View Full Version : pies picks mids or talls?
barwick
10 Sep 2006, 20:45
Would like to hear what other pies fans think we need after getting belted by the bulldogs , what picks do we have and would we trade or just go for the kids?
Bengal Tiger
10 Sep 2006, 21:06
You need to pick kids or experienced players who have experienced success in September.
Its the only way to end the Collywobbles curse.
surfer1
11 Sep 2006, 09:16
We have a lot of very good young players coming up in next three years. They are not ready to be the flagbearers yet. We need at least 2 fast midfielders with 2-3 years behind then in the 22-24 year mould. A proepr big ruckman and that's all.
You need to pick kids or experienced players who have experienced success in September.
Its the only way to end the Collywobbles curse.
No point looking at the Tigers list then i guess.
Palmer Stoat
11 Sep 2006, 10:33
Truth is we need talls, mids, and a tap ruckman. But we won't be able to solve all these deficiencies in one draft.
vinnie_vegas69
11 Sep 2006, 10:49
I'd aim for a hard, inside mid in the first round, a versatile tall in the second round, and a project ruck/forward in the third round, as a rough guide.
Outa McSporren
11 Sep 2006, 13:11
Can anyone clarify for me which number pick the pies will now get in the draft?
Will we have pick 12 for finishing 5th or pick 10 for being the highest ranked loser of the elimination final? Or even pick 9 for possibly losing enough percentage to go underneath St Kilda?
Jack-Packenham
11 Sep 2006, 13:34
Can anyone clarify for me which number pick the pies will now get in the draft?
Will we have pick 12 for finishing 5th or pick 10 for being the highest ranked loser of the elimination final? Or even pick 9 for possibly losing enough percentage to go underneath St Kilda?
St Kilda 9
Collingwood 10
Outa McSporren
11 Sep 2006, 13:54
St Kilda 9
Collingwood 10
Cheers
Presti_is_god
11 Sep 2006, 14:00
Best available regardless of position. Get picky in the later rounds.
ford_dealer
11 Sep 2006, 14:26
If i were Collingwood, i would be looking at (if they are still around)
Jetta, Collard, or Selwood, or even maybe Albert Proud.
Maybe Sellar might be still around, and they could take him
They should then get a KPP they can work with for a few years (Ben Reid, Nathan Brown)
jimmy_clement#8
11 Sep 2006, 14:28
If i were Collingwood, i would be looking at (if they are still around)
Jetta, Collard, or Selwood, or even maybe Albert Proud.
Maybe Sellar might be still around, and they could take him
They should then get a KPP they can work with for a few years (Ben Reid, Nathan Brown)
Yep spot on. Priority is a gun midfielder with first pick.
ford_dealer
11 Sep 2006, 14:37
Also, before anyone points it out... i know Sellar is not a midfielder, but he would be good for Collingwood, whether he will be tall enough to be a genuine ruckman AFl ruckman i don't know, but he may be a handy CHF or CHB
will you take knoble,tivendale, roden, tuck, coughlin or hartigan??
will you take knoble,tivendale, roden, tuck, coughlin or hartigan??
Roden will probably be delisted no? Hartigan would be ok and Coughlin is worth a punt. Is he really that injury prone?
ptrain8
11 Sep 2006, 19:21
will you take knoble,tivendale, roden, tuck, coughlin or hartigan??
Coughlan will not be considered AT ALL for trading.
ford_dealer
11 Sep 2006, 19:29
Coughlan will not be considered AT ALL for trading.
exactly... Star player and leader at the club. He will return to his best form