Votes vs. Geelong for Round 7

[West Coast 06]

Hard to give, so I will give for effort.

5 Chick (never stopped chasing all day.)
4 Wirra
3 Judd
2 Priddis
1 Braun

[TheBigUnit]

5 - C Judd
4 - D Wirrpanda
3 - A Hansen
2 - B Waters
1 - M Rosa

[Big Man]

5 - C Judd
4 - D Wirrpanda
3 - A Hansen
2 - B Waters
1 - M.Priddis

Totally outplayed today, cant wait for redemption v Melbourne next Sunday :thumbsu:

[Blue and Gold Blood]

5) Wirrapunda
4) Hansen
3) Judd
2) Waters
1) Rosa

[Max zero]

No strict order, just our better players.

Priddis
Wirrapanda
Rosa
Hansen
Judd

[Embers]

5. David Wirrpanda
4. Ashley Hansen
3. Darren Glass
2. Matt Priddis
1. Matt Rosa

-5 for both Sebay and Armstrong

[larrikin]

Suprised how many are giving Judd high votes. Maybe I should watch again. Actually no, I'm not going to put myself through that.

5 - Wirra
4 - Hansen
3 - Waters
2 - Stenglein
1 - Glass

Tough to give votes. Very few players actually won their position

[Lion El'Johnson]

5. Hansen
4. Braun
3. Judd
2. Glass
1. Chick

[TheBigUnit]

Suprised how many are giving Judd high votes. Maybe I should watch again. Actually no, I'm not going to put myself through that.


He was the only one who gave us anything of substance through the middle in the last half in particular. We got back into the game in the last 1/4 largely thanks to him.

[nibbles]

got a feeling votes are going to be all over the shop today, didn't look at the possession counts but this is who i felt were our best...

5) wirrpanda
4) braun
3) stenglein
2) glass
1) judd

[Embers]

In all honesty no one was actually good. They were a few okays but thats about it. Worst performance since the Derby last year

[FiveStrings]

5: Braun
4: Hansen
3: Judd
2: Rosa
1: Wirrpanda

[Genesis67]

5. Wirra
4. Stenglein
3. Glass
2. Priddis
1. Rosa

[The_Eagles]

Wirrpanda
Judd
Hansen
Waters
Rosa

[The Made Guy]

5. C Judd
4. D Wirrpanda
3. A Hansen
2. M Rosa
1. B Waters

[MAG87]

5. B Waters
4. Chris Judd
3. D. Wirrapanda
2. M. Rosa
1. A Hansen

[Belgarion]

5. Rosa
4. Judd
3. Glass
2. Priddis
1. Hansen

[Fletchers Girl]

I don't know this is a hard one to do, so here goes.....

5. Panda
4. Judd
3. Rosa
2. Braun
1. Waters

[EagleMan87]

5. Hansen
4. Wirra
3. Selwood
2. Priddis
1. Rosa

Unlucky: Judd, Chick

[daddy_4_eyes]

5. Rosa - Thought he was our best. Ran hard all day
4. Judd - Seemed he always had 2 opponents on him, but was still influential
3. Glass - Wish we had 2 of him. He was being switched all over the place to cover holes as our other tall defenders were 2nd rate
2. Waters - How reliable is his disposal now? Think back 12 months and he's a different player
1. Hansen - Provided a target

[Stenglein's a Champ!]

M. Rosa
C. Judd
D. Glass
B. Waters
D. Wirrpanda

[bassmanx]

5. Wirra
4. Braun
3. Judd
2. Rosa
1. Priddis

[BarcaRulz]

5. Wirra
4. Judd
3. Glass
2. Waters
1. Braun

[Kerr4PM]

Wirra
Rosa
Priddis
Waters
Braun

[*Mystique*]

5. Wirra
4. Judd
3. Rosa
2. Waters
1. Braun

[carn_the_cattas]

I know I'm not a West coast supporter but heres my votes.
5. Wirrpanda - If he wasn't playing Geelong would've kicked more goals. Reads the play beautifully and cut off many Geelong attack whilst also setting up forays forward.
4. Rosa - I rate him very highly. Got a lot of the ball whilst also pushing forward to snag a couple of goals.
3. Glass - If you wanted to see how to play full back, this is the game to watch. At one end Scarlett stopped goals and set of forward attacks, at the other end Glass did the same.
2. Hansen - Presented really well. Had a lot of mark out on the lead and kicked a few too.
1. Waters - Will be a gun for a long time. As will Priddis. West Coast, despite being the best team over the last few years have gathered a lot of young talent. Mitch Brown has huge potential too.

If you looked at the stats and saw Judd with 29 touches and goal you would immediatly think, BOG, but being at the game, he didn't have a huge impact. He had a few bursts he and there but he wasn't influential, if he was West Coast would've won. Statiscally, he outdid Joel Corey and based on impact on the game I think Corey had the upper hand. It just shows how stats can be decieving.

Good luck for the rest of the year. No doubt you'll be there come September. Geelong is in more of a "wait and see" position.

[Kerr4PM]

Well done Mate :thumbsu: ^

[Seadog]

5. Wirrapanda
4. Judd
3. Glass
2. Rosa
Not much after that.

[EagleMan87]

5. Wirrapanda
4. Judd
3. Glass
2. Rosa
Not much after that.

Selwood kept Gablet quiet, Hansen kicked 3, Priddis was good, etc.

[Stenglein's a Champ!]

5. Wirrapanda
4. Judd
3. Glass
2. Rosa
Not much after that.

Waters had 29 touches and 13 marks.

IMO he's worth at least a vote.

[Emerald]

5 - Matt Rosa
4 - David Wirrpanda
3 - Chris Judd
2 - Beau Waters
1 - Darren Glass

[eaglerock]

5.rosa
4.judd
3.waters
2.wirra
1.hanson

[Frappe]

Selwood kept Gablet quiet, Hansen kicked 3, Priddis was good, etc.

Selwood kept Junior quiet until just before half-time. Thought Junior was the most influential player in the 3rd quarter, and continued on in the 4th...

[Ricky Bobby]

I thought Kerr showed how much he has matured today. Was at the game today and im sure Kerr of 12 months ago would have given Ling a whack he deserved for constantly holding on to him. My mate is a passionate Cats man and he was discraced at the tactics used against him. My votes are
5. Panda
4. Waters (coming on in lepas and bounds!!!!!)
3. Rosa (best game i have seen him play. Showed some pace i dint think he had!)
2. Judd (got us back in it the last just not enough help)
1. Selwood (did a job on Jesus for 3 quarters)

[Sharpy]

5. Judd
4. Waters
3. Wirra
2. Rosa
1. Hanson

[nibbles]

4. Waters (coming on in lepas and bounds!!!!!)


:eek:

hopefully his hands don't fall off!

[Ruddiger]

5 Judd
4 Wirrpanda
3 Hansen
2 Waters
1 Rosa

[Embley]

Lynch was very good in the ruck...especially in the 4th before Seaby came back and we lost the momentum. Seaby was poor today IMO.

5 Judd (hard to put anyone above him :S)
4 Selwood
3 Lynch
2 Rosa
1 Wirrpanda (had it on a string)

[Big Cox]

Do i have to :thumbsd:

[midorigreenwood]

5)Michael Braun
4)Beau Waters
3)Ashley Hansen
2)Matt Rosa
1)Darren Glass

[peterss]

5 - Rosa
4 - Waters
3 - Wirra
2 - Hansen
1 - Glass

[Ted Ed Fred]

3 votes: Judd
2: Glass
1: Wirrpanda (why did he spend half of the final quarter on the bench?)


Can't believe people are rating Hansen's performance. Was poor all game, 2 of his goals came in the 4th when we were never a real chance of winning.

[nibbles]

Do i have to :thumbsd:

actually, you've been removed from the voters list anyway mate

http://www.bigfooty.com/forum/showthread.php?t=313650&page=2

[Keyser Soze]

5 wirra
4 rosa
3 judd
2 waters
1 selwood

[Magnum27]

5.Judd
4.Chick
3.Waters
2.Hansen
1.B.Jones

[TheBigUnit]

Can't believe people are rating Hansen's performance. Was poor all game, 2 of his goals came in the 4th when we were never a real chance of winning.

He did alright considering he got little if any delivery in the 3rd.

[larrikin]

Can't believe people are rating Hansen's performance. Was poor all game, 2 of his goals came in the 4th when we were never a real chance of winning.
14 marks from a CHF isn't a bad effort

[eagleskickass]

5 - Wirra
4 - Hansen
3 - Chick
2 - Braun
1 - Judd

Very Hard...but losses always are.

[nearlyblonde]

5. Wirra
4. Chick
3. Rosa
2. Judd
1. Glass

[Isandula]

5. Judd
4. Waters (wow, finally got a vote from me....in a losing game :mad: :( )
3. Rosa
2. Wirra
1. Chick

[hawkeye23]

I'm voting on endeavour, and there wasn't much of that displayed by many:

5. Judd
4. Chick - how he's supposed to chase down three blokes unassisted, I have no idea
3. Wirrpanda
2. Waters
1. Rosa

[lyall]

5 - Judd
4 - Glass
3 - Wirrapanda
2 - Waters
1 - Priddis

[Lynch takes a mark]

5 Judd
4 Glass
3 Wirra
2 Rosa
1 Hurn

[jod23]

5 - Wirra
4 - Hansen
3 - Rosa
2 - Judd
1 - Waters

[wce_all_da_way]

5. Judd
4. Wirra
3. Waters
2. Rosa
1. Glass

[wce4premiership]

5. wirra
4. Glass
3. Waters
2 Judd
1. chick

[pauljam]

5 - Judd
4 - Wirra
3 - Hansen
2 - Waters
1 - Glass

[Frizzo]

5 Judd
4 Rosa
3 Wirra
2 Waters
1 Glass

[Isandula]

Damn seeing Judd get so many 5 votes, seems like forever since he was so good :(

Wow our first lose was 15 weeks ago