View Full Version : Matthew Leuenberger vs Tomahawk
black_hart
18 Apr 2007, 21:01
Ok so Tomahawk comfortably beat out Gibbs so now for the ultimate best of 2006 draft poll!
Leuenberger vs Hawkins
Who will be the best?
To be fair, Leunberger hasn't played yet so a bit hard to tell. And whilst Hawkins has had a great start to his career, that doesn't mean he WILL have a great career. Atm, Hawkins for mine though
Stuck21
18 Apr 2007, 21:15
havn't seen leungberger play yet so it wouldn't be fair to make a comparison yet. Hawkins does look very promising from what i have seen though
Ok so Tomahawk comfortably beat out Gibbs so now for the ultimate best of 2006 draft poll!
Leuenberger vs Hawkins
Who will be the best?
BTW how is Leuenberger progressing? I haven't heard much about him. :)
dales.girl38
18 Apr 2007, 22:06
They're both in my SC team, and seeing as Leuenberger has done nothing (only an emergency, but that's not the point...) I'm saying Hawkins, as he has at least debuted.
Grimreepah
18 Apr 2007, 22:20
If Leuey plays a few games and is as promising as Tom Hawkins I will be very happy.
gormanisahack
18 Apr 2007, 22:37
hard to judge when havent seen much of Luenberger in the AFL. How good does everyone think Tomahwak can be? People liken him to Plugger. I cant help but think he is more like the modern CHF in a Barry Hall or Jonathon Brown. Not saying hes nearly as good as them just has the physique and moves like them.
TheGeneral
18 Apr 2007, 23:03
What a stupid poll!
Mitch Clarke v Hawkins would be a fairer comparison.
Drummond
18 Apr 2007, 23:32
Worst poll ever?
black_hart
19 Apr 2007, 13:24
What a stupid poll!
Mitch Clarke v Hawkins would be a fairer comparison.
No different to Gibbs v Hawkins. But yeah get your point;)
black_hart
19 Apr 2007, 13:26
hard to judge when havent seen much of Luenberger in the AFL. How good does everyone think Tomahwak can be? People liken him to Plugger. I cant help but think he is more like the modern CHF in a Barry Hall or Jonathon Brown. Not saying hes nearly as good as them just has the physique and moves like them.
Funny i saw hawkins on the news the other day and he was saying brown was his role model. When you watch him play you can see similarities to brown in the way he marks,moves & kicks for goal.
No different to Gibbs v Hawkins. But yeah get your point;)
Comparing anyone to Gibbs is just silly. Gibbs is the best #1 draft pick in the past 25 years. :)
Worst poll ever?
Definately a crap poll, but no where near the worst.
Free Willy
19 Apr 2007, 17:46
Adrian McAdam kills them all.............
Well at least his first 3 games. :rolleyes:
Alphanumeric
20 Apr 2007, 15:20
Leunberger hasn't played a game yet. Pointless poll in my opinion.
Ask again in 17 weeks.
delirious1
20 Apr 2007, 15:22
Who even thought Leuenberger would get a game this year:confused:
wait a year or two, and he will be the best young ruckman in the game:thumbsu: