hawkeyeqld
4 Mar 2002, 13:58
Where they started... where they are now, for whatever reason.
Any thoughts on losing these players.. here's mine?
ADELAIDE
D.Gallagher, A.Eccles (CARL), C.Rintoul (COLL), S.Wellman (ESS), L.Picioane, S.Rehn (HAW), P.Vardy (MELB), R.O'Loughlin (SYD).
*Wellman a star, Picioane will be. Rehn past prime, Eccles will be a good squad player for Blues and the rest are ordinary.
BRISBANE
M.Clarke (ADEL), S.O'Bree, N.Buckley (COLL), R.Hilton (RICH), S.Lawrence, B.Voss, T.Knobel (STK), S.Rusca, M.Picken, T.Bartlett (WB).
* 4 top quality players there. But you can afford to get rid of players of that quality when the only thing visible from the AFL's a**e is Brisbane's (and Sydney's) toenails. :D
CARLTON
K.Massie, B.Nelson (ADEL), A.Chatfield (GEEL), M.Porter (KANG), A.Hamill (STK), B.Harrison (WB).
* Hamill the star here..
COLLINGWOOD
M.Michael (BRIS), T.Hotton (CARL), B.Sanderson (GEEL), S.Rocca, J.McCartney (KANG), N.Stone (HAW), A.Schauble, P.Williams (SYD), B.Tuckey (WCE), A.James (WB).
* These 10 players would beat todays Collingwood! :eek:
ESSENDON
C.Ladhams (ADEL), J.Doering, M.Davis, G.Manton (CARL), S.Cummings, A.Dimmatina (COLL), S.Eastaugh (FRE), D.Johnson (GEEL), D.Hardwick, A.Kingsley, C.C-Collins, G.Wanganeen (PA),
S.Milne (STK).
* Is Port Adelaide Essendons pasture?
FITZROY
C.Johnson, A.Lynch (BRIS), J.Molloy (COLL), D.Kickett (FRE), T.Woods, J.Barker (HAW), S.Clayton, J.Blakey (KANG), D.Ward (MELB), M.Primus, S.Paxman (PA), R.Warfe (SYD).
* What a team... if only...
FREMANTLE
D.Schell (ADEL), R.Betheras, J.Clement, B.Holland (COLL), M.Burton, J.Sinclair, W.Abraham (KANG), J.White (MELB), G.Taylor (RICH), C.Callaghan, H.Black (STK), T.Carroll, G.Harding (WCE), K.Hunter, D.Bandy (WB).
* Freo, freo, freo :rolleyes:
GEELONG
M.Mansfield, E.Bray, S.Fletcher, A.Hickmott (CARL), C.Steinfort (COLL), L.Colbert (KANG), C.Bizzell (MELB), A.Houlihan, C.Biddiscome (RICH), G.Bennett, L.Brockman (SYD), M.Robbins (WB).
* Ordinary players picked up by other clubs.. player development must not be up to scratch, as the other teams see potential which Geelong could not harness. Colbert wanted finals footy. Lee.. go back in 2004!
HAWTHORN
B.Scott (BRIS), P.Barnard (ESS), T.Croad, L.McPharlin (FRE), J.Baird (KANG), G.Rigoni (MELB), P.Hudson (RICH), C.Obst (SYD), M.Collica, R.Taylor (WCE), N.Saunders (WB).
* Good players here mostly traded for high draft picks.
MELBOURNE
N.Bassett (ADEL), M.Pike (BRIS), J.Farmer, T.Simmonds, J.Norrish, T.Longmuir (FRE), B.Grgic (GEEL), M.Bishop (PORT).
* Will Grgic or Bizzell kick nine in a half? Not likely.
NORTH MELB
M.Stevens, B.Bienke, E.Hewitt, S.Welsh (ADEL), C.McKernan, L.Smith (CARL), G.Freeborn (COLL), B.Sholl, T.McGrath, K.Kingsley, C.Mooney (GEEL), M.Capuano (STK), W.Schwass (SYD).
* Gee, someone at North must be hogging all the money? Let's hope he doesn't get injured. :cool:
PORT ADELAIDE
R.Biglands, M.Bode (ADEL), S.Freeborn (CARL), N.Eagleton (WB).
* Excess weight here.
RICHMOND
J.Murphy (CARL), S.McKee (COLL), R.Funcke (MELB), D.Bourke (KANG), J.Plapp (STK), S.Maxfield (SYD), M.Merenda (WCE).
* 3 good players, 5 run of the mill delistings.
ST. KILDA
M.Lappin, S.Cranage (CARL), S.Wakelin (COLL), M.Carr (FRE), J.Smith (HAW), J.McLaren (KANG), D.Wakelin (PORT), S.Sziller (RICH), A.Dunkley, B.Hall, T.Lockett (SYD), D.Sierakowski (WCE).
* Better go to the bar and drown your sorrows Sainters. :mad:
SYDNEY
R.Fitzgerald (ADEL), P.Licuria, A.Rocca (COLL), T.Cook (FRE), G.Stafford, D.Gaspar, C.King (RICH), S.Garlick (WB).
* Does this mean Greg Stafford will be a handy pick-up?
WEST COAST
B.Fewster, D.Metropolis (FRE), M.White (GEEL), B.Robbins (KANG), J.Crabb (PA), F.Gehrig (STK), J.Ball (SYD).
* 3 good talls who would be very useful back where they started.
WESTERN BULLDOGS
M.Martin (BRIS), J.Plunkett (CARL), T.Lane (COLL), C.Ellis, S.Powell (MELB), S.Cox (HAW), B.Montgomery (PORT), L.Cameron (RICH).
* all players have gone on to better things.
Any thoughts on losing these players.. here's mine?
ADELAIDE
D.Gallagher, A.Eccles (CARL), C.Rintoul (COLL), S.Wellman (ESS), L.Picioane, S.Rehn (HAW), P.Vardy (MELB), R.O'Loughlin (SYD).
*Wellman a star, Picioane will be. Rehn past prime, Eccles will be a good squad player for Blues and the rest are ordinary.
BRISBANE
M.Clarke (ADEL), S.O'Bree, N.Buckley (COLL), R.Hilton (RICH), S.Lawrence, B.Voss, T.Knobel (STK), S.Rusca, M.Picken, T.Bartlett (WB).
* 4 top quality players there. But you can afford to get rid of players of that quality when the only thing visible from the AFL's a**e is Brisbane's (and Sydney's) toenails. :D
CARLTON
K.Massie, B.Nelson (ADEL), A.Chatfield (GEEL), M.Porter (KANG), A.Hamill (STK), B.Harrison (WB).
* Hamill the star here..
COLLINGWOOD
M.Michael (BRIS), T.Hotton (CARL), B.Sanderson (GEEL), S.Rocca, J.McCartney (KANG), N.Stone (HAW), A.Schauble, P.Williams (SYD), B.Tuckey (WCE), A.James (WB).
* These 10 players would beat todays Collingwood! :eek:
ESSENDON
C.Ladhams (ADEL), J.Doering, M.Davis, G.Manton (CARL), S.Cummings, A.Dimmatina (COLL), S.Eastaugh (FRE), D.Johnson (GEEL), D.Hardwick, A.Kingsley, C.C-Collins, G.Wanganeen (PA),
S.Milne (STK).
* Is Port Adelaide Essendons pasture?
FITZROY
C.Johnson, A.Lynch (BRIS), J.Molloy (COLL), D.Kickett (FRE), T.Woods, J.Barker (HAW), S.Clayton, J.Blakey (KANG), D.Ward (MELB), M.Primus, S.Paxman (PA), R.Warfe (SYD).
* What a team... if only...
FREMANTLE
D.Schell (ADEL), R.Betheras, J.Clement, B.Holland (COLL), M.Burton, J.Sinclair, W.Abraham (KANG), J.White (MELB), G.Taylor (RICH), C.Callaghan, H.Black (STK), T.Carroll, G.Harding (WCE), K.Hunter, D.Bandy (WB).
* Freo, freo, freo :rolleyes:
GEELONG
M.Mansfield, E.Bray, S.Fletcher, A.Hickmott (CARL), C.Steinfort (COLL), L.Colbert (KANG), C.Bizzell (MELB), A.Houlihan, C.Biddiscome (RICH), G.Bennett, L.Brockman (SYD), M.Robbins (WB).
* Ordinary players picked up by other clubs.. player development must not be up to scratch, as the other teams see potential which Geelong could not harness. Colbert wanted finals footy. Lee.. go back in 2004!
HAWTHORN
B.Scott (BRIS), P.Barnard (ESS), T.Croad, L.McPharlin (FRE), J.Baird (KANG), G.Rigoni (MELB), P.Hudson (RICH), C.Obst (SYD), M.Collica, R.Taylor (WCE), N.Saunders (WB).
* Good players here mostly traded for high draft picks.
MELBOURNE
N.Bassett (ADEL), M.Pike (BRIS), J.Farmer, T.Simmonds, J.Norrish, T.Longmuir (FRE), B.Grgic (GEEL), M.Bishop (PORT).
* Will Grgic or Bizzell kick nine in a half? Not likely.
NORTH MELB
M.Stevens, B.Bienke, E.Hewitt, S.Welsh (ADEL), C.McKernan, L.Smith (CARL), G.Freeborn (COLL), B.Sholl, T.McGrath, K.Kingsley, C.Mooney (GEEL), M.Capuano (STK), W.Schwass (SYD).
* Gee, someone at North must be hogging all the money? Let's hope he doesn't get injured. :cool:
PORT ADELAIDE
R.Biglands, M.Bode (ADEL), S.Freeborn (CARL), N.Eagleton (WB).
* Excess weight here.
RICHMOND
J.Murphy (CARL), S.McKee (COLL), R.Funcke (MELB), D.Bourke (KANG), J.Plapp (STK), S.Maxfield (SYD), M.Merenda (WCE).
* 3 good players, 5 run of the mill delistings.
ST. KILDA
M.Lappin, S.Cranage (CARL), S.Wakelin (COLL), M.Carr (FRE), J.Smith (HAW), J.McLaren (KANG), D.Wakelin (PORT), S.Sziller (RICH), A.Dunkley, B.Hall, T.Lockett (SYD), D.Sierakowski (WCE).
* Better go to the bar and drown your sorrows Sainters. :mad:
SYDNEY
R.Fitzgerald (ADEL), P.Licuria, A.Rocca (COLL), T.Cook (FRE), G.Stafford, D.Gaspar, C.King (RICH), S.Garlick (WB).
* Does this mean Greg Stafford will be a handy pick-up?
WEST COAST
B.Fewster, D.Metropolis (FRE), M.White (GEEL), B.Robbins (KANG), J.Crabb (PA), F.Gehrig (STK), J.Ball (SYD).
* 3 good talls who would be very useful back where they started.
WESTERN BULLDOGS
M.Martin (BRIS), J.Plunkett (CARL), T.Lane (COLL), C.Ellis, S.Powell (MELB), S.Cox (HAW), B.Montgomery (PORT), L.Cameron (RICH).
* all players have gone on to better things.