View Full Version : Who will have more success in the US?
ICanDressMyself
31 Oct 2006, 17:51
Following the great success of Ben Graham, who will have the better career in America?
Following the great success of Ben Graham, who will have the better career in America?
my vote is for dew, he would be on mabey 200,000 grand at port, and at his age coulkd be getting a lot more for a longer period of time.
Mitchell Madness
1 Nov 2006, 08:29
I personally believe stewie dew. Unliek rocca, he has a lot more versetility, and nto only would be able to be a punter, but could maybe see himself as one of the wingers or wide recievers or whatever they call it in the NFL
I voted the Big Sav..
I fear the Cheerleaders and Chilli Dogs will prove too much of a distraction for Baby Duey.
in the paper today it was almost certain that he was going to leave, that would be a shame for port if he did
ICanDressMyself
1 Nov 2006, 16:40
in the paper today it was almost certain that he was going to leave, that would be a shame for port if he did
He's no longer at Port Power.
He's no longer at Port Power.
so hes left?
thats a shame, hopefully he does well in nfl
Dj Chriss
1 Nov 2006, 17:10
Sav would be, he is not only a bigger kick but he can also make a tackle unlike the soft stuart dew
TigerGlory
1 Nov 2006, 19:26
Dunno if they would want Dew on the field at all, there jobs are to punt and thats it.
On just punting, you'd pick Sav Rocca by a mile. But if they did indeed put them on the ground, Stuart Dew would be pretty useful, he does have a bit of pace on him.
Sav would be, he is not only a bigger kick but he can also make a tackle unlike the soft stuart dew
Ignorant comment there. Punters don't tackle :rolleyes:
Anyway Rocca has the better chance of making it because he has both length and 'hang time' in his kicks while Dew can roost them a fair distance he wouldn't get the required hang time unless he dramatically changed his kicking style. Both Dew and Rocca might not make any rosters as they will be competeing against other guys for one spot.
I do think Dew would be a great place kicker (if he learnt to kick from a tee) because hes accurate and kicks long and flat.
I personally believe stewie dew. Unliek rocca, he has a lot more versetility, and nto only would be able to be a punter, but could maybe see himself as one of the wingers or wide recievers or whatever they call it in the NFL
Punters are Punters mate, they dont double up as wide recievers.
Mitchell Madness
2 Nov 2006, 17:02
Punters are Punters mate, they dont double up as wide recievers.
That is not what i meant, what i mean was that when he is in training the club thinking of drafting him may find him more suitable to a different role
mudgeathon
2 Nov 2006, 21:47
That is not what i meant, what i mean was that when he is in training the club thinking of drafting him may find him more suitable to a different role
Would never happed...most people don't realise how fast and talented you have to be, to be a wide reciever in american football. Some of the wide recievers are some of fastest people in the world, who can run low 10 second 100m, no footy player can go below 10.5 or 10.6
And he wouldn't even get a mention for been a blocker, some of them are over 150kg. He literally would get smashed.
Killer eagle
2 Nov 2006, 22:52
Who cares, NFL is a game of padded up rugby players, that has constant stoppages every 5 seconds to allow the overweight crowd with the short attention spans to get down to the burger stand and chow down on there supersized quadriplepounder meals, while theyre deciding which school to shoot up next.
westdog54
2 Nov 2006, 23:19
IMO Rocca is a much better kicker of the ball. Just a beautiful natural kicking action
westdog54
2 Nov 2006, 23:41
Ignorant comment there. Punters don't tackle :rolleyes:
Anyway Rocca has the better chance of making it because he has both length and 'hang time' in his kicks while Dew can roost them a fair distance he wouldn't get the required hang time unless he dramatically changed his kicking style. Both Dew and Rocca might not make any rosters as they will be competeing against other guys for one spot.
I do think Dew would be a great place kicker (if he learnt to kick from a tee) because hes accurate and kicks long and flat.
Generally no, but if the bloke returning the punt beats the oncoming defenders, its handy to have another player who can lay a tackle.