View Full Version : SFL Div 3 Reserves
Pages :
1
2
3
4
5
6
7
8
9
10
11
12
13
14
[
15]
16
Frankencow
27 Apr 2008, 14:40
Good win for the Yarras over Mount. Will be preparing all week to play the Skye juggernaut. Skye could conceivably do the Seniors/Reserves double. Gags was good for Sandown, and Deano had a good first half but went a little quiet in the second. Despite the score, it didn't really seem the game was over until well into the last to us.
Disappointing to see the Mount twos bring an esky full of beer with them. Members of our Committee were (rightly) very annoyed. That sort of thing only encourages us not to support Mount's bar next time and the clubs are the losers in the end.
By some strange coincidence, the Yarras and Canterbury both had groups end up at the Terminus. Canterbury sound like they've bounced back in the ones and twos since last week's disappointments.
Good win for the Yarras over Mount. Will be preparing all week to play the Skye juggernaut. Skye could conceivably do the Seniors/Reserves double. Gags was good for Sandown, and Deano had a good first half but went a little quiet in the second. Despite the score, it didn't really seem the game was over until well into the last to us.
Disappointing to see the Mount twos bring an esky full of beer with them. Members of our Committee were (rightly) very annoyed. That sort of thing only encourages us not to support Mount's bar next time and the clubs are the losers in the end.
By some strange coincidence, the Yarras and Canterbury both had groups end up at the Terminus. Canterbury sound like they've bounced back in the ones and twos since last week's disappointments.
At present trying to bounce back from the stint at the terminus:D
Hey Cow,
Rumour has it, you guys had the same umpire from last week against us.
Did you have 2 umpires or just the one again?
We had only one umpire and he was absolutely useless. Calling frees from behind play and not in position to call many at all.:mad:
How did you guys fare with the loss of a few guys due to injury?
the kid3
28 Apr 2008, 13:43
Good win for the Yarras over Mount. Will be preparing all week to play the Skye juggernaut. Skye could conceivably do the Seniors/Reserves double. Gags was good for Sandown, and Deano had a good first half but went a little quiet in the second. Despite the score, it didn't really seem the game was over until well into the last to us.
Disappointing to see the Mount twos bring an esky full of beer with them. Members of our Committee were (rightly) very annoyed. That sort of thing only encourages us not to support Mount's bar next time and the clubs are the losers in the end.
By some strange coincidence, the Yarras and Canterbury both had groups end up at the Terminus. Canterbury sound like they've bounced back in the ones and twos since last week's disappointments.
Well played by the Yarra's 2nds on Sat, look foward to the next time around.
Bad form by our blokes if that is the case, i will have words to the group this week. You are right bar sales are the life line of our clubs and to do that is not on. :thumbsd:
Frankencow
28 Apr 2008, 14:58
Hey Cow,
Rumour has it, you guys had the same umpire from last week against us.
Did you have 2 umpires or just the one again?
We had only one umpire and he was absolutely useless. Calling frees from behind play and not in position to call many at all.:mad:
How did you guys fare with the loss of a few guys due to injury?
We did well Jim, same umpire as last week. Had a good game, no dropping the ball decisions like last week. :D Umpiring's always better when you don't think of it as an issue, and no real obvious mistakes stood out. Good bloke too, had a beer with some of the boys from both sides after the game.
Yeah, had the five out from the Seniors since last week and another of our best in the twos from last week unavailable because of a wedding too. A lot of the blokes that came in were very hungry and determined to earn their spots, so the competition is bringing out the best in us. Spotty (for those that know him) was outstanding and just about BOG. Game was still up for grabs halfway through the last quarter in my opinion. Gags, Deano, #47 and Paddy looked among their best. Unfortunately Dildo went down with an ankle just before half time. Hopefully he'll be back soone enough and Hadley did well rucking the second half.
Another of our midfielders is carrying an injury and had a run in the thirds, but was pretty much doing it by himself. Thirds need time to gel and will hopefully be a bit better when a few come back in the other two sides. I've no idea what they feed Mount's thirds, but they're all beanstalks!
Magilla Gorilla
28 Apr 2008, 15:16
We did well Jim, same umpire as last week. Had a good game, no dropping the ball decisions like last week. :D Umpiring's always better when you don't think of it as an issue, and no real obvious mistakes stood out. Good bloke too, had a beer with some of the boys from both sides after the game.
Yeah, had the five out from the Seniors since last week and another of our best in the twos from last week unavailable because of a wedding too. A lot of the blokes that came in were very hungry and determined to earn their spots, so the competition is bringing out the best in us. Spotty (for those that know him) was outstanding and just about BOG. Game was still up for grabs halfway through the last quarter in my opinion. Gags, Deano, #47 and Paddy looked among their best. Unfortunately Dildo went down with an ankle just before half time. Hopefully he'll be back soone enough and Hadley did well rucking the second half.
Another of our midfielders is carrying an injury and had a run in the thirds, but was pretty much doing it by himself. Thirds need time to gel and will hopefully be a bit better when a few come back in the other two sides. I've no idea what they feed Mount's thirds, but they're all beanstalks!Open you eyes man,Gags and Paddy had more turn overs than a macca's burger on a hot plate,deano was just servicable and #47 played a lone hand all in all a very disappointing game from Mounts 2's and maybe it's time for some players to get the chop chop in particular # 2,15,36,43,46,59 shall i continue.:eek:
MountPrettyBoy
28 Apr 2008, 18:39
Open you eyes man,Gags and Paddy had more turn overs than a macca's burger on a hot plate,deano was just servicable and #47 played a lone hand all in all a very disappointing game from Mounts 2's and maybe it's time for some players to get the chop chop in particular # 2,15,36,43,46,59 shall i continue.:eek:
Gags and Patty were probably our two best players.
Our forward line just didn't seem to function properly, only getting 1 goal out of our key forward compared to the 5 or 6 he kicked last week (credit to Sth Yarra's defence for doing this).
We just couldn't match Sth Yarra's intensity, especially around the stoppages. I reckon our Rucks won more taps but their midfielders won way more clearances.
Our backline did well considering the lack of support from the rest of us.
It's still early days yet, we'll just have to focus on our mistakes/weaknesses on the training track and bounce back next week.
But overall, Sth Yarra used the ball better, were smarter with their positioning of players and showed more intensity and hunger.
Magilla Gorilla
28 Apr 2008, 20:42
Gags and Patty were probably our two best players.
Our forward line just didn't seem to function properly, only getting 1 goal out of our key forward compared to the 5 or 6 he kicked last week (credit to Sth Yarra's defence for doing this).
We just couldn't match Sth Yarra's intensity, especially around the stoppages. I reckon our Rucks won more taps but their midfielders won way more clearances.
Our backline did well considering the lack of support from the rest of us.
It's still early days yet, we'll just have to focus on our mistakes/weaknesses on the training track and bounce back next week.
But overall, Sth Yarra used the ball better, were smarter with their positioning of players and showed more intensity and hunger.I never said they weren't there best i said they turned it over time and time again no point getting possessions if you turn it over.I have a Q for you MPB why didn't you have the intensity and the hunger....... Well
Master of Cooks
28 Apr 2008, 21:18
I never said they weren't there best i said they turned it over time and time again no point getting possessions if you turn it over.I have a Q for you MPB why didn't you have the intensity and the hunger....... Well
Maybe we took them lightly.
Maybe we weren't switched on properly.
Maybe we didn't prepare properly.
Who knows, but one thing i know is Sth Yarra were clearly better on the day.
Just for the record, as we all know, that ground is a huge home ground advantage for the yarra's, and they will be hard to beat there in both the reserves and seniors.
Sanigav
29 Apr 2008, 00:52
Just for the record, as we all know, that ground is a huge home ground advantage for the yarra's, and they will be hard to beat there in both the reserves and seniors.
Interesting thought considering all they've been trying to do is get moved somewhere else. Think it was something to do with how wet it gets
AROUNDTHETRAPS
29 Apr 2008, 07:04
I think MOC is referring to the change rooms we all know they are very ordinary and it puts a "negative" in players minds before they even run out on the ground, it might not seem much by if i'm off the mark OK but how many poeple dislike this ground due to the change room's ? BFG your a coach whats your thoughts ?:cool:
I think MOC is referring to the change rooms we all know they are very ordinary and it puts a "negative" in players minds before they even run out on the ground, it might not seem much by if i'm off the mark OK but how many poeple dislike this ground due to the change room's ? BFG your a coach whats your thoughts ?:cool:Your correct in what you say there change room puts most clubs in a negative mode it hinders pre game preparation,Saturdays game must start on Tuesday and Thursday night by addressing all the negatives of the ground so by Saturday the players know what they are facing and hopefully will perform accordingly.
lonewolf
29 Apr 2008, 10:08
Interesting thought considering all they've been trying to do is get moved somewhere else. Think it was something to do with how wet it gets
I think the main problem with their ground (changerooms aside) is the lack of lighting - only having lights at one end would make training problematic. Given a decent amount of rain, one end of the ground looks like an English marsh. The ground itself was pretty good in my opinion, though a little small.
MountPrettyBoy
29 Apr 2008, 13:40
Maybe we took them lightly.
Maybe we weren't switched on properly.
Maybe we didn't prepare properly.
Who knows, but one thing i know is Sth Yarra were clearly better on the day.
Just for the record, as we all know, that ground is a huge home ground advantage for the yarra's, and they will be hard to beat there in both the reserves and seniors.
I agree with all the above.. There's your answer Magilla..
SouthYarra16
29 Apr 2008, 17:50
jeeze u guys talk shit shit u guys dont go out as hard to play becoz the rooms are to small talk crap boys and coming from the coach 2
jeeze u guys talk shit shit u guys dont go out as hard to play becoz the rooms are to small talk crap boys and coming from the coach 2Nice work Corey i didn't say we don't go out as hard, as you would know,all i said it hinders your pre game plans did you win the seniors.......no so our prep work was ok don't you agree,maybe you should wear slippers next time instead of boots and my player wouldn't of had a bruised ankle.;)
AROUNDTHETRAPS
30 Apr 2008, 07:48
Hey M-loin bumped into a guy who's a new recruit to you guys his name was Brad and said he used to play for Dandy thinks like everybody else that you guys are the team to beat ! How are the new recruits all fitting in and how does this guy go as I think I saw him play before and he's not the most talanted but he does give you everything ?:cool:
Hey M-loin bumped into a guy who's a new recruit to you guys his name was Brad and said he used to play for Dandy thinks like everybody else that you guys are the team to beat ! How are the new recruits all fitting in and how does this guy go as I think I saw him play before and he's not the most talanted but he does give you everything ?:cool:Brads fitted in well gives another rotation through mid field we have about 10 to 15 new players and what i can see all have fitted in well,as far as the team to beat it's a long season any thing could happen .
Frankencow you can sleep at night now vinny is back, played first game today.:D
g'day from the gold coast boys!!:p good to see the eagles continue their winning ways!! no disrespect to canterbury, but wow, should be a good game this week doveton v skye(on the rebound)
inureface
23 May 2008, 01:31
g'day from the gold coast boys!!:p good to see the eagles continue their winning ways!! no disrespect to canterbury, but wow, should be a good game this week doveton v skye(on the rebound)
looking to play div3 THIS YEAR .any clubs need a ff, with the right delivery 100 plus ff .height 2oo cm weight 86 k age 31 have not played for 2 years .can only train once every week mostly tuesdays .will play twos or ones ,just returned from 2 year work stint in U .S .A.
AROUNDTHETRAPS
23 May 2008, 07:04
Mate if live in Doveton why not support your local club as this is what keeps clubs alive they are undefeated in the reserves and appear OK in the ones at this stage.:cool:
inureface
24 May 2008, 00:14
Mate if live in Doveton why not support your local club as this is what keeps clubs alive they are undefeated in the reserves and appear OK in the ones at this stage.:cool:
Never leave your computer on if your mate is comeing around.I actually play div2 this year .But good luck to Doveton Eagles.
2 big games in the magoos this week, doveton have the chance to go 2 games clear and mount can push skye out of the top 4!!
the kid3
28 May 2008, 13:07
2 big games in the magoos this week, doveton have the chance to go 2 games clear and mount can push skye out of the top 4!!
Looking foward to the clash down at the hanger. Should be a very good contest.
Wondering, will frankencow be able to keep the gag in check if the Yarra's can get over the Eagles.:D
discotrain
29 May 2008, 03:38
i see you played against the sandown cobras last week blac did you get a kick?
i see you played against the sandown cobras last week blac did you get a kick?
4, quality though!!:p big question is, when will you again grace us with your presence??
discotrain
29 May 2008, 16:57
played ok against skye missed the cobras game due to work ready to go against the yarra this week!
MadMan V1.2
30 May 2008, 17:51
Looking foward to the clash down at the hanger. Should be a very good contest.
Wondering, will frankencow be able to keep the gag in check if the Yarra's can get over the Eagles.:D
It really is unreal the gag that has been put on the Yarra boys!!!!
seriously big footy is not that bad, keeps people entertained on days that arnt Tuesday, thursday and especially Saturdays!!!
Looking forward to the Return of the Cow!!! when the gag is removed obviously!!!
It really is unreal the gag that has been put on the Yarra boys!!!!
seriously big footy is not that bad, keeps people entertained on days that arnt Tuesday, thursday and especially Saturdays!!!
Looking forward to the Return of the Cow!!! when the gag is removed obviously!!!
you heard it here first madman!!!! call me hutchy:D
surely that gag has been lifted frankencow??
say something frankencow!! just something little!!:o
frankencow has lost his nerve!!:(
Starting to get interesting at the top this year, very even comp.... whats your thoughts at the half way mark??
gee it's quiet on here with no frankencow, the ban must be why they are winning!!! 8 and 1 and sitting preety, can anyone match them in the second half of the year???:confused:
No 1 important
25 Jun 2008, 22:50
gee it's quiet on here with no frankencow, the ban must be why they are winning!!! 8 and 1 and sitting preety, can anyone match them in the second half of the year???:confused:
interesting to note that you had a good win against Doveton the other week, but now you are coming up against Mount and Skye in the next two games, infact you have beaten all clubs once except for Mount and Skye, how do you think you will go?
interesting to note that you had a good win against Doveton the other week, but now you are coming up against Mount and Skye in the next two games, infact you have beaten all clubs once except for Mount and Skye, how do you think you will go?
we have beaten everyone except for mount and the yarra's. Not to sure how we will fare time will tell. They smacked us last time.
RDOULTRY
26 Jun 2008, 09:46
gee it's quiet on here with no frankencow, the ban must be why they are winning!!! 8 and 1 and sitting preety, can anyone match them in the second half of the year???:confused:
Great to see in the reserves this year that at the moment, 5 teams are fighting for the top 4 spots. South are definitely sitting pretty, and after playing everyone once, they are the obvious team to beat. This week's results should break up the top four a little, but I think it will come down to the last few games of the season.
just putting two and two together, but did cerberus forfit the match against mount today? no scores and there ones only kicked 5 points against mount. Also interesting to note that mussaridis played for doveton seconds today and kicked 9. Maybe qualifying a few blokes just in case down there?:confused:
who r u
19 Jul 2008, 23:17
just putting two and two together, but did cerberus forfit the match against mount today? no scores and there ones only kicked 5 points against mount. Also interesting to note that mussaridis played for doveton seconds today and kicked 9. Maybe qualifying a few blokes just in case down there?:confused:
No need to qualify anyone Smuu, Mussa has come back after a few weeks out and has played in the magoos.
No need to qualify anyone Smuu, Mussa has come back after a few weeks out and has played in the magoos.
so you would expect him back in the ones next week then after kicking nine i assume?
lonewolf
21 Jul 2008, 09:42
just putting two and two together, but did cerberus forfit the match against mount today? no scores and there ones only kicked 5 points against mount. Also interesting to note that mussaridis played for doveton seconds today and kicked 9. Maybe qualifying a few blokes just in case down there?:confused:
I can confirm that Cerberus reserves forfeited on Saturday, though from talking to a couple of their players, it was due to the coaching staff making a statement to the playing group. Apparently they played the guys that had been training in the seniors, and didn't have enough that had trained to field a reserve side. We actually played a scratchie between our reserves and a side made up of our 3rds and Cerberus reserves, which made for some interesting times.
I can confirm that Cerberus reserves forfeited on Saturday, though from talking to a couple of their players, it was due to the coaching staff making a statement to the playing group. Apparently they played the guys that had been training in the seniors, and didn't have enough that had trained to field a reserve side. We actually played a scratchie between our reserves and a side made up of our 3rds and Cerberus reserves, which made for some interesting times.
Was there a bit of an intra-club scuffle lone wolf? Hope they can get a side together this week so we can have a hit out before playing the top side. Also not real fair that you blokes don't get percentage either.
lonewolf
22 Jul 2008, 09:58
Was there a bit of an intra-club scuffle lone wolf? Hope they can get a side together this week so we can have a hit out before playing the top side. Also not real fair that you blokes don't get percentage either.
Noscuffles SMUU28, just interesting watching whether teamates were prepared to really tackles each other in a game that only served as a full contact training drill. Happy to say that while played in the right spirit, no-one shirked an issue.
MountPrettyBoy
22 Jul 2008, 16:39
Noscuffles SMUU28, just interesting watching whether teamates were prepared to really tackles each other in a game that only served as a full contact training drill. Happy to say that while played in the right spirit, no-one shirked an issue.
The hit-out was a bit of a glorified scratch match between Mt Waverley vs The 'Allies'.
It was a decent contest though, mainly the first half.
The second half was a bit of a blow out with Mt Waverley dominating.
This was mainly due to the Allies having no bench and some of the older players not being able to run out the whole match and Mt Waverley having the better personnel.
But overall, it was a good fun hit-out, I think overall everybody enjoyed themselves and it was played in good spirits.
The hit-out was a bit of a glorified scratch match between Mt Waverley vs The 'Allies'.
It was a decent contest though, mainly the first half.
The second half was a bit of a blow out with Mt Waverley dominating.
This was mainly due to the Allies having no bench and some of the older players not being able to run out the whole match and Mt Waverley having the better personnel.
But overall, it was a good fun hit-out, I think overall everybody enjoyed themselves and it was played in good spirits.
did the cerberus boys think they would have a side this week or should i start planning training!!!!
discotrain
30 Jul 2008, 16:51
just putting two and two together, but did cerberus forfit the match against mount today? no scores and there ones only kicked 5 points against mount. Also interesting to note that mussaridis played for doveton seconds today and kicked 9. Maybe qualifying a few blokes just in case down there?:confused:
stupid comment smuu! why would you try qualifying senior players for twos footy when your ones are trying to make finals??? also take a look at his playing record this year, before sandown he hadnt played in nearly 6 weeks so isnt coming back thru the twos the norm?? i assume it is at most clubs, what about jenkins? is that what canterbury is doing?:p
stupid comment smuu! why would you try qualifying senior players for twos footy when your ones are trying to make finals??? also take a look at his playing record this year, before sandown he hadnt played in nearly 6 weeks so isnt coming back thru the twos the norm?? i assume it is at most clubs, what about jenkins? is that what canterbury is doing?:p
my point exactly if his in your best 18 shouldn't he be playing ones not kicking a bag against Sandown two's? the way sandown are he would have kicked a bag in the ones anyway. Jenko has played one two's game and that is it, so i don't know where you are going there. Anyway see you sat....
stupid comment smuu! why would you try qualifying senior players for twos footy when your ones are trying to make finals??? also take a look at his playing record this year, before sandown he hadnt played in nearly 6 weeks so isnt coming back thru the twos the norm?? i assume it is at most clubs, what about jenkins? is that what canterbury is doing?:p
must have been trying to set up a smoke screen disco:rolleyes: so when is he playing his last two to qualify?
must have been trying to set up a smoke screen disco:rolleyes: so when is he playing his last two to qualify?
He played against Sandown after not playing for 6 weeks and then was unavailable against Sth Yarra, so he again played in the two's whats your point Smuu28.
I think you will find that the side has been winnning all year without these players in fact there are players in the 1sts who can still qualify, as well as several players out injured.
As it turned out he wasn't required in the firsts anyway !
He played against Sandown after not playing for 6 weeks and then was unavailable against Sth Yarra, so he again played in the two's whats your point Smuu28.
I think you will find that the side has been winnning all year without these players in fact there are players in the 1sts who can still qualify, as well as several players out injured.
As it turned out he wasn't required in the firsts anyway !
can't argue with that!!
He played against Sandown after not playing for 6 weeks and then was unavailable against Sth Yarra, so he again played in the two's whats your point Smuu28.
I think you will find that the side has been winnning all year without these players in fact there are players in the 1sts who can still qualify, as well as several players out injured.
As it turned out he wasn't required in the firsts anyway !
looks like you blokes with mussa are as big a favourites as skye are in the ones for the flag;) mind you theres a bit of a log jamb from 2nd to 5th. Interesting few weeks about to unfold...
looks like you blokes with mussa are as big a favourites as skye are in the ones for the flag;) mind you theres a bit of a log jamb from 2nd to 5th. Interesting few weeks about to unfold...
will all come down to the last round!! interesting events at the sth yarra v dandenong game on saturday, heard yarras lead by 8-9 goals when an interchange player entered the field of play to help an injured teammate off the ground, dandy called for a player count and yarra had there score wiped. still ended up winning easily but may effect there percentage come final round!! frankencow, you allowed to discuss??
will all come down to the last round!! interesting events at the sth yarra v dandenong game on saturday, heard yarras lead by 8-9 goals when an interchange player entered the field of play to help an injured teammate off the ground, dandy called for a player count and yarra had there score wiped. still ended up winning easily but may effect there percentage come final round!! frankencow, you allowed to discuss??
Yarras were leading by about 9 goals at the time when a yarra player went down and asked for the stretcher. Both teams went to thier own huddle when Yarra's bench came onto the ground, not just one player but all of the bench. Dandy's bench called for a head count and Yarra's score was wiped. This was in the second quarter. To yarra's credit, they lost the plot for the rest of the quarter but came out after the break and got back to business and controlled the game.
From what I heard after the game, there will be an investigation into this to see if the lost score will be re-instated or not. SFL to investigate and decide this week.
MadMan V1.2
5 Aug 2008, 17:34
Jesus, scored wiped and still won, unreal!!
Mussa told me on satday avo that he will be qaulifying for doveton ressies for finals.
be a loss for the seniors id say....
GOING PLACES
5 Aug 2008, 23:11
Jesus, scored wiped and still won, unreal!!
Mussa told me on satday avo that he will be qaulifying for doveton ressies for finals.
be a loss for the seniors id say....
Great effort by Mussa. Good to see him hang around and watch Dovetons seniors on Saturday. Also by what he was saying he will be coaching elsewhere next year. Probably should just about win best clubman this year.
benchman
6 Aug 2008, 12:28
Great effort by Mussa. Good to see him hang around and watch Dovetons seniors on Saturday. Also by what he was saying he will be coaching elsewhere next year. Probably should just about win best clubman this year.
do i detect some sarcasm corwey??
Con Found It
6 Aug 2008, 12:41
Benchman you have declared you support the Rockers yet you seem to spend all your time on the Div 3 sites,very puzzling my friend.
so why aren't you posting on Div 2 only, and stop worrying about the sides you no longer play,just a thought :D
benchman
6 Aug 2008, 16:08
Benchman you have declared you support the Rockers yet you seem to spend all your time on the Div 3 sites,very puzzling my friend.
so why aren't you posting on Div 2 only, and stop worrying about the sides you no longer play,just a thought :D
their is no1 talking on any of the other forums..........and with the dingos dominating div2 is a little pointless this year anyway
Con Found It
6 Aug 2008, 16:25
their is no1 talking on any of the other forums..........and with the dingos dominating div2 is a little pointless this year anywayFair point,you seem to have an opinion on Skye and Mount whats the go their. Eg Rowley,Corey,Costantino M O C ,Price :confused:
southern star
6 Aug 2008, 20:00
Great effort by Mussa. Good to see him hang around and watch Dovetons seniors on Saturday. Also by what he was saying he will be coaching elsewhere next year. Probably should just about win best clubman this year.
That would make it back to back best clubman
Great effort by Mussa. Good to see him hang around and watch Dovetons seniors on Saturday. Also by what he was saying he will be coaching elsewhere next year. Probably should just about win best clubman this year.
just a pleb aren't you!!:thumbsd:
Great effort by Mussa. Good to see him hang around and watch Dovetons seniors on Saturday. Also by what he was saying he will be coaching elsewhere next year. Probably should just about win best clubman this year.
Quite bizzare that Doveton are dropping players back into the ressies to qualify them for finals. From history, wasn't there a statement a couple of years ago from Doveton that they don't do this sort of thing. Funny, 'cause I think they are. If it was my club and the seniors are just hanging in there with a chance, wouldn't you play your best 21 in the seniors. Bizzare!!!!
benchman
8 Aug 2008, 12:59
Quite bizzare that Doveton are dropping players back into the ressies to qualify them for finals. From history, wasn't there a statement a couple of years ago from Doveton that they don't do this sort of thing. Funny, 'cause I think they are. If it was my club and the seniors are just hanging in there with a chance, wouldn't you play your best 21 in the seniors. Bizzare!!!!
wouldnt didak be playing for colliwobbles if you awlyas play you're best 21 to make sure you get in finals.......
point being if a bloke is being disciplined, he doesnt play, regardless of best 21 or not......if a bloke goes to a caoch and says he dont wanna play 1's, then you dont play him, regardless of best 21.... you play the best 21 that WANT to be there, and DESERVE to be there
no offense to muzza, dont know him never met him,but im sure the dovey selection comitee know wat they r doing
wouldnt didak be playing for colliwobbles if you awlyas play you're best 21 to make sure you get in finals.......
point being if a bloke is being disciplined, he doesnt play, regardless of best 21 or not......if a bloke goes to a caoch and says he dont wanna play 1's, then you dont play him, regardless of best 21.... you play the best 21 that WANT to be there, and DESERVE to be there
no offense to muzza, dont know him never met him,but im sure the dovey selection comitee know wat they r doing
Yeah but, a senior player at a number of clubs and is now playing in the ressies. He is better than that.
WERTHECHAMPIONS
8 Aug 2008, 13:45
Yeah but, a senior player at a number of clubs and is now playing in the ressies. He is better than that.
Spot on Benchman, I can assure you that Doveton are not dropping anyone back to qualify them for a 2's flag. I guarantee you Doveton are playing to make the finals in the Seniors and hopefully we will get over the line. Whilst a 2's flag would be a bonus, it is definitely not what the club is aiming for.
Whilst we do have a couple of ex Dandy players at the club, we do not have the same thought process as the Dandenong Demons do in taking the easy way out and playing for 2's flags.
Tell me would you be playing Mussa in the 1's if he hasnt trained for about 10 weeks and cant commit due to work commitments? I dont think so, better off playing a young kid who trains twice a week and deserves his spot. Mussa knows what the club is about and if that means he has to play 2's thats where he will play.
Now that the home and away season has finished, any nominations for Ressies team of the year??
From what games I have seen this year of a number of clubs, I'll put in-
Jason Wood from Canterbury
Grant Wyatt, Kane Bundy and Tim Watson from Doveton
Dean Leask from Mount Waverly
Patton, Malone, Rodders from Skye
Bart McDonald, Trav Moore from Dandenong
Don't know his name, but #38 i think from Sth.Yarra, this guy has curly hair and haddlee as well.
Thelionsleeps2nite
25 Aug 2008, 15:02
How the f*ck did Mount beat Duffton did Duffton lie down so Mount can get up it's the only solution iv'e got as Kinder is as usefull as $hit on a brick.
Now that the home and away season has finished, any nominations for Ressies team of the year??
From what games I have seen this year of a number of clubs, I'll put in-
Jason Wood from Canterbury
Grant Wyatt, Kane Bundy and Tim Watson from Doveton
Dean Leask from Mount Waverly
Patton, Malone, Rodders from Skye
Bart McDonald, Trav Moore from Dandenong
Don't know his name, but #38 i think from Sth.Yarra, this guy has curly hair and haddlee as well.
higgon and rumbold from sth yarra, kruger, baum and hamish giles from canterbury, attwood from mount, i'll think of more latter!!
morningglory
26 Aug 2008, 12:09
Its always hard to come up with best teams in the Reserves because the good players often head up to the 1s. I wouldn't disagree with anyone named so far. For mine, Bundy from Doveton has been the stand-out for the year in the 2s, and I've been surprised that he hasn't been given a better crack at it. He should win the league BnF. Even harder to name a Best 22. Below is the best I could come up with from what names have been mentioned so far, plus a few others I've played against over the years and rated:
B - Jury (Yarra), P Garrivan (Mount), Giles (Cant)
HB - Higgon (Yarra), O'Byrne (Sandown), Wyett (Doveton)
C - Bundy (Doveton), Leask (Mt), Baum (Cant)
HF - Fernando (Doveton), Attwood (Mt), Nicolosi (Dand)
F - Arena (Doveton), Gorman (Doveton), Bath (Yarra)
Rucks -Rodriguez (Skye), Wood (Cant), McDonald (Dand)
Bench - Lambert (Skye), Burridge (Skye), Brady (Yarra), S Garrivan (Mount)
Its always hard to come up with best teams in the Reserves because the good players often head up to the 1s. I wouldn't disagree with anyone named so far. For mine, Bundy from Doveton has been the stand-out for the year in the 2s, and I've been surprised that he hasn't been given a better crack at it. He should win the league BnF. Even harder to name a Best 22. Below is the best I could come up with from what names have been mentioned so far, plus a few others I've played against over the years and rated:
B - Jury (Yarra), P Garrivan (Mount), Giles (Cant)
HB - Higgon (Yarra), O'Byrne (Sandown), Wyett (Doveton)
C - Bundy (Doveton), Leask (Mt), Baum (Cant)
HF - Fernando (Doveton), Attwood (Mt), Nicolosi (Dand)
F - Arena (Doveton), Gorman (Doveton), Bath (Yarra)
Rucks -Rodriguez (Skye), Wood (Cant), McDonald (Dand)
Bench - Lambert (Skye), Burridge (Skye), Brady (Yarra), S Garrivan (Mount)
you piss taking?? justin wild(doveton)
and what about jt from canterbury, he'd replace bart in the guts!!
Master of Cooks
26 Aug 2008, 13:49
Its always hard to come up with best teams in the Reserves because the good players often head up to the 1s. I wouldn't disagree with anyone named so far. For mine, Bundy from Doveton has been the stand-out for the year in the 2s, and I've been surprised that he hasn't been given a better crack at it. He should win the league BnF. Even harder to name a Best 22. Below is the best I could come up with from what names have been mentioned so far, plus a few others I've played against over the years and rated:
B - Jury (Yarra), P Garrivan (Mount), Giles (Cant)
HB - Higgon (Yarra), O'Byrne (Sandown), Wyett (Doveton)
C - Bundy (Doveton), Leask (Mt), Baum (Cant)
HF - Fernando (Doveton), Attwood (Mt), Nicolosi (Dand)
F - Arena (Doveton), Gorman (Doveton), Bath (Yarra)
Rucks -Rodriguez (Skye), Wood (Cant), McDonald (Dand)
Bench - Lambert (Skye), Burridge (Skye), Brady (Yarra), S Garrivan (Mount)
Not too sure about other teams, but from mt T. Beecroft is a certainity. I'd have him ahead of Leask based on this years preformances. Also Cugley and Marshall would be pretty stiff to miss out imo.
morningglory
26 Aug 2008, 14:22
you piss taking?? justin wild(doveton)
and what about jt from canterbury, he'd replace bart in the guts!!
Was trying to get some people from every club into the team. I don't know if you've tried, but its hard piecing together a team of blokes who aren't good enough to play in their Senior teams.
Master of Cooks, why don't I just put 22 Mt Waverley blokes in? :rolleyes:
Master of Cooks
26 Aug 2008, 19:32
Was trying to get some people from every club into the team. I don't know if you've tried, but its hard piecing together a team of blokes who aren't good enough to play in their Senior teams.
Master of Cooks, why don't I just put 22 Mt Waverley blokes in? :rolleyes:
Pretty sure i only nominated 3 blokes.:o
always dropped
27 Aug 2008, 00:32
you piss taking?? justin wild(doveton)
and what about jt from canterbury, he'd replace bart in the guts!!
my noms are Cantrbury Ruck Rick Brown . the rest of the players are SKYE
back line Lee Lambert,
Centre John Reece,Tim Lambert
Forwards NONE
Followers David Paton
Bench None
Coach David Paton
MadMan V1.2
27 Aug 2008, 17:59
what about the other lambert??
always dropped
27 Aug 2008, 18:49
what about the other lambert??
he is a **** head (can i be suspended for saying that word )
But i think you would see him some where next year .
good luck for this saturday hope you are B.O.G.
my noms are Cantrbury Ruck Rick Brown . the rest of the players are SKYE
back line Lee Lambert,
Centre John Reece,Tim Lambert
Forwards NONE
Followers David Paton
Bench None
Coach David Paton
Rick Brown has only played one ressies game and that was last week due to a wedding, so he couldn't play ones.
from each team the players that in my opinion make the team of the year are as follows....
DOVETON: Wyett, Bundy, Leak, Wild, Fernando
MOUNT: Attwood, T. Beecroft, S. Beecroft, Leask
SOUTH: Higgon, Jury, Rumbold, Ibrahim, Willams
SKYE: L.Lambert, T.Lambert, Rodders, Polson
CANTERBURY: Wood, H.Giles, Kruger, Baum
DANDY: McDonald, Nicolosi
CERBRUS: Anderson
was going to put in Allen from cant but he is just a hack:D
from each team the players that in my opinion make the team of the year are as follows....
DOVETON: Wyett, Bundy, Leak, Wild
MOUNT: Attwood, T. Beecroft, S. Beecroft, Leask
SOUTH: Higgon, Jury, Rumbold, Ibrahim, Willams
SKYE: L.Lambert, T.Lambert, Rodders, Polson
CANTERBURY: Wood, H.Giles, Kruger, Baum
DANDY: McDonald, Nicolosi
CERBRUS: Anderson
was going to put in Allen from cant but he is just a hack:D
no room for leading goal kicker fernando??
always dropped
27 Aug 2008, 22:33
Rick Brown has only played one ressies game and that was last week due to a wedding, so he couldn't play ones.
Then if he is a ones player i would replace him with Chris Rodrigues SKYE.
always dropped
27 Aug 2008, 22:39
no room for leading goal kicker fernando??
Can you hear the drums .
from each team the players that in my opinion make the team of the year are as follows....
DOVETON: Wyett, Bundy, Leak, Wild, Fernando
MOUNT: Attwood, T. Beecroft, S. Beecroft, Leask
SOUTH: Higgon, Jury, Rumbold, Ibrahim, Willams
SKYE: L.Lambert, T.Lambert, Rodders, Polson
CANTERBURY: Wood, H.Giles, Kruger, Baum
DANDY: McDonald, Nicolosi
CERBRUS: Anderson
was going to put in Allen from cant but he is just a hack:D
Quite possibly the best twos midfielder I have ever seen.
discotrain
28 Aug 2008, 17:53
Quite possibly the best twos midfielder I have ever seen.
is a handy player but spends to much time showboatin to his mates on the sidelines, notice he didnt get a kick or not alot of em last week even though mount pumped the eagles! if he can pull his head in a bit would be a quality player! maybe lonewolf can help him out!
the kid3
29 Aug 2008, 08:54
From reports he has a bicep injury and i think you will find he spent the last 3/4 on the pine. He does try to bring the crowd into the game to much sometimes.
morningglory
31 Aug 2008, 02:00
Quite possibly the best twos midfielder I have ever seen.
Laughable...
Pretty competent at CHF - killed us there when he played there, but his true colours show out when he plays up the ground. Looks disinterested unless he's near goals and can act like a d**khead around his mates.
On a side note, congratulations to Yarra today. Looked far too good for an inconsistent Canterbury side, and despite not finishing top two they still appear a threat. Going further on the note of today, congratulations to Skye in the Seniors, who really showed their class and professionalism by not turning straight to the punch after the game was iced at 3QT. :rolleyes:
Ty Webb
31 Aug 2008, 15:34
Surely when naming any Res. All Star Side you start with Swooper and name the rest around him!!!!!
always dropped
31 Aug 2008, 16:15
Surely when naming any Res. All Star Side you start with Swooper and name the rest around him!!!!!
that is so stupid he would be umpireing the game .
Laughable...
Pretty competent at CHF - killed us there when he played there, but his true colours show out when he plays up the ground. Looks disinterested unless he's near goals and can act like a d**khead around his mates.
On a side note, congratulations to Yarra today. Looked far too good for an inconsistent Canterbury side, and despite not finishing top two they still appear a threat. Going further on the note of today, congratulations to Skye in the Seniors, who really showed their class and professionalism by not turning straight to the punch after the game was iced at 3QT. :rolleyes:
Doodles goes alright!
On a side note, how good was the left, right, left combo from the guy with the massive chin? 3 punches, 1 combo, 2 blokes hit.
Kudos to the blokes that were on the receiving end coz they kept on playin.
Some controversy to come out of the cant/yarra ressie game, re Bernard Brady?
http://www.sportingpulse.com/team_info.cgi?player=Bernard%20Brady&action=PSTATS&pID=187046024&client=1-3909-0-64495-6151453
11 senior games during the season is clearly over the limit. Even if they sorted out some "promise" that he won't play seniors next week, it's still against the rules?
Some controversy to come out of the cant/yarra ressie game, re Bernard Brady?
http://www.sportingpulse.com/team_info.cgi?player=Bernard%20Brady&action=PSTATS&pID=187046024&client=1-3909-0-64495-6151453
11 senior games during the season is clearly over the limit. Even if they sorted out some "promise" that he won't play seniors next week, it's still against the rules?
Wasn't going to say anything as it is now in hands of league but as you say rules have been broken.... watch this space i suppose.
scratcha
31 Aug 2008, 21:22
Some controversy to come out of the cant/yarra ressie game, re Bernard Brady?
http://www.sportingpulse.com/team_info.cgi?player=Bernard%20Brady&action=PSTATS&pID=187046024&client=1-3909-0-64495-6151453
11 senior games during the season is clearly over the limit. Even if they sorted out some "promise" that he won't play seniors next week, it's still against the rules?
If this is the case.... Plain and simple the game should be taken from Sth Yarra and awarded to Canterbury, No Ifs or Buts. ...However... the league is too weak, especially with Sth Yarra reps working for the SFL>
If this is the case.... Plain and simple the game should be taken from Sth Yarra and awarded to Canterbury, No Ifs or Buts. ...However... the league is too weak, especially with Sth Yarra reps working for the SFL>
The rules are as i understand it is if both teams- seniors and reserves- play on the same day the only qualification rule is the six club games, players can move between the grades regardless of how many seniors and reserves games played, if the teams play on different days the max 10 senior game minimum of 4 reserve game rule applies along side the six club game qualification. This has been the case in every league i have played in.
The rules are as i understand it is if both teams- seniors and reserves- play on the same day the only qualification rule is the six club games, players can move between the grades regardless of how many seniors and reserves games played, if the teams play on different days the max 10 senior game minimum of 4 reserve game rule applies along side the six club game qualification. This has been the case in every league i have played in.
spot on, but what will happen now?? nothing!!:thumbsd:
MadMan V1.2
31 Aug 2008, 23:16
I must admit, there seem to be a few sth yarra players that clearly should not of been playing 2's!!
but like someone said, the SFL Yarras will get no punishment id assume
I must admit, there seem to be a few sth yarra players that clearly should not of been playing 2's!!
but like someone said, the SFL Yarras will get no punishment id assume
:p
:p
:p
:p
the kid3
1 Sep 2008, 11:25
Surely when naming any Res. All Star Side you start with Swooper and name the rest around him!!!!!
Still an astute judge i see Ty Webb. :rolleyes:
RDOULTRY
1 Sep 2008, 14:55
Some controversy to come out of the cant/yarra ressie game, re Bernard Brady?
http://www.sportingpulse.com/team_info.cgi?player=Bernard%20Brady&action=PSTATS&pID=187046024&client=1-3909-0-64495-6151453
11 senior games during the season is clearly over the limit. Even if they sorted out some "promise" that he won't play seniors next week, it's still against the rules?
It seems as though Brady was allowed to play as the yarra's went to the SFL and said they were short on numbers(late in the week)!!!:eek::eek::eek: Now there is a few things to this. Firstly, I know for a fact that there were a few on the side lines that missed out on selection (eligable and fit players). Secondly, you can still field a side with 16 players (clearly had more than this even without Brady). And lastly, they have had a colts team (3rds) this year because of excess numbers, and you can't tell me that none of these guys were available. Looks like it has been handy for the Yarras to have someone on the inside.:mad:
Poor form Yarras, poor form SFL.:thumbsd::thumbsd:
the kid3
1 Sep 2008, 16:25
It seems as though Brady was allowed to play as the yarra's went to the SFL and said they were short on numbers(late in the week)!!!:eek::eek::eek: Now there is a few things to this. Firstly, I know for a fact that there were a few on the side lines that missed out on selection (eligable and fit players). Secondly, you can still field a side with 16 players (clearly had more than this even without Brady). And lastly, they have had a colts team (3rds) this year because of excess numbers, and you can't tell me that none of these guys were available. Looks like it has been handy for the Yarras to have someone on the inside.:mad:
Poor form Yarras, poor form SFL.:thumbsd::thumbsd:
Apart from the fit ones that missed Saturday they had a bench on Saturday.
So if the above is correct then they have misled the league and should be stripped of the game..:mad:
Would anyone from Yarra like to explain or are going to sit their in silent guilt??????????
always dropped
1 Sep 2008, 16:43
Still an astute judge i see Ty Webb. :rolleyes:
bad luck about the loss on saturday ,may be you should have played SWOOPA. if you think you could build a reserves side around the guy.