Round 1 Votes vs Sydney

[Big Cox]

We do a 5 system here dont we. Here goes

5. Daniel Kerr - What a tackle in the end. Super all day. Gonna win the Brownlow soon I think
4. Chris Judd - Not as good as Kerr but not far off. Typical Judd
3. David Wirrpanda - Looked the fittest he has in a while. Marshalled the defence
2. Mark Seaby - Went one on 2 vs the best ruck combo in the league and more then did well. 2 crucial goals too
1. Rowan Jones - Couldnt do a thing wrong today. Best game in a year I think from him

Honorbale mentions : Mitch Brown Adam Selwood and Q Lynch (just missed out both of them).

[BarcaRulz]

5. Kerr: highest possies, fantastic game-winning tackle
4. Judd: explosive, 2 goals, some good clearences
3. Wirrapanda: great at the back, good cleaning/mopping up
2. Selwood: always open, good kicking, cool head
1. Seaby: did well alone in the ruck, good goal, good midfield play

Unlucky: Lynch, Chick, Waters, Brown

[EagleMan87]

5: Judd, christ, can anyone tackle this man?!
4: Kerr, awesome. Barely laid a foot wrong and was unstoppable around the clearances.
3: Rojo, I agree, his best game in ages. No bad kicks, constantly in the action
4: Brown. For a first gamer he was awesome. No goals, but constant pressure and a great mark. Desereves a RS nomination from his first game, how good is that?
5: Staker. Considering I didn't think he was ready for this game, he was great. Always near the ball, in defence or attack or midfield. I'm definatley impressed.

Unlucky: Chick, Seaby was awesome, Wirra, Lynch, Waters

[TheBigUnit]

5 - Kerr
4 - Judd
3 - Wirrpanda
2 - Seaby
1 - Lynch

Last 2 were hard to give. Great team performance!

[Belgarion]

I haven't seen the match yet. Here in Brisbane both channel 10 and foxtel had the Lions vs Hawks match. The Eagles Vs Swans match is not shown until 2am.

I will watch a replay tomorrow and vote then.

Belgarion

[Embers]

5. Kerr - Easily BOG. That tackle was inspiring. Show it time and time again to the youngsters
4. Judd - No explanation needed. So slick
3. RJones - Just awesome today. Didnt put a foot wrong I thought. Best performance in years
2. Adam Selwood - Could raffle it here but Selly deserves 2. Everytime the ball was kicked into their forward line he was there in some shape or form.
1. David Wirrpanda - If it wasnt for THAT kick hed be higher but overall apart from that one bad mistake it was the fittest and fastest he has looked in along time. Good game

[Special Agent]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Seaby
2. Wirrpanda
1. R Jones

[Embers]

I haven't seen the match yet. Here in Brisbane both channel 10 and foxtel had the Lions vs Hawks match. The Eagles Vs Swans match is not shown until 2am.

I will watch a replay tomorrow and vote then.

Belgarion

That sucks ey :thumbsd:

[Fletchers Girl]

5 - KERR An amazing game and a great match saving tackle!
4 - JUDD Enough said the guy is a fking legend!!
3 - SEABY Did really well considering
2 - WIRRA Really stood up and did some great things
1 - BROWN Did some great things early on especially since it was his 1st game

[Frizzo]

5 - Judd
4 - Kerr
3 - R. Jones
2 - Selwood
1 - Wirrpunda

[Alphanumeric]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Seaby
2. Staker
1. Wirra

Staker did an awesome job on Goodes.

[Embers]

5 - Judd
4 - Kerr
3 - R. Jones
2 - Selwood
1 - Wirrpunda

That is a intelligent man my friends :)

[lyall]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Seaby
2. Selwood
1. Glass

[Lion El'Johnson]

5 - Kerr
4 - Seaby
3 - Judd
2 - Selwood
1 - Brown

[The_Eagles]

Judd
Kerr
Seaby
Wirrpanda
Brown

[Gunnar Longshanks]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Seaby
2. Glass
1. Selwood

Glass gets overlooked pretty regularly.

I thought he beat Barry Hall soundly tonight. Very important effort.

[Embers]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Seaby
2. Glass
1. Selwood

Glass gets overlooked pretty regularly.

I thought he beat Barry Hall soundly tonight. Very important effort.

Good point bout Glass but his disposal tonight was absolutely horrible. I cringed when he got near it. Did the defensive job though with some help for a change

[eagleskickass]

5 - Kerr
4 - Judd
3 - Seaby!
2 - Wirrpanda
1 - Brown

[Gunnar Longshanks]

Good point bout Glass but his disposal tonight was absolutely horrible. I cringed when he got near it. Did the defensive job though with some help for a changeHall is Sydney's most important player. Glass beat him soundly.

How can people get excited about Staker's performance on Goodes while ignoring the superior efforts of Glass on Hall?

Don't take Glass for granted. That was an excellent performance on Hall tonight.

[Jimbob]

5. Kerr - BOG easily
4. R Jones - presented well and was in everything
3. Seaby - Good job in the ruck
2. Wirra - Good as always, was a bit untidy early thou but moped up as usual
1. Brown - Good 1st game

[heals]

5-BROWN
4-BROWN
3-BROWN
2-BROWN
1-BROWN

Nah seriousley
5- Kerr
4- Judd
3- Seaby
2- Wirrapunda
1- BROWN


:D :thumbsu:

[daddy_4_eyes]

5.Kerr - I thought he was BOG. Stepped up when needed and had some vital touches
4. Judd - Consistent all day, but not his usual dominant self (stats aside)
3. Selwood - I thought he was crucial to our defensive setup.
2. Seaby - Rucked well, beat Everitt and Jolly. But couldn't beat the umps
1. R.Jones - The man has learned how to kick! Was good today.

[Big Man]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Wirrpanda
2. R Jones
1. Glass.

[Big Man]

5. Kerr

Glass gets overlooked pretty regularly.

I thought he beat Barry Hall soundly tonight. Very important effort.

Agreed.

Beaten soundly in the 1st but bounced back like a AA should.

[Gunnar Longshanks]

3. Selwood - I thought he was crucial to our defensive setup.Do you reckon he was more crucial than the player who shut down the best forward on the ground?

[peterss]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Selwood
2. Wirrpanda
1. Brown

[Embers]

Do you reckon he was more crucial than the player who shut down the best forward on the ground?

As important. Glass can thank Selly for alot of help tonight. Normally Glass does it alone but not today. Selwood helped all of our key defenders out alot and his disposal was top notch all night. If were talking bout underrated Selwood is certainly up there

[West Coast 06]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Seaby
2. Rojo
1. Glass

[RhEF JC]

Do you reckon he was more crucial than the player who shut down the best forward on the ground?

what?
no one else wants this one?
ok, I'll say it-

"Mitch Brown didn't get shut down" (plus obligatory ":p")

[larrikin]

Do you reckon he was more crucial than the player who shut down the best forward on the ground?
Yes

5 - Judd
4 - Kerr
3 - Selwood
2 - Seaby
1 - R. Jones

[jorel6669]

5. Chris Judd
4. Daniel Kerr
3. Mark Seaby
2. Adam Selwood
1. Rowan Jones

[Dry Rot]

I was there, it surely is

5. Kerr
4. Kerr
3. Kerr
2. Kerr
1. Kerr

Absolute pleasure to have watched him live.

[Gunnar Longshanks]

Yes

5 - Judd
4 - Kerr
3 - Selwood
2 - Seaby
1 - R. JonesYeah - but we all know that you don't watch the games.

[Crissy_v]

5- Kerr
4- Judd
3- Wirrpanda
2- Seaby
1- Braun

[nearlyblonde]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Selwood
2. Seaby
1. Rowan Jones

[Bestbird]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Seaby
2. Wirra
1. R Jones

I'd say Woosha would be particularly happy with Seaby's game in light of Cox's late ommision.

[bassmanx]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Wirra
2. Seaby
1. Glass

Unfreakin' believable!
I was not at all confident with the players we had out.
The young lads stood up and made a serious name for them selves.
I is being one very proud West Coast supporter tonight.

And Freo lost...WOOT!!!!!!

[Blue and Gold Blood]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Seaby
2. Rojo
1. Glass
what i think in that order :thumbsu:

[F-U]

5. Daniel Kerr
4. Chris Judd
3. Rowan Jones
2. Adam Selwood
1. Dazza Glass

Special mention to Mitch Brown. Have we finall found a real CHF. It took us 20 years but we got there in the end :D

[bzparkes]

5.Kerr
4.Judd
3.Seaby
2.Rojo
1.Wirra

[daddy_4_eyes]

Do you reckon he was more crucial than the player who shut down the best forward on the ground?

Who do you think is the player who regularly blocked the hole in front of Hall?

Votes are based on opinion, you don't need to justify your votes by criticising others.

[Emerald]

5 - Daniel Kerr
4 - Chris Judd
3 - Mark Seaby
2 - Rowan Jones
1 - Darren Glass

[Gunnar Longshanks]

Who do you think is the player who regularly blocked the hole in front of Hall?

Votes are based on opinion, you don't need to justify your votes by criticising others.Is discussion against the rules?

People tend to overlook Glass because he doesn't get a lot of the ball.

Hall would have been fired up for last night. He would have been very focused on putting in a big one after the GF. But Glass beat him soundly and that was a major factor in us getting home.

Glass did his job as well as anyone in our team - moreso than RoJo and Wirrpanda. Don't be so dazzled by the stats sheet.

[BarcaRulz]

Is discussion against the rules?

People tend to overlook Glass because he doesn't get a lot of the ball.

Hall would have been fired up for last night. He would have been very focused on putting in a big one after the GF. But Glass beat him soundly and that was a major factor in us getting home.

Glass did his job as well as anyone in our team - moreso than RoJo and Wirrpanda. Don't be so dazzled by the stats sheet.

Thats your opinion, others have their own views on the game. Discuss it all you want, but you don't have to say it 9000 times to anyone who doesn't have a similar line up to your one.

[midorigreenwood]

1 point for this

FwIOJOTMWUc


That will teach you to monster our itty bitty panda!!!


5 - Daniel Kerr
4 - Chris Judd
3 - Wirrupanda
2 - Braun
1 - Selwood

[Gunnar Longshanks]

Thats your opinion, others have their own views on the game.And they're welcome to express those views.

That doesn't mean I can't disagree with them.

Discuss it all you want, but you don't have to say it 9000 times to anyone who doesn't have a similar line up to your one.I'm sorry - I didn't realise that you were the official censor.

How about I post what I want and you thank your lucky stars for having the opportunity to read it?

Deal?

[Gunnar Longshanks]

5 - Daniel Kerr
4 - Chris Judd
3 - Wirrupanda
2 - Braun
1 - SelwoodHow can you leave Seaby out? <Gunnar cut it out!!! People vote who they want to vote for, mind your own bloody business! - GB>

He rucked all night and kicked two goals - including the crucial one in the last term.

I'm all for people having their own opinion, but leaving Seaby out of your votes suggests you were watching a different game.

[BarcaRulz]

And they're welcome to express those views.

That doesn't mean I can't disagree with them.

I'm sorry - I didn't realise that you were the official censor.

How about I post what I want and you thank your lucky stars for having the opportunity to read it?

Deal?


Disagree all you want, but you don't have to parade it around after each post. Why quote ratings and tell them they missed out on people? In a way you are saying that your ratings are the only ones that are correct.

Everyone has a right to their own opinion without you poping up to disagree with them. What is it you wish to achieve with this anyway?

[Isandula]

That Video just made me laugh:D Well done Judd!:thumbsu:
Very good game, though there were quite a few mistakes but its only the 1st round.

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Seaby
2. Wirra
1. Braun/Selwood-couldnt split

Great first game from Brown, real impressed

[midorigreenwood]

How about I post what I want and you thank your lucky stars for having the opportunity to read it?


http://img154.imageshack.us/img154/5500/vlcsnap2429537mu6.jpg


Bow at my feet..... and I shall show you how merciful I am!!! :P

[midorigreenwood]

How can you leave Seaby out?

He rucked all night and kicked two goals - including the crucial one in the last term.

I'm all for people having their own opinion, but leaving Seaby out of your votes suggests you were watching a different game.

May well be true... I'll keep an eye on seaby when I watch the game again :3

[nibbles]

5 kerr
4 judd
3 wirra
2 seaby
1 braun

impressive were glass, rojo, staker, brown, selwood and lynch

geez, there were some very good performances last night, hard to split them - but i have to go with kerr for basically just busting his guts out and kicking some ass...

[Gunnar Longshanks]

Everyone has a right to their own opinion without you poping up to disagree with them. No - they don't.

They have a right to express their opinion, and I have an equal right to disagree.

No-one has the right to express a view with a guarantee that it won't be challenged.

If people can't handle their opinions being countered, then why post them in the first place?

[Belgarion]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Rowan Jones
2. Wirrpanda
1. Mitchel Brown

Belgarion

[94_Eagles]

5. Kerry
4. Juddy
3. Seaby
2. Jonesey
1. Glassy

[Stenglein's a Champ!]

Sorry, had to tape it and watch it today...

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Wirrpanda
2. Seaby
1. Glass

I thought Waters disposal by foot was brilliant. Big improvement, considering that was his major weakness for the majority of last season.

[nibbles]

who saw the look in beau's eyes when he was shaping up to hall? even as he was moving away, is eyes just stayed locked on hall and he didn't even blink

he looked bloody possessed - i thought he was about to eat him like a goldfish...

love his work

[EagleMan87]

who saw the look in beau's eyes when he was shaping up to hall? even as he was moving away, is eyes just stayed locked on hall and he didn't even blink

he looked bloody possessed - i thought he was about to eat him like a goldfish...

love his work

True that, he had that 'I don't give a **** how tough you are, I'll smash ya' look in his eyes. Wouldn't wanna piss him off in a nightclub.:D

[daddy_4_eyes]

True that, he had that 'I don't give a **** how tough you are, I'll smash ya' look in his eyes. Wouldn't wanna piss him off in a nightclub.:D

I thought he had the "oh crap I picked a fight with the wrong guy" look.
You know the type, he tries to look strong and tough on the outside, but on the inside he's hoping a teammate stands by his side.

[wce4premiership]

5. kerr
4. judd
3. seaby
2. wirra
1. selwood

[larrikin]

Yeah - but we all know that you don't watch the games.
That's interesting coming from the bloke who lives in Sydney but couldn't make it to the game

[EagleMan87]

I thought he had the "oh crap I picked a fight with the wrong guy" look.
You know the type, he tries to look strong and tough on the outside, but on the inside he's hoping a teammate stands by his side.

We're talking about Beau Waters here, right? :confused:

He's tough, doesn't need anyone standing next to him.

[Special Agent]

I don't think he was our third most important player.

And I certainly don't think that Seaby, who rucked all night and kicked two goals, should be left out of the votes completely.

I'm not sure why you always seem to get your knickers in a twist about everyone elses votes, but it sure is entertaining to read.

[FiveStrings]

5: Kerr
4: Judd
3: Seaby
2: Glass
1: RoJo (could have been any of a number of players, but I don't often get the chance to give Rowan a vote)

Sorry to Lynch, Wirra, Selwood, Braun and especially Mitch Brown who looked awesome on debut. I look forward to the rest of his career in the blue and gold.

[FiveStrings]

I'll just check my votes against the official marking guide:

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Seaby
2. Glass
1. Selwood

Glass gets overlooked pretty regularly.

I thought he beat Barry Hall soundly tonight. Very important effort.

Hmm, 4 out of 5. I don't know whether to be relieved or disturbed.

[Goldenblue]

5 - Judd
4 - Kerr
3 - Selwood
2 - Seaby
1 - Brown

<Gunnar treat this as a warning, you start your crap on about how others vote, I will give you a holiday for 2 weeks. Just stop antagonizing everyone because you think you have impeccable knowledge on the Eagles - Goldenblue>

[Keyser Soze]

5 - Kerr
4 - Judd
3 - Selwood
2 - Staker
1 - Glass

Apologies to Seaby, Lynch, Wirra and Rojo - I thought Judd and Kerr were the standouts with the next half dozen or so very even and hard to split.

[*Mystique*]

Can I play as well? If so my votes are:

5 - Judd
4 - Kerr
3 - Glass
2 - Wirra
1 - RoJo

[heals]

That's interesting coming from the bloke who lives in Sydney but couldn't make it to the game



<Gunnar treat this as a warning, you start your crap on about how others vote, I will give you a holiday for 2 weeks. Just stop antagonizing everyone because you think you have impeccable knowledge on the Eagles - Goldenblue>

OHHH SNAP :D :thumbsu:

[shmule]

5. Kerr
4.Judd
3. Seaby
2. Wirra
1. Selwood/ Rojo can't decide

[94_Eagles]

Gunnar got in trouble..

[Frizzo]

Thanks GoldenBlue.

[eaglerock]

1:kerr
2:judd
3:seaby
4:staker
5:wirrpanda

[Milkman]

Oops, forgot to vote.

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Wirra (despite a couple of uncharacteristic mistakes)
2. Seaby
1. Selwood

[Big Man]

Oops, forgot to vote.

It happens when you sleep once in a week. ;)

3. Wirra (despite a couple of uncharacteristic mistakes)


Those 2 early OOF's? I was quivering thinking "OH NO" hes gonna have a shocker.

He came real good though. :thumbsu:

[Milkman]

It happens when you sleep once in a week. ;)


Nah, can't really blame that until my crack runs out. ;)


Those 2 early OOF's? I was quivering thinking "OH NO" hes gonna have a shocker.

He came real good though. :thumbsu:

Yeah well, when arguably the best kick in the side is spraying them all over the place, it doesn't fill one with confidence. How was his brilliant trademark one handed pickup though?

[Big Man]

Yeah well, when arguably the best kick in the side is spraying them all over the place, it doesn't fill one with confidence. How was his brilliant trademark one handed pickup though?

Absolutley wonderful!!

Awesome player with a million cleaning up nicknames such as; The Janitor, The Vacuum, The Human Mop, David Domestos nah that was crap :o and Wirra which I am sure is a name-brand broom in Japan pronounced The "Rirra" Broom.

Cant wait for Sat Night. :thumbsu:

[Milkman]

Absolutley wonderful!!

Awesome player with a million cleaning up nicknames such as; The Janitor, The Vacuum, The Human Mop, David Domestos nah that was crap :o and Wirra which I am sure is a name-brand broom in Japan pronounced The "Rirra" Broom.

Cant wait for Sat Night. :thumbsu:

:D :thumbsu:

Bring it on.

[wce_all_da_way]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Seaby
2. Wirra
1. RoJo

[sdb4884]

Kerr
Judd
Wirrapunda
Seaby
Rowan Jones

Honorable mentions to all, especially Mitch Brown.

[jod23]

5 - D.Kerr
4 - C.Judd
3 - M.Seaby
2 - R.Jones
1 - D.Wirrpanda

[Goldenblue]

Jod, Please remove Gunnar's votes from the list - Cheers GB.

[Cuzz09]

5: D.Kerr
4: C.Judd
3: D.Wirrpanda
2: M.Seaby
1: B.Staker

[Ricky Bobby]

First time on the Eagles board. Bit nervous. lol. West Coast fan living in Melbourne. My votes are as such
5. Kerr: 2nd best midfielder in the comp without cuz playing. Huge game.
4. Judd: Standard game for him exceptional if anyone else had done it. Did anyone see him shrug off Mcveigh? Phenomanal
3. Wirra: Doesnt get the rating of a gilbee in melbourne as a clean up defender but just as good
4. Seaby: Huge effort without Cox. Best game i have seen him play.
5. Lynch: The way he pushed and led up the ground was really impressive. Thats what seperates him from the likes of reiwoldt, brown pavlich. If he can keep doing that al year while kicking his 2-4 goals a game he will cause opposition coaches alot of headaches.
Like everyone else has said apologies to rojo, selwood, braun, brown. Go the mighty eagles!!!!!!!!!!!!

[Goldenblue]

First time on the Eagles board. Bit nervous. lol. West Coast fan living in Melbourne. My votes are as such
5. Kerr: 2nd best midfielder in the comp without cuz playing. Huge game.
4. Judd: Standard game for him exceptional if anyone else had done it. Did anyone see him shrug off Mcveigh? Phenomanal
3. Wirra: Doesnt get the rating of a gilbee in melbourne as a clean up defender but just as good
4. Seaby: Huge effort without Cox. Best game i have seen him play.
5. Lynch: The way he pushed and led up the ground was really impressive. Thats what seperates him from the likes of reiwoldt, brown pavlich. If he can keep doing that al year while kicking his 2-4 goals a game he will cause opposition coaches alot of headaches.
Like everyone else has said apologies to rojo, selwood, braun, brown. Go the mighty eagles!!!!!!!!!!!!

Welcome to the board, no need to be nervous, just feel right at home. :thumbsu:

[Frizzo]

First time on the Eagles board. Bit nervous. lol. West Coast fan living in Melbourne. My votes are as such
5. Kerr: 2nd best midfielder in the comp without cuz playing. Huge game.
4. Judd: Standard game for him exceptional if anyone else had done it. Did anyone see him shrug off Mcveigh? Phenomanal
3. Wirra: Doesnt get the rating of a gilbee in melbourne as a clean up defender but just as good
4. Seaby: Huge effort without Cox. Best game i have seen him play.
5. Lynch: The way he pushed and led up the ground was really impressive. Thats what seperates him from the likes of reiwoldt, brown pavlich. If he can keep doing that al year while kicking his 2-4 goals a game he will cause opposition coaches alot of headaches.
Like everyone else has said apologies to rojo, selwood, braun, brown. Go the mighty eagles!!!!!!!!!!!!

You should be nervous! According the the Official Marking Guide...

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Seaby
2. Glass
1. Selwood

...you only got 3 out of 5.

Oh, the shame!

[Mr Eagle]

You know guys and girls, the CLASSY thing to do would be to leave the Gunnar issue where it is and get on with the voting...

[EagleMan87]

You know guys and girls, the CLASSY thing to do would be to leave the Gunnar issue where it is and get on with the voting...

But you know we're not classy, we're evil...Mwuhahahaha!

[Keyser Soze]

Probably a dumb question, but I'm still relatively new here so cut us some slack.:o

Does anyone count up the votes each round and total them up at the end of the year?

If not I'm happy to volunteer to do so or help whoever does.

[EagleMan87]

Probably a dumb question, but I'm still relatively new here so cut us some slack.:o

Does anyone count up the votes each round and total them up at the end of the year?

If not I'm happy to volunteer to do so or help whoever does.

No human does it. We have DeepBlue do all the calculating. So far Rook 13A to 16A has won it..."Maybe someday you'll learn that not everything can be solved by chess, DeepBlue"

[Frizzo]

"Maybe someday you'll learn that not everything can be solved by chess, DeepBlue"

Haaaahahaha!!

Classic line.

[pauljam]

Sorry, a bit late :-)

5 - D.Kerr
4 - C.Judd
3 - M.Seaby
2 - R.Jones
1 - D.Wirrpanda

Classic game from the mighty Evils!!!

[Mr Eagle]

Probably a dumb question, but I'm still relatively new here so cut us some slack.:o

Does anyone count up the votes each round and total them up at the end of the year?

If not I'm happy to volunteer to do so or help whoever does.

In the past, Jod23 has been keeper of the BFWCPOTY tallies...Jod, would you care to chime in at this point?

[EDIT: see also http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=310132]

[hawkeye23]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Wirrpanda
2. Seaby
1. Glass

[Magnum27]

5.Kerr
4.Judd
3.Wirrapanda
2.Glass
1.Brown

[Sharpy]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Wirra
2. Seaby
1. Rojo

[beatlesmith]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Wirrapanda
4. Seaby
5. Brown

[The Made Guy]

Sorry about the lateness of these votes, but I've been overseas.

5. D Kerr
4. C Judd
3. M Seaby
2. D Wirrpanda
1. A Selwood