View Full Version : Goodbye and Thanks
bomber_dave
2 Sep 2006, 11:30
These players should NOT be wearing the famous red sash next year:
Bolton
Cole
Heffernan
Henneman
Reynolds
Rioli
Jolley
Trade Bait (to get something you have to give up something decent)
Welsh
Soloman
Jimmy Gwilt
2 Sep 2006, 11:37
Bolton - think hell be traded
Cole - showing some good signs - think hell be kept
Heffernan - not going anywhere
Henneman - probably delisted
Reynolds - touch and go
Rioli - retired
Jolley - not going anywhere
also cartledge im not sure about, welsh should stay but u never know anyone can play his role (slattery). Solomon will stay
only o keefe at this stage of the rookies wil probably go
Given Cole and Heff are contracted i cant see them going anywhere ;)
big bomber
2 Sep 2006, 12:13
These players should NOT be wearing the famous red sash next year:
Bolton
Cole
Heffernan
Henneman
Reynolds
Rioli
Jolley
Trade Bait (to get something you have to give up something decent)
Welsh
Soloman
I think Cole did some good things last night and should definitely be kept Heffernan is a handy player to have as well. The others should be delisted or traded and i think we should package up Welsh and pick 36 for aker, and solomon fo a late second round or early third round pick seeing as the talent runs deep in this draft
Richie Cole was very good last night, why would we get rid of him after giving up a 2nd rounder last year?
go_the_bombers
2 Sep 2006, 12:25
Richie Cole was very good last night, why would we get rid of him after giving up a 2nd rounder last year?
True! He's got the pre season to train he backside off and get fit then impress next year and if he don't its out the door
True! He's got the pre season to train he backside off and get fit then impress next year and if he don't its out the door
if he keeps playing they way he did last night he won't be out the door, he has it in him
go_the_bombers
2 Sep 2006, 12:28
if he keeps playing they way he did last night he won't be out the door, he has it in him
True! But I was just saying get his fitness up and he will be a better player
True! But I was just saying get his fitness up and he will be a better player
yeah, looks like he's ober his injury woes which is good
The Dustbin
2 Sep 2006, 12:36
Bolton, Reynolds, Henneman, Cartledge to be delisted. Rama and Rioli retired.
I would prefer to keep Welsh and Solly...
mcphee_is_a_gun
2 Sep 2006, 12:38
The only thing Cartledge did last night was bring up his trade value imo.
The only thing Cartledge did last night was bring up his trade value imo.
exactly, hopefully someone bites
mcphee_is_a_gun
2 Sep 2006, 12:41
exactly, hopefully someone bites
realistically i think we'd get a 3rd rder.
realistically i think we'd get a 3rd rder.
i'd take that and run, if teams think we were going to de-list him anyway, we wouldn't get more than a 4th or 5th rounder, anything would be a bonus IMO
mcphee_is_a_gun
2 Sep 2006, 12:47
i'd take that and run, if teams think we were going to de-list him anyway, we wouldn't get more than a 4th or 5th rounder, anything would be a bonus IMO
I actually think he'll just be the sweetner in a trade we do, for a club needing a young developing ruckmen. St Kilda or Bulldogs maybe?
Darealrath
2 Sep 2006, 12:54
realistically i think we'd get a 3rd rder.
At best i reckon we'd be able to swap him and our (early) 4th round pick for a (mid-late) 3rd round pick.
He did some ok things last night though so i wouldn't be bothered if we kept him for another year for some ruck depth.
Bolton, Henno, Rioli, Reynolds and Jolley are the ones to go imo. All obvious. Carts maybe too. With Rama also unlikely to be on the proper list at the least. That's 6 or 7. Should be enough for our draft requirements unless we want to trade some experience to really raid the draft.
Cole has done a few things to impress me and will be a lot better with a pre-season. Heff has been ok this season. Both are contracted anyway.
monfries_young-gun
9 Sep 2006, 20:08
Bolton..
Henneman..
Reynolds..
Thanks for what?
Champs wear da No.16
9 Sep 2006, 21:23
These players should NOT be wearing the famous red sash next year:
Bolton
Cole
Heffernan
Henneman
Reynolds
Rioli
Jolley
Trade Bait (to get something you have to give up something decent)
Welsh
Soloman
Why jolley? the guy just wont the reserves B&F by 3 votes, and he missed 4 games....3 because he was playing AFL the other from illness
Longy413
10 Sep 2006, 19:08
Why jolley? the guy just wont the reserves B&F by 3 votes, and he missed 4 games....3 because he was playing AFL the other from illness
Maybe that's his level...
go_the_bombers
10 Sep 2006, 19:31
Maybe that's his level...
I think Jolley can play at AFL level! But Essendon have had a few players on its list in the past couple of years better at VFL than at AFL
MrAaron
10 Sep 2006, 19:34
hopefully Bolton & Hennemen will be offloaded to **** creak
then i'll be happy
go_the_bombers
10 Sep 2006, 19:37
hopefully Bolton & Hennemen will be offloaded to **** creak
then i'll be happy
What about Reynolds ;)
Jolley will never be more of a depth player and I'm not too sure he'd last long anyway if he was to be promoted as de-listing decisions look to become tougher over the next couple of years
whats wrong with you people, how much have you seen of him?
probably only the 3 AFL games he has played.... Jeez lucky we didnt dump Hird after his first 3 games, coz they were all ****house!
Longy413
11 Sep 2006, 18:40
What qualities does Jolley have that Hird had?
You're comparing to times when list sizes were a lot bigger.
go_the_bombers
11 Sep 2006, 19:02
whats wrong with you people, how much have you seen of him?
probably only the 3 AFL games he has played.... Jeez lucky we didnt dump Hird after his first 3 games, coz they were all ****house!
I cant remember Hirds first 3 games :o
dodgyJim
11 Sep 2006, 19:46
I would be disappointed to see Jolley get traded/delisted. haven't really seen enough of him to warrant that yet and the fact that he won the B&F it BGO is pretty good. I think he deserves another season.
I reckon Richie Cole should go and train with whoever the hell Jobe Watson trained with over the summer. An injury free and very fit Cole would be an asset off the HBF/Wing me thinks.