrig

[Bourky23]

1st - Nick Riewoldt
2nd - Sam Fisher
3rd - Nick Dal Santo
4th - Jason Gram
5th - Robert Harvey
6th - Brendon Goddard
7th - Joey Montagna
8th - Fraser Gehrig
9th - Luke Ball
10th - Max Hudghton

[SIR SAINT HOTDOG]

haha i rekon lenny will still prob finish top 10... your list seems pretty spot on though



lenny was on track for brownlow until he injured his knee

[nicko016]

1- N Riewodlt
2- S Fisher
3- N Dal Santo
4- J Gram
5- B Goddard
6- R Harvey
7- M Hudgton
8- L Montagna
9- F Gehrig
10- L Ball

[Rough_Edges]

1 - Riewoldt
2 - S.Fisher
3 - Goddard
4 - Gram
5 - Harvey
6 - Dal Santo
7 - Hudgton
8 - Montagna
9 - L Ball
10 - Baker

[sxcdavster40]

Lenny quite an amazing player, so sad to see him go down. Gram has also been a massive contributor this year and provides great run off half-back.

Goddard a great player with a smart mind, thoroughly improved.

Pretty accurate Hotdog, these are my thoughts.

Personally i think:

1. Lenny (Jokes), Riewoldt
2. Harvey
3. Dal Santo
4. Goddard
5. Harvey
6. Gram
7. Ball
8.Hudghton
9. Lenny (What a superstar)
10. Gehrig

[Benny_]

1. Riewoldt
2. S.Fisher
3. B.Goddard
4. N.Dal Santo
5. R.Harvey
6. J.Gram
7. M.Hudghton
8. L.Ball
9. L.Montagna
10. S.Baker

[The Punter]

1 Riewoldt
2 S Fisher
3 Gram
4 Harvey
5 Goddard
6 Dal Santo
7 Ball
8 Montagna
9 Hudghton
10 Voss

[BATTERY]

1. J.Gram
2. Riewoldt
3. S.Fisher
4. B.Goddard
5. Dal Santo
6. L.Montagna
7. R.Harvey
8. M.Hudghton
9. L.Ball
10. Baker

[AnGuS#6]

lenny was on track for brownlow until he injured his knee

Good Work Hotties :thumbsu:. u shouldn't be fantasizing on a public forum though!

[Wiener12]

1st: Nick Riewoldt
2nd: Sam Fisher
3rd: Brendon Goddard
4th: Jason Gram
5th: Robert Harvey
6th: Max Hudghton
7th: Nick Dal Santo
8th: Luke Ball
9th: Leigh Montagna
10th: Fraser Gehrig

[johnnyhoward]

1. Goddard
2. Riewoldt
3. Dal Santo
4. Gram
5. Harvey
6. S. Fisher
7. Montagna
8. Baker
9. Hayes
10. Hudghton

[krasky]

1. nick riewoldt
2. sam fisher
3. steven baker
4. jason gram
5. leigh montagna
6. brendan goddard
7. nick dal santo
8. fraser gehrig
9. luke ball
10. robert harvey

[Tas43]

1 - Riewoldt
2 - Sam Fisher
3 - Goddard
4 - Gram
5 - Dal santo
6 - Harvey
7 - Montagna
8 - Luke Ball
9 - Max hudghton
10 - Hayes

[mad-saint-guy]

Results

1: Nick Riewoldt 145 votes
2: Jason Gram 134 votes
3: Sam Fisher 131 votes
4: Robert Harvey 121 votes
5: Nick Dal Santo 115 votes
6: Brendon Goddard 115 votes
7: Fraser Gehrig 108 votes
8: Max Hudghton 108 votes
9: Leigh Montagna 107 votes
10: Brett Voss 104 votes

[mad-saint-guy]

So how is it scored? Is it simply whoever gets the most right, or should their be a points system? Eg: If you get the player's placing right, you get 5 points, if it is within 3 spots you get 2 points and if its within 5 spots you get one point. How does that sound?

[Kildonan]

It will be the closest match with the most players nearest to the correct position.

We will confer on it (Sainter and I)

[Rough_Edges]

Jeez I am gonna be close

(my predictions) (real)
1. Riewoldt - Riewoldt
2 - S.Fisher - Gram
3 - Goddard - S. Fisher
4 - Gram - Harvey
5 - Harvey - Goddard
6 - Dal - Dal
7 - Hudgton - Hudgton
8 - Montagna - Gehrig
9 - L.Ball - Monty
10 - Voss - Voss

All very close to their positions.

[Kildonan]

The quality of the top 10 picks was very high.

There were several very close but Sainter and I think that The Punter was the closest.

We have scored the competition by giving for each of the 10 positions:
10 points for getting an exact match
9 points for being 1 off exact match
8 points for being 2 off exact match
etc...
1 point for being 9 off exact match
0 points for player not named in top 10

Using this formula, The Punter wins with 86 points including 5 exact matches and 4 players 1 off their exact finishing positions.

No-one picked all 10 players.


1 Riewoldt 1
2 S Fisher 3
3 Gram 2
4 Harvey 4
5 Goddard 5/6
6 Dal Santo 5/6
7 Ball -
8 Montagna 9
9 Hudghton 7/8
10 Voss 10


Congratulations The Punter, you have won a year's free membership @ BigFooty

Time to find yourself an avatar

[johnnyhoward]

My pick - Real - Score

1. Goddard - Roo - 6
2. Riewoldt - Gram - 9
3. Dal Santo - S Fisher - 7
4. Gram - Harvey - 8
5. Harvey - Goddard - 9
6. S. Fisher - Dal Santo - 7
7. Montagna - Hudghton - 8
8. Baker - G-Train - 0
9. Hayes - Joey - 0
10. Hudghton - Voss - 7

I took a real punt on Goddard (I just wanted to go against popular opinion ;)).

So just out of interest because I'm bored, I scored a paltry 61...