Votes for Round 3: the Derby [Archive] - Australian Rules Football Forum

Big Man

14 Apr 2007, 22:14

5. T.Stenglein (Wonderful disposal shut his opponent out my BOG) *Entered before announcment......
4. M.Braun ( So underrated great player)
3. B.Staker (best game Ive seen Brent play)
2. D.Glass (Shut Pav down)
1. Bones (awesome run off HB)

*and the winner is.......Brauny. Well deserved I couldnt split him and Stenga :thumbsu:

Army was very good tonight, RoJo is my hero ATM and Kerr and Judd did the hard things tonight.

Wonderful effort lads.

Stenglein's a Champ!

14 Apr 2007, 22:18

Have to agree with you there BM.

5. T.Stenglien
4. M.Braun
3. B.Staker
2. D.Glass
1. Bones

Evil-Eagle

14 Apr 2007, 22:20

5. Tyson Stenglein
4. Michael Braun
3. Daniel Kerr
2. Brent Staker
1. Steven Armstrong

A Living God

14 Apr 2007, 22:21

Too many good players:
Hunter, Glass, Judd, Kerr, Braun, Armstrong, R Jones, B Jones, Staker, Stenglin, Hurn, Rosa, Priddis, Hurn

1 vote each.

5. Glass (good 3 quarters not much in the last but not his fault)
4. Armstrong
3. Hunter (good 3 quarters not much in the last but not his fault)
2. Stenglin
1. Braun

sTeeL

14 Apr 2007, 22:22

Where to start.... B. Jones, Armstrong, Priddis, Stenglien, Embley, Braun, Staker and Hurn all had brilliant games.

5. T.Stenglien
4. M.Braun
3. B. Jones
2. Embley
1. Armstrong

So many good players though

Lion El'Johnson

14 Apr 2007, 22:22

5. Stenglein
4. Staker (essentially for the brilliant first half)
3. Braun
2. Armstrong
1. Kerr

Ruddiger

14 Apr 2007, 22:24

5. Stenglein
4. Kerr
3. Staker
2. Glass
1. Braun

Hunter, Army...hard to find a bad player

heals

14 Apr 2007, 22:25

This would have to be the hardest game ive voted on so many great players today.

5- Stenglien
4- Braun
3- Armstrong
2- Glass
1- Kerr (for the 12 or so contested touches)

Great game by all and so many unlucky.

Kempie

14 Apr 2007, 22:26

5. Brent Staker (When it mattered)
4. D. Glass (ditto)
3. Tyson Stenglein (good all night)
2. Steven Armstrong. (just great FP play)
1. Rowan Jones (hey, he can kick !)

Michael Braun (good, but a bit rude :) )

Belgarion

14 Apr 2007, 22:29

5. Braun
4. Kerr
3. Rowan Jones
2. Armstrong
1. Glass

Belgarion

midorigreenwood

14 Apr 2007, 22:30

5 Steven Armstrong
4 Brent Staker
3 Michael Braun
2 Chris Judd
1 Andrew Embley

Lynch takes a mark

14 Apr 2007, 22:32

really hard to give votes in this game

5 - Braun
4 - Judd
3 - Glass
2 - Brett Jones
1 - Armstrong

Staker, Kerr, Rowan Jones, Hunter ect were all awesome too

bassmanx

14 Apr 2007, 22:38

5. Braun (****en oath)
4. Stenglein
3. Judd
2. Armstrong
1. Wirra

TheBigUnit

14 Apr 2007, 22:45

Very hard to give votes, but I'll have a go...

5 - T Stenglein (Great all game
4 - B Staker (Terrific 1st half, I like the new role he's been given)
3 - B Jones (This guy's a gun, I love his rebound and run work through traffic)
2 - S Armstrong (he's a handy little FP, some nice snaps)
1 - M Braun (Another solid game from Brauny, but I just didn't think he was a real standout best, maybe I'm under rating him)

Quite a few unluckies...

wce_all_da_way

14 Apr 2007, 22:47

5. Stenglein
4. Braun
3. Staker (Was brilliant today)
2. Bones
1. Armstrong

worsfold

14 Apr 2007, 22:59

5. Stenglein
4. Braun
3. Judd
2. Kerr
1. Selwood - (just cause he got up the nose of headland)

Special Agent

14 Apr 2007, 23:06

5. Braun
4. Stenglien
3. Glass
2. Armstrong
1. Staker

EagleMan87

14 Apr 2007, 23:07

1. Armstrong by a f*cking mile, 3 goals, 18 possies
2. Stenglein, awesome thoughout
3. Braun, great, and the swearing only adds to it:D
4. Glass, played well in defence and kept us in it for a while
5. Bones: Nicoski Mk II this bloke is. Not as damaging, but I like him:thumbsu:

eagleskickass

14 Apr 2007, 23:09

5 - Stinga
4 - Armstrong
3 - Glass
2 - Hunter
1 - Braun

West Coast 06

14 Apr 2007, 23:25

Hard to slit the top three spots, but I'll go with:

5. Stenglein
4. Armstrong
3. Glass
2. Bones
1. Hunter

Cant believe I didn't give the Rosco medalist a vote, but I honestly did not see that one coming!:eek:

jorel6669

15 Apr 2007, 00:04

5. Steven Armstrong
4. Michael Braun
3. Rowan Jones
2. Brett Jones
1. Darren Glass

Sorry Stinger!

Frizzo

15 Apr 2007, 00:10

5. Tyson Stenglein
4. Steven Armstrong
3. Darren Glass
2. Brent Staker
1. Michael Braun

Sorry RoJo!!! You were awesome, AGAIN!

peterss

15 Apr 2007, 00:30

5. RoJo
4. Braun
3. Armstrong
2. Stinger
1. Hunter

Emerald

15 Apr 2007, 00:57

5 - Michael Braun
4 - Tyson Stenglein
3 - Steven Armstrong
2 - Darren Glass
1 - Matt Rosa

The Made Guy

15 Apr 2007, 01:08

Tough game to give votes. But I thought our defence was superb tonight, so my votes are biased towards the backmen on this occasion.

5. A Hunter
4. D Glass
3. T Stenglein
2. M Braun
1. S Armstrong

MAG87

15 Apr 2007, 01:13

5. Michael Braun (bloody awesome no doubt about it)
4. Darren Glass (shutting down Pavlich)
3. Tyson Stenglein (simply superb)
2. Chris Judd
1. Daniel Kerr

Embers

15 Apr 2007, 02:30

5. Tyson Stenglein
4. Michael Braun
3. Brent Staker
2. Adam Hunter
1. Steve Armstrong

nibbles

15 Apr 2007, 03:08

definitely tough to give out votes for this one - so many equal contributors, but all at different times and in different ways, but for me its:

5 stenglein
4 glass
3 staker
2 armstrong
1 bones

can't wait to watch it again tomorrow :thumbsu:

BarcaRulz

15 Apr 2007, 04:03

5. Stenglein
4. Braun
3. Glass
2. Armstrong
1. Hunter

Magnum27

15 Apr 2007, 08:53

5.T.Steinglein
4.D.Glass
3.D.Kerr
2.M.Braun
1.A.Hunter

Sharpy

15 Apr 2007, 10:58

5. Armstrong
4. Braun
3. Glass
2. Rojo
1. Steinglein

eaglerock

15 Apr 2007, 11:27

5.stinger
4.brett jones
3.armstrong
2.staker
1.braun

Keyser Soze

15 Apr 2007, 11:54

5 Stenglein
4 Braun
3 Rojo
2 B Jones
1 Staker

If anyone else had games like Judd and Kerr I probably would have given them votes but they set the bar high for themselves.

Apologies also to Glass, Hunter, Armstrong and Waters

Goldenblue

15 Apr 2007, 13:36

5 Braun
4 Stenglein
3 Glass
2 Armstrong
1 Staker

lyall

15 Apr 2007, 13:48

5 - Braun
4 - Glass
3 - Stenglein
2 - Bones
1 - Staker

The Made Guy

15 Apr 2007, 14:10

I dont think my votes have ever been so different from the consensus!

larrikin

15 Apr 2007, 14:23

5 - Stenglein
4 - Braun
3 - Glass
2 - Armstrong
1 - Bones

Isandula

15 Apr 2007, 14:58

5. Stenglein
4. Braun
3. Armstrong
2. Staker
1. Glass

nearlyblonde

15 Apr 2007, 16:11

5. Stenglein
4. Glass
3. Bones
2. Armstrong
1. Braun

Bestbird

15 Apr 2007, 16:17

It would be easier to give 15 players 1 vote each as it was pretty even performance which i'm sure Woosha would be delighted with.

Sorry Judd, Kerr and Armers

5. Hunter - Completely shut Tarrant out of the game and picked up a lazy 25 possies
4. Stinger - Played on the important Dockers midfielders and beat them
3. Glass - Got some help but beat Pav on many of the 50/50 contests
2. Staker - Taking to the tall utility role like a duck to water.
1. Braun Top game and great to see him get some accolades

F-U

15 Apr 2007, 16:20

5. Tyson Stenglein
4. Adam Hunter
3. Rowan "I kicked a goal all by myself with no help from Judd" Jones
2. Brent Staker
1. Michael Braun

wce4premiership

15 Apr 2007, 18:54

5.Braun
4.Stinga
3.Glass
2.Armstrong
1.bones

daddy_4_eyes

15 Apr 2007, 19:10

5.Stenglein
4.Glass
3.Braun
2.RJones
1.Armstrong

94_Eagles

15 Apr 2007, 19:19

5. Stingery
4. Brauny
3. Glassy
2. Armstrongy
1. Bonesy

Fletchers Girl

15 Apr 2007, 21:58

5 - Stinger
4 - Braun
3 - Glass
2 - Kerr
1 - Armstrong

EagleMan87

15 Apr 2007, 22:07

5. Stingery
4. Brauny
3. Glassy
2. Armstrongy
1. Bonesy

Classy!

:D :thumbsu:

jod23

15 Apr 2007, 23:28

5 - Stenglein
4 - Braun
3 - Glass
2 - R.Jones
1 - B.Jones

Unlucky for Army, Staker and Hunts who were all pretty good.

FiveStrings

16 Apr 2007, 10:02

Hope I'm not treading on anyone's toes in creating this thread...

5: Braun (the medal could have gone to a few people, but Brauny had as good a game as any and made a great acceptance speech)
4: Kerr (excellent first half when the game was in the balance)
3: Stenglein
2: Armstrong
1: Glass

Tough one this round. Apologies to Hunter, Juddy and both the Joneses plus whoever else I've forgotten.

Genesis67

16 Apr 2007, 11:56

5 - Stenglein (Should've got the RGM)
4 - Staker
3 - Brauny
2 - Army
1 - Glass

sdb4884

16 Apr 2007, 12:41

5:Glass: Outstanding match on Pavlich, should've been medalled.
4:Braun: Set us up, let himself down a bit with his speech
3:Kerr: Fantastic first half, solid second
2:Staker: Great game, Played superb as a loose Key Back
1:Judd: Clearance King, Loved the way he took on those two Dockers, good game.

I'm Sorry KS

16 Apr 2007, 15:03

5: Stenglein
4: Braun
3: Glass
2: Kerr
1: Armstrong

The_Eagles

16 Apr 2007, 15:41

Braun
Stenglein
Glass
Armstrong
Hunter

hawkeye23

16 Apr 2007, 20:31

5. Braun - known in our house as Golden Boy
4. Glass
3. Stenglein
2. Kerr
1. Staker

*Mystique*

17 Apr 2007, 12:30

5. Braun
4. Stenglein
3. Kerr
2. Glass
1. Armstrong

The Made Guy

18 Apr 2007, 01:54

As an aside, it was interesting to see Worsfold/Connolly's votes for this game.

They voted the top 4 Eagles players as Hunter, Glass, Braun and Kerr (in that order).