Very Tough Question - The Other Way

[The Coon Dog]

Who the LATEST player to arrive at the Kennel from every other club. They must have played at least one game at BOTH clubs.

I am not counting those who played for another AFL Club in between (eg: Ben Harrison went from Carlton to Richmond then to the Bulldogs, so I wouldn't count him as the Carlton player, even though he wasn't the latest, just an example).

ADELAIDE:
BRISBANE:
CARLTON:
COLLINGWOOD:
ESSENDON:
FITZROY:
FREMANTLE:
GEELONG:
HAWTHORN:
MELBOURNE:
NORTH MELBOURNE:
PORT ADELAIDE:
RICHMOND:
St.KILDA:
SYDNEY:
WEST COAST:

* I cannot find anyone that came from Adelaide, nor can I think of anyone either.

[Captain Sensible]

If you're going to have the Brions and Fitzroy then you should have The Brissy Bears as a seperate entity as well.

[Aquamarinejewel]

ADELAIDE:
BRISBANE:
CARLTON:
COLLINGWOOD:
ESSENDON:
FITZROY:
FREMANTLE:
GEELONG: Peter Street
HAWTHORN:
MELBOURNE:
NORTH MELBOURNE:
PORT ADELAIDE:
RICHMOND:
St.KILDA:
SYDNEY:
WEST COAST:

[The Coon Dog]

ADELAIDE:
BRISBANE:
CARLTON:
COLLINGWOOD:
ESSENDON:
FITZROY:
FREMANTLE:
GEELONG: Peter Street
HAWTHORN:
MELBOURNE:
NORTH MELBOURNE:
PORT ADELAIDE:
RICHMOND:
St.KILDA:
SYDNEY:
WEST COAST:

That all you could think of??? The tennis must be good!

[The Coon Dog]

If you're going to have the Brions and Fitzroy then you should have The Brissy Bears as a seperate entity as well.

I'll allow you to have carte blanche on this one. It's late, I'm tired & off the top of my head I'm struggling to think of a Bear that became a Bulldog.

[Aquamarinejewel]

That all you could think of??? The tennis must be good!

Ha! very funny. I didn't want to take the excitement and enjoyment away from our other Doggie Posters having a go at guessing. Yes, the tennis was very good.

[Templeton31]

ADELAIDE:
BRISBANE: Aker
CARLTON:
COLLINGWOOD:
ESSENDON:
FITZROY:
FREMANTLE: Koops
GEELONG: Peter Street
HAWTHORN:
MELBOURNE:
NORTH MELBOURNE:
PORT ADELAIDE: Morgan
RICHMOND:
St.KILDA:
SYDNEY: Garlick?
WEST COAST:McDoogs

It is tough!

[wb_age]

ADELAIDE:
BRISBANE:
CARLTON:
COLLINGWOOD:
ESSENDON:
FITZROY:
FREMANTLE:Koops
GEELONG: Peter Street
HAWTHORN:Rawlings
MELBOURNE:
NORTH MELBOURNE:
PORT ADELAIDE:Eagleton
RICHMOND:
St.KILDA:
SYDNEY:
WEST COAST:

[lifelike_]

ADELAIDE:
BRISBANE: Marty Pask (IIRC arrived after Aker?)
CARLTON:
COLLINGWOOD:
ESSENDON:
FITZROY:
FREMANTLE: Steven Koops
GEELONG: Peter Street
HAWTHORN: Jade Rawlings
MELBOURNE:
NORTH MELBOURNE:
PORT ADELAIDE: Nathan Eagleton
RICHMOND:
St.KILDA: Nicky Winmar
SYDNEY: Richard Osborne
WEST COAST:

[Aquamarinejewel]

Unsure about this one....but was Tony Campbell the latest Melbourne player to cross over to us?

[westdog54]

Port Adelaide- Brett Montgomery

[westdog54]

Unsure about this one....but was Tony Campbell the latest Melbourne player to cross over to us?
Pretty sure Luke Beveridge was later

Not sure we can count Aker and Pask as they haven't actually played for us yet, so I'm thinking Bartlett from Brisbane.

blown if I can think of the rest.

[lifelike_]

I think Aaron James came from Richmond.

[Aquamarinejewel]

Pretty sure Luke Beveridge was later.

Ofcourse, I forgot about poor Beveridge. Thanks for that westdog54.

[~PC~]

ADELAIDE:
BRISBANE: Travis Baird
CARLTON: James Cook
COLLINGWOOD: Todd Curley
ESSENDON:Gary Barrow
FITZROY: Matthew Dent
FREMANTLE: Stephen Koops
GEELONG: Peter Street
HAWTHORN: Jade Rawlings
MELBOURNE: Tony Campbell
NORTH MELBOURNE: Jose Romero
PORT ADELAIDE: Brett Montgomery
RICHMOND: Aaron James
St.KILDA: Nicky Winmar
SYDNEY: Simon Garlick
WEST COAST: Robbie West

[~PC~]

Pretty sure Luke Beveridge was later

Not sure we can count Aker and Pask as they haven't actually played for us yet, so I'm thinking Bartlett from Brisbane.

blown if I can think of the rest.

Campbell went back to Melbourne and came back to us in 95 for 96 season at which point i think Beverage was already at St Kilda.

[Aquamarinejewel]

A stab in the dark here....how about Tony Buhagiar coming over to us from Essendon?

[~PC~]

A stab in the dark here....how about Tony Buhagiar coming over to us from Essendon?

My records indicated Gary Barrow.

And NO ONE from Adelaide. Ever. The other way yes, but not our way.

[The Coon Dog]

So far these are correct.

ADELAIDE:
BRISBANE: TRAVIS BAIRD (short memories or what?)
CARLTON: JAMES COOK
COLLINGWOOD:
ESSENDON:TONY BUHAGIAR
FITZROY: MATTHEW DENT
FREMANTLE: STEVEN KOOPS
GEELONG: PETER STREET
HAWTHORN: JADE RAWLINGS
MELBOURNE:
NORTH MELBOURNE:
PORT ADELAIDE: BRETT MONTGOMERY (see note for Travis Baird)
RICHMOND: AARON JAMES
St.KILDA: NICKY WINMAR
SYDNEY: SIMON GARLICK
WEST COAST: ROBBIE WEST

Aker, Pask & McDougall haven't played a game for the Bulldogs.

The following guesses are wrong:
Gary Barrow - came from Essendon without playing a senior game there (as did Keenan Reynolds).
Todd Curley, Tony Campbell, Luke Beveridge, Jose Romero, Nathan Eagleton (Scott Bassett, Adam Morgan & Monty all came after him), Adam Morgan & Richard Osborne weren't the most recent arrivals at the Kennel from their respective clubs.

JUST 3 TO GO (Excluding Adelaide).

[Monkster]

From Melbourne, Allen Jackovich?

[Aquamarinejewel]

So I was correct on Tony Buhagiar ...TCD?

[~PC~]

Melbourne is Allan Jackovich
Collingwood is Josh Mahoney

[The Coon Dog]

From Melbourne, Allen Jackovich?

YES!!

[The Coon Dog]

So I was correct on Tony Buhagiar ...TCD?
You seem surprised? Yes, you were correct.

[The Coon Dog]

So far these are correct.

ADELAIDE:
BRISBANE: TRAVIS BAIRD (short memories or what?)
CARLTON: JAMES COOK
COLLINGWOOD:
ESSENDON:TONY BUHAGIAR
FITZROY: MATTHEW DENT
FREMANTLE: STEVEN KOOPS
GEELONG: PETER STREET
HAWTHORN: JADE RAWLINGS
MELBOURNE: ALLAN JAKOVICH
NORTH MELBOURNE: JOSE ROMERO
PORT ADELAIDE: BRETT MONTGOMERY (see note for Travis Baird)
RICHMOND: AARON JAMES
St.KILDA: NICKY WINMAR
SYDNEY: SIMON GARLICK
WEST COAST: ROBBIE WEST

Just Collingwood to go. Todd Curley arrived in 1996 & this guy arrived 3 years later.

[Aquamarinejewel]

You seem surprised? Yes, you were correct.

Not surprised I thought as much just wasn't 100% sure.

[~PC~]

I still say it was Jose from North.

[The Coon Dog]

I still say it was Jose from North.


You are right. It was Jose. I was looking at the wrong dates for Phil Krakouer but he arrived 3 years before Jose.

As Maxwell Smart would say, "Sorry about that P.C."

[~PC~]

You are right. It was Jose. I was looking at the wrong dates for Phil Krakouer but he arrived 3 years before Jose.

As Maxwell Smart would say, "Sorry about that P.C."

And Josh for Collingwood?

[lifelike_]

Josh Mahoney from Collingwood?

Edit: Beaten to it :)

[~PC~]

Post the answer! I want to go to bed.

[The Coon Dog]

Josh Mahoney from Collingwood?

Edit: Beaten to it :)


Well done everyone!!!!!!!!!!!


That was a bit of fun, certainly tests the grey matter, surprising tho how quickly you forget some names.

[The Coon Dog]

The full list.

ADELAIDE: NONE
BRISBANE: TRAVIS BAIRD
CARLTON: JAMES COOK
COLLINGWOOD: JOSH MAHONEY
ESSENDON:TONY BUHAGIAR
FITZROY: MATTHEW DENT
FREMANTLE: STEVEN KOOPS
GEELONG: PETER STREET
HAWTHORN: JADE RAWLINGS
MELBOURNE: ALLAN JAKOVICH
NORTH MELBOURNE: JOSE ROMERO
PORT ADELAIDE: BRETT MONTGOMERY
RICHMOND: AARON JAMES
St.KILDA: NICKY WINMAR
SYDNEY: SIMON GARLICK
WEST COAST: ROBBIE WEST

[~PC~]

Good work CD. I did enjoy doing that. Cheers.

[comrade]

With the exception of a few, that list just goes to show that our trading history is somewhat shady. Let's hope we've turned a corner!!

[~PC~]

With the exception of a few, that list just goes to show that our trading history is somewhat shady. Let's hope we've turned a corner!!

I think you'll find all but four were actually drafted.

[Dog Town]

Did Jeff Hilton get cleared from Melbourne to us in exchange for Darryl Griifen? I know it fell though but cant remember what the circumstances were.

[RedWhite&Blue]

Did Jeff Hilton get cleared from Melbourne to us in exchange for Darryl Griifen? I know it fell though but cant remember what the circumstances were.

Is that Ryan Griffen's dad?
Ha ha ha harrrrrrrr...