Top 50

[laurens_vdS]

:)TOP 50 AS OF 15/09/06:)

1 Bryce Gibbs (Glenelg)
2 Scott Gumbleton (Peel Thunder)
3 Lachlan Hansen (Gippsland Power)
4 James Sellar (Glenelg)
5 Mitchell Thorp (Northern Bombers)
6 Matthew Leuenberger (East Perth)
7 Albert Proud (Mt.Gravatt)
8 Joel Selwood (Bendigo Pioneers) - :)Hopefully True:) - :thumbsu:GO TIGERS:thumbsu:
9 Leroy Jetta (South Fremantle)
10 Jack Riewoldt (Clarence)
11 Clayton Collard (South Fremantle)
12 Ricky Petterd (Broadbeach)
13 Bachar Houli (Western Jets)
14 Broc O’Brien (Peel Thunder)
15 Ben Reid (Murray Bushrangers)
16 Clinton Benjamin (Claremont)
17 Tom Hislop (Burnie Dockers)
18 Tom Hurley (Sturt)
19 Daniel Connors (Bendigo Pioneers)
20 Chris Schmidt (West Adelaide)
21 David Armitage (Morningside)
22 Shaun Grigg (North Ballarat Rebels)
23 Tom Hawkins (Sandringham Dragons)
24 Nathan Brown (North Ballarat Rebels)
25 Mitchell Brown (North Ballarat Rebels)
26 Eric MacKenzie (Claremont)
27 Brent Renouf (Southport)
28 Jarryd Morton (Claremont)
29 Jarryd Allen (Calder Cannons)
30 Andrejs Everitt (Dandenong Stingrays)
31 Gavin Urquhart (Morningside)
32 Tom Collier (Lauderdale)
33 Garry Moss (East Perth)
34 Travis Boak (Geelong Falcons)
35 Todd Pfeiffer (North Adelaide)
36 Jarrod Harbrow (Murray Bushrangers)
37 Robert Eddy (Gippsland Power)
38 Joshua Kennedy (Sandringham Dragons)
39 Kurt Tippett (Southport)
40 Daniel O’Keefe (Geelong Falcons)
41 Nathan Djerrkura (Wanderers)
42 Jackson Sheringham (Geelong Falcons)
43 Daniel Dzufer (Caloundra)
44 James Hawksley (Peel Thunder)
45 Tim Houlihan (North Ballarat Rebels)
46 Shawn Colbung (East Perth)
47 Ben Ross (Gippsland Power)
48 Grant Weeks (Bendigo Pioneers)
49 Shaun Hampson (Mt.Gravatt)
50 Rhyce Prismall (Western Jets)

[sinepari]

Where did you flog that from?

Grub has been doing a top 50 for overa month

[laurens_vdS]

Yeah Grub has a good list!:thumbsu:

[brett_go_cats]

how come hawkins is down at 23? should he be on the list even since he is F/S?

[laurens_vdS]

SOZ forgot about that one!:o

[sinepari]

Why Mitchell Brown ahead of Collier & MacKenzie?

Why Hawksley so low?

Not a criticism, I'd just like to hear your reasoning.

Cheers

[laurens_vdS]

Haven't seen much of Hawksley play but from wat ive heard should probally be a bit hire!
Now that i think about it MacKenzie should probally be infront of him but i still do not think Collier is up to his standard!

[laurens_vdS]

In my opinion

[sinepari]

I think Collier is a MUCH better prospect than M.Brown. But that's just my opinion.

What part of his game is inferior?

[laurens_vdS]

Do not hink clubs will go to him!
In AFL will not be able to ruck! to short
has good speed and fitness but i think his marking lets him down on sum ocassions:thumbsd:

[sinepari]

Of course he won't ruck at AFL. CHB/Flanker.

I definitely think clubs will go him, earlier than some anticipate.

I'm not sure what you mean by 'marking lets him down'. I don't see too many flaws in that area.

[laurens_vdS]

Havent you seen him play.
IMO his marking lets him down.
wat do u think clubs will see in him? IM NOT SURE:confused:

[diablo14]

:)TOP 50 AS OF 15/09/06:)

1 Bryce Gibbs (Glenelg)
2 Scott Gumbleton (Peel Thunder)
3 Lachlan Hansen (Gippsland Power)
4 James Sellar (Glenelg)
5 Mitchell Thorp (Northern Bombers)
6 Matthew Leuenberger (East Perth)
7 Albert Proud (Mt.Gravatt)
8 Joel Selwood (Bendigo Pioneers) - :)Hopefully True:) - :thumbsu:GO TIGERS:thumbsu:
9 Leroy Jetta (South Fremantle)
10 Jack Riewoldt (Clarence)
11 Clayton Collard (South Fremantle)
12 Ricky Petterd (Broadbeach)
13 Bachar Houli (Western Jets)
14 Broc O’Brien (Peel Thunder)
15 Ben Reid (Murray Bushrangers)
16 Clinton Benjamin (Claremont)
17 Tom Hislop (Burnie Dockers)
18 Tom Hurley (Sturt)
19 Daniel Connors (Bendigo Pioneers)
20 Chris Schmidt (West Adelaide)
21 David Armitage (Morningside)
22 Shaun Grigg (North Ballarat Rebels)
23 Tom Hawkins (Sandringham Dragons)
24 Nathan Brown (North Ballarat Rebels)
25 Mitchell Brown (North Ballarat Rebels)
26 Eric MacKenzie (Claremont)
27 Brent Renouf (Southport)
28 Jarryd Morton (Claremont)
29 Jarryd Allen (Calder Cannons)
30 Andrejs Everitt (Dandenong Stingrays)
31 Gavin Urquhart (Morningside)
32 Tom Collier (Lauderdale)
33 Garry Moss (East Perth)
34 Travis Boak (Geelong Falcons)
35 Todd Pfeiffer (North Adelaide)
36 Jarrod Harbrow (Murray Bushrangers)
37 Robert Eddy (Gippsland Power)
38 Joshua Kennedy (Sandringham Dragons)
39 Kurt Tippett (Southport)
40 Daniel O’Keefe (Geelong Falcons)
41 Nathan Djerrkura (Wanderers)
42 Jackson Sheringham (Geelong Falcons)
43 Daniel Dzufer (Caloundra)
44 James Hawksley (Peel Thunder)
45 Tim Houlihan (North Ballarat Rebels)
46 Shawn Colbung (East Perth)
47 Ben Ross (Gippsland Power)
48 Grant Weeks (Bendigo Pioneers)
49 Shaun Hampson (Mt.Gravatt)
50 Rhyce Prismall (Western Jets)


grub??? is that you??? or someone trying to pretend they know as much as you??? get your own list buddy boy.

[Pharaoh]

grub??? is that you??? or someone trying to pretend they know as much as you??? get your own list buddy boy.

I think it's just a Tigers fan with no actual idea doing a quick copy and paste from Grub's list and then putting Joel Selwood at no. 8 which was the whole purpose of the exercise.

[sinepari]

Havent you seen him play.
IMO his marking lets him down.
wat do u think clubs will see in him? IM NOT SURE:confused:
Don't insult me, nor turn things around. I've been following these kids for more than just this season.

[diablo14]

I think it's just a Tigers fan with no actual idea doing a quick copy and paste from Grub's list and then putting Joel Selwood at no. 8 which was the whole purpose of the exercise.

fair call. but why not just say, i want the tiges to take selwood at 8, rather than starting to try to pass off the list as something they themselves created?

[laurens_vdS]

were do u think selwood wil go then?
is he really better than who is infront of him?

[sinepari]

Selwood is a freak, and could easily go top 4.

Could slide too, however that would be a huge pick-up for any club.

[sinepari]

Why do you rate Hurley ahead of Connors?

[laurens_vdS]

i agree selwood is a good cahnce to go top four bit in there there are a range of quality players!
I thinm the top three is set in GOLD!
but after that it's nearly even

[laurens_vdS]

soz lots of typos!

[sinepari]

This thread is a good laugh.

[micky_11]

i think hislop will go higher than 17, he dominates in every game