Vote for Rnd 2 vs Collingwood.

[Biggie]

5. D.Kerr (Nothing much to say really other than FAR OUT HE IS GOOD!)
4. M.Braun ( Really stood up in the 4th so underated by all)
3. C.Judd ( Another fantastic game victim of his own high standards)
2. B.Waters ( this boy is tracking along very nicely, AWESOME mark)
1. D.Wirrapanda (would've been higher if not for the 3 goals against, AWESOME goal)

Great effort,guys must lift another notch to beat Freo next week.

[Lynch takes a mark]

5. D.Kerr
4. C.Judd
3. M.Braun
2. B.Waters
1. Stenglein

[BarcaRulz]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Braun
2. Waters
1. Wirrapanda

Alot of players are unlucky to miss out, great game by the whole team i thought.

[Stenglein's a Champ!]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Braun
2. Bones
1. RoJo

[wce4premiership]

5. kerr
4. judd
3. braun
2. waters
1. stenglien


sorry wirra

[Frizzo]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Waters
2. B. Jones
1. R. Jones

[A Living God]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Bruan
4. Waters
1. Seaby

[EasternHills]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. B. Jones
2. Bruan
1. stenglien

[West Coast 06]

5. Braun
4. Judd
3. Kerr
2. Bones
1. Wirra

Glass, Chick, Staker, Stenglein and Rosa unlucky.

[nibbles]

5. kerr
4. judd
3. braun
2. stenglein
1. waters

sorry bones, wirra, glass and rojo

[Big Cox]

5. Chris Judd - Class as always with alot of attention too. 2 crucial goals
4. Daniel Kerr - Good but disposal was iffy at times
3. Michael Braun - Top game
2. Tyson Stenglein - 27 possessions for a tagger is handy
1. Matt Priddis/Rosa - too hard to split them both

[midorigreenwood]

Chris Judd - efficient disposal as usual.... he seemed to be gliding...nothing fazed him.... too bad he didn't get the goal after that steal....

Daniel Kerr - was a ball hog...but he was often under pressure by the opposition which reduced the effectiveness of his disposals... had a great last quarter though.

Rowan Jones - One of his best games ever imo.... a magnet to the ball...some of his disposals was wobbly but overall very effective.... he seems to have a confidence problem though...... two or three times he could have kicked it but instead decided to pass it off. His one percent-ers were phenomenal.

David Wirrapanda - what can you say.... goal of the year? awesome start to the first quarter....but the person who decided that he should man up on leon davis again should get a kick in the arse.... overall his good balanced up with that disasterous period of play.

Mark Seaby - haven't seen any stats ....but I thought he was kicking Josh Fraser and co's arse before he got taken off (was it an injury?). Took several strong contested marks too.

[Jabso]

I thought the rucks were break even tbh.

Seaby - 3K 10HB = 13D. 4M. 5T. 24 HO
Graham - 9K 6HB = 15D. 8M. 1T. 2 HO (played mostly out of the ruck though)

Fraser (disapointing) - 9K 0 HB = 9D. 3M. 0T. 19HO
Richards (ok considering his recent standards) - 7K 4HB = 11D. 2M. 0T. 22HO.

[doppleganger]

Outsiders view

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. B.Jones
2. Stenglein
1. Braun

Kerr and Judd the difference, the umps certainly love those two!

Wirrpanda let L.Davis kick another 3 so wouldn't put him in any votes

Seaby was close to being beaten by Richards, and Richards is a hack, so no votes for Seaby

Waters & Priddis stiff to miss out

[midorigreenwood]

It was all in my head then :3

gah.... didn't set the aerial properly .... my recorded copy of the game is all damaged up :/

Can you download afl games without joining aussietorrents?

*goes search in mininova....*

edit: nvm ...the sydney eagles game is on there.... hopefully someone will put the collingwood one too >,>

[kilaw]

1. Kerr - Had a fantastic game, worked really hard
2. Judd - Lazy 29 disposals and two crucial goals
3. Waters
4. B.jones - did very well in the backline, very impressed
5. Stinga

[peterss]

Based on how i saw it at the game not on the stats

5. David Wirrpanda
4. Adam Selwood
3. Rowan Jones
2. Beau Waters
1. Micheal Braun

[nibbles]

David Wirrapanda - the person who decided that he should man up on leon davis again should get a kick in the arse....

agreed

maybe the rotational resting of players caused it, but that mismatch is a killer every time for us - even my brother goes 'watch davis kick 2 goals straight away on wirra' - and he pretty much did

you could even see wirra's face - he wasn't happy with that match up at all...

i thought chick did a good job on davis though

[TheBigUnit]

5 - Kerr
4 - Judd
3 - Rowan Jones
2 - Priddis
1 - Brett Jones

[Ruddiger]

5. Judd
4. B.Jones
3. Braun
2. Kerr
1. Wirra

Mitch Brown was good too.

[Special Agent]

5. Kerr
4. Braun
3. Waters
2. Judd
1. B. Jones

[Embers]

5. Daniel Kerr
4. Chris Judd
3. Michael Braun
2. Beau Waters
1. Tyson Stenglein

Honorable mention to Matt Rosa for THAT last quarter

[Fletchers Girl]

5 - Kerr
4 - Judd
3 - Waters
2 - Wirra
1 - Stinger

[WeSt CoAsT EaGLeS]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. B.Jones
2. Wirrpunda
1. R.Jones

[Embers]

Cant believe so many are giving Wirra votes. That 2nd qtr was awful. Worst qtr ive seen from him in ever pretty much

[Creo]

5. Kerr
4. RoJo
3. Braun
2. Judd
1. Wirra

[Lion El'Johnson]

1. Kerr
2. Braun
3. Judd
4. Wirrpunda
5. Brett Jones

[EagleMan87]

1. Kerr
2. Bones
3. Judd
4. Rojo
5. Wirra

Let me edit this mistake...

1. Kerr
2. Judd
3. Bones
4. Waters
5. Priddis

Unlucky:

Armstrong, Rosa, Braun, Seaby, Selwood

[Cuzz09]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. B.Jones
2. Waters
1. Braun

[hawkeye23]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Bones
2. Waters
1. Braun

[Bestbird]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Stinger
2. Waters
1. Braun

Thought Priddis and Graham had much improved games compared to last week which is a good sign

[EagleMan87]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Stinger
2. Waters
1. Braun

Thought Priddis and Graham had much improved games compared to last week which is a good sign

Unlucky; Bones, Selwood, Seaby, Rojo, Rosa

Definatley, especially Priddi's game, 10 tackles! Would get the rising star this week if he could.:thumbsu:

[nearlyblonde]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Braun
2. Stenglein
1. B. Jones

[Stereophonic]

5- Kerr
4- Judd
3- RoJo
2- Stenglein
1-Braun/Bones

Honerable Mentions:

Beau Waters, M Priddis, Wirpanda (if not only for that goal of the year). :thumbsu:

[*Mystique*]

5 - Kerr4 - Judd3 - Stenglein2 - Braun1 - B.Jones

[jod23]

5 - D.Kerr
4 - C.Judd
3 - T.Stenglein
2 - R.Jones
1 - B.Jones

Unlucky for Braun, Wirra and Waters who were all very good.

[eaglerock]

5.kerr
4.judd
3.waters
2.stinger
1.braun

[Milkman]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Braun
2. Stenglein
1. B. Jones

[no1bankteller]

51. Matt Priddis

I thought he was our best young player on the day and in our top 5.

[Keyser Soze]

5 - Kerr
4 - Judd
3 - Stenglein
2 - B Jones
1 - Braun

[Emerald]

5 - Daniel Kerr (Deserved 10)
4 - Chris Judd
3 - Beau Waters
2 - Michael Braun
1 - Brett Jones

Unlucky: David Wirrpanda, Matt Priddis, Matt Rosa and Tyson Stenglien

[jorel6669]

5. Daniel Kerr
4. Brett Jones
3. Rowan Jones
2. Chris Judd
1. David Wirrpanda

[Crissy_v]

5- Kerr
4- B.Jones
3- Judd
2- Waters
1- Braun

[jorel6669]

Cant believe so many are giving Wirra votes. That 2nd qtr was awful. Worst qtr ive seen from him in ever pretty much

More for his forward display, I would have thought. Looked really dangerous when the ball came near him.

Does anyone think his down back days could/should be over? He could be far more valuable to us as a permanent forward pocket, as we have Selwood, Bones, Waters, Chick to cover the back flanks/pockets. Sure, the Pund will always be good as a spare man, but opposition coaches know to man him up and nullify that.

[FiveStrings]

5: Kerr
4: Judd
3: Braun
2: Bones
1: Priddis

[Bestbird]

More for his forward display, I would have thought. Looked really dangerous when the ball came near him.

Does anyone think his down back days could/should be over? He could be far more valuable to us as a permanent forward pocket, as we have Selwood, Bones, Waters, Chick to cover the back flanks/pockets. Sure, the Pund will always be good as a spare man, but opposition coaches know to man him up and nullify that.

Can't see the selectors playing Wirra as a permanent forward and nor should they.

Would rather see someone like Mckinley, Morton or LeCras develop into the role as a long term replacement for P Matera.



That or Sampi getting into some kind of decent form

[Sharpy]

Kerr
Judd
Stinga
Waters
Braun

[daddy_4_eyes]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. B.Jones
2. Braun
1. R.Jones

[eagleskickass]

5 - Kerr
4 - Judd
3 - Braun
2 - Priddis
1 - Seaby

[3Judd3]

5. Kerr

4. Braun

3. Judd

2. B. Jones

1. Wirra

[The_Eagles]

Kerr
Judd
Stenglein
B Jones
R Jones

[bassmanx]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Braun
2. Wirra
1. Stenglein

[Magnum27]

5.Kerr
4.Judd
3.B.Jones
2.Stenglein
1.Braun

[larrikin]

5 - Kerr
4 - Judd
3 - B. Jones
2 - Waters
1 - Stenglein

[Isandula]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Waters
2. Stenglein
1. Braun

[Goldenblue]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Braun
2. Stinger
1. Wirrpunda

[Belgarion]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Wirrpanda (including his "goal of the year" candidate)
2. Braun
1. Waters

Belgarion

[heals]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Braun
2. Wirrapanda
1. Stenglien

So wanted to give mitch brown a vote, for the reason of him being mitch brown:D .

[Lynch takes a mark]

after watching the replay today I have decided to revise my votes

5. Judd - Much more effective than Kerr. Huge hurt factor with his kicking and was awesome in the packs.
4. Kerr - big stats but most were very cheap and didn't hurt the opposition as much as the other 4.
3. Seaby - very very good performance in the ruck, some great work around the ground too.
2. Brett Jones - very very good game off the back line, Disposal into the forward 50 was very damaging. caught spectating a couple of times that resulted in goals though.
1. Braun - 3rd best midfielder easy

honourable mentions (very close to getting votes)

Waters - good off half back but not enough impact overall.
Stenglein - strong in the packs but butchered the ball on too many occasions
Chick - absolute superb defensive game.

[wce_all_da_way]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Stenglein
2. Brett Jones
1. Waters

[pauljam]

5 - Kerr
4 - Judd
3 - BJones
2 - Braun
1 - Stinga

[MoFF]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Wirrpanda
2. Braun
1. Waters

[94_Eagles]

5. Kerr
4. Wirrpanda
3. Judd
2. Selwood
1. Braun

[beatlesmith]

5. Kerr
4. Judd
3. Wirrapanda
2. Braun
1. Stenglein

[VanBerlo=God]

5. D.Kerr (Nothing much to say really other than FAR OUT HE IS GOOD!)
4. M.Braun ( Really stood up in the 4th so underated by all)
3. C.Judd ( Another fantastic game victim of his own high standards)
2. B.Waters ( this boy is tracking along very nicely, AWESOME mark)
1. D.Wirrapanda (would've been higher if not for the 3 goals against, AWESOME goal)

Great effort,guys must lift another notch to beat Freo next week.
copy the Sydney BF B&F why don't you :rolleyes: :p

[midorigreenwood]

copy the Sydney BF B&F why don't you :rolleyes: :p

You're delusional

its the BFWCPOTY07 (http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=313650)

one of the mods had to climb Wireless Hill ala Moses and Mt Sinai in the bible to consult with the great man himself... "he who shall not be named but is dating that hot chick who does the weather on channel 7 on the weekends"

The great man shook his head at the indiscriminate arguing the eaglets were having about who were the greatest of them all and set the rules on their energies could be used more effectively.

Hence the Three Commandments etched onto a tablet to signify the words of he who must not be named.

The Sydney B & F was devised by a smelly teenager who still lives with his mother.... nothing alike to ours :/

[bzparkes]

5. Chris Judd - Class as always with alot of attention too. 2 crucial goals
4. Daniel Kerr - Good but disposal was iffy at times
3. Michael Braun - Top game
2. Tyson Stenglein - 27 possessions for a tagger is handy
1. Matt Priddis/Rosa - too hard to split them both


Ditto for me, especially on the Kerr point. Selwood unlucky to miss out but didn't really notice him in the 4th very much.

[Biggie]

copy the Sydney BF B&F why don't you :rolleyes: :p

:confused:

OK.........

[The Made Guy]

Here are my considered votes for the R2 game.

5. D Kerr
4. C Judd
3. M Braun
2. B Jones
1. R Jones

[daddy_4_eyes]

You're delusional

its the BFWCPOTY07 (http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=313650)

one of the mods had to climb Wireless Hill ala Moses and Mt Sinai in the bible to consult with the great man himself... "he who shall not be named but is dating that hot chick who does the weather on channel 7 on the weekends"

The great man shook his head at the indiscriminate arguing the eaglets were having about who were the greatest of them all and set the rules on their energies could be used more effectively.

Hence the Three Commandments etched onto a tablet to signify the words of he who must not be named.

The Sydney B & F was devised by a smelly teenager who still lives with his mother.... nothing alike to ours :/

:D :thumbsu:


BFWCPOTY has been running for the past 5-odd years. Lots of history associated with this great award.

[lyall]

Thought I'd put these in. Going by memory
5 - Kerr
4 - Judd
3 - Wirra
2 - Stinger
1 - B. Jones