View Full Version : In's & Outs : last 50 games !
This is the change in lists in TW’s reign (just 50 games) ;
OUT:
B:.... Kelleway A..... Limbach..... Kelleway D
HB:.... Zantuck..... Gaspar..... Chaffey
C:.... Fleming..... Fiora..... Blumfield
HF:.... Hilton..... Marsh..... Rogers
F:.... Dagicevic..... Ottens..... Rodan
FOLL:.... Stafford..... Campbell..... Roach
INT:.... Weller..... Houlihan..... Fletcher
.......Archibald..... Marsh..... Humm
.......Nicholls
IN:
B:.... Thursfiled..... McGuanne..... White
HB:.... JON..... Polak..... Bowden P
C:.... Polo..... Deledio..... Meyer
HF:.... Riewolt..... Hughes..... Tambling
F:.... Collins..... Pattison..... King
FOLL:.... Simmons..... Foley..... Howat
INT:.... Connors..... Casserley..... Graham
.......Edwards
We have come along way!
Richo Rules
11 May 2007, 19:56
im pretty sure frawley cut d kellaway and rogers
polakthetiger
11 May 2007, 20:10
This is the change in lists in TW’s reign (just 50 games) ;
We have come along way!
not so far!
Rancid_Beasties
12 May 2007, 12:21
This is the change in lists in TW’s reign (just 50 games) ;
OUT:
B:.... Kelleway A..... Limbach..... Kelleway D
HB:.... Zantuck..... Gaspar..... Chaffey
C:.... Fleming..... Fiora..... Blumfield
HF:.... Hilton..... Marsh..... Rogers
F:.... Dagicevic..... Ottens..... Rodan
FOLL:.... Stafford..... Campbell..... Roach
INT:.... Weller..... Houlihan..... Fletcher
.......Archibald..... Marsh..... Humm
.......Nicholls
IN:
B:.... Thursfiled..... McGuanne..... White
HB:.... JON..... Polak..... Bowden P
C:.... Polo..... Deledio..... Meyer
HF:.... Riewolt..... Hughes..... Tambling
F:.... Collins..... Pattison..... King
FOLL:.... Simmons..... Foley..... Howat
INT:.... Connors..... Casserley..... Graham
.......Edwards
We have come along way!
Firstly, I didnt know we had 2 marsh's at our club? And Limbach at Full Back? WTF?
Ok I would actually argue team 1 would beat team 2. Not necessarily on potential but on the sheer fact there are:
4 All Australians (a.kellaway, d.gaspar, b.ottens, w.campbell)
6 players who have been or will be 150+gamers (D.Kellaway, M.Chaffey, M.Rogers, A.Fiora, D.Rodan, G.Stafford)
6 players who had potential/ a few good games but didnt go on with it (limbach, zantuck, blumfield, hilton, draga, roach)
vs
0 All Australians
Only 1 Player who has played over 100 games
Only 4 or 5 Players who are potential AA's in the future (and thats only potentially, ie before richmondisation!)
8 Players who are either total duds or dont want to play for us (White, P.Bowden, Meyer, Casserley, Graham, Howat, King and Pattison)
Face it, this rebuilding we've been doing is RUBBISH!
stompie
12 May 2007, 12:58
I've got a soft spot for Richmond. I've always thought the players have a real go, and really put their heart in. I think the problem is that you always recruit weak-bondied panzies such as Pettifer. Even his name I dislike. Reminds me of female underwear. Then there is Fiora. His name has always had flower/hat connotations for me, which was quite an apt description of the way he plays.
Magic17
12 May 2007, 19:55
Ottens aside, Wallace has only just started making the really tough decisions unfortunately.
Now though I do worry that the hard calls are reactionary changes and not proactive as they should have been.
His 'out's' should have a reserves team as well by now.