Votes Rd 8 Vs Melbourne

[Belgarion]

5. Judd (I could give him 10 it that were possible)
4. Stenglein
3. Kerr
2. Lynch (Would have got 4 if he had kicked straighter)
1. Morton (Good game by the youngster)

Belgarion

[A Living God]

5. Lynch
4. Lynch's Glove
3. Judd
2. Hansen
1. Kerr

or

4. Judd
3. Hansen
2. Kerr
1. Staker

[94_Eagles]

5. Judd
4. Lynch
3. Glass
2. Fletcher
1. B. Jones

[Goldenblue]

5. Judd
4. Glass
3. Lynch
2. Kerr
1. Morton

[A Living God]

5. Judd
4. Glass
3. Lynch
2. Kerr
1. Morton
How? He had 7 possesions the ball barely went near him. Not his fault but how do figure he was 2nd best on ground?

[weagles_fan]

5. Judd
4. Lynch
3. Hansen
2. Kerr
1. B.Jones

[sTeeL]

5. Judd
Judd was brilliant

4. Kerr
Kerr not far behind.

3. Lynch
Lynch played really well just let himself down with his Kicking.

2. Fletcher
Fletcher had a good return to AFL footy and made some good linking. Let himself down a tiny bit by not being harder at some of the contests but i was pretty happy with his overall output

1. Stenglien
Stinger is always good

Honorable Mentions: Morton, Cox, Waters, Wirra
Loved Mortons game, Cox did his job in the Ruck, Waters is a champ and Wirra kicked a few.

[BarcaRulz]

5. Judd (classy game from a classy player)
4. Lynch (scored 5, presented well.. needs to learn how to kick straight though)
3. Kerr (good game, got reported though :()
2. Stinger (another good game)
1. Cox (i thought he did well around the ground today)

[TheBigUnit]

5 C Judd (by a long way)
4 Q Lynch
3 D Kerr
2 A Hansen
1 M Morton

[MAG87]

5. Judd
4. Hansen
3. Kerr
2. Lynch
1. Cox

[Big Man]

5. Judd
4. Lynch
3. Kerr
2. Hansen
1. T.Stenglein

[Goldenblue]

How? He had 7 possesions the ball barely went near him. Not his fault but how do figure he was 2nd best on ground?

My votes, my choice, are you Gunnar in disguise? ;)

I thought Glass did a good job on their skipper, especially the passages of play when Melbourne kicked a few in a row.

[bzparkes]

5.Judd
4.Kerr
3.Lynch
2.Stenglein
1.Hansen

[beatlesmith]

5. Judd
4. Lynch
3. Kerr
2. Stenglein
1. Morton

[wce4premiership]

5. Lynch - extremely dominant performance
4. Judd - great work all day
3. kerr - not far behind judd and great effort, chased lots as well
2. stenglien - good job in the middle as always
1. hansen - hard to choose out of him or staker but he did really well

close to votes = waters, staker and fletcher.

[FiveStrings]

500: Judd
4: Lynch
3: Kerr
2: Stenglein
1: Bones

[eagles0903]

5. Juddy - Easily
4. Hansen - Thought he with Judd set the game up for us
3. Lynch - Good game by TBU - would have been great if he had kicked straight
2. Kerr - Back to some good form
1. Stinger - so underrated just does the job week in week out:thumbsu:

[The_Eagles]

Judd
Lynch
Hurn
Hansen
Kerr

[Lion El'Johnson]

5. Judd
4. Kerr
3. Hunter
2. Wirrpunda
1. Lynch

[heals]

5- Judd
4- Hansen
3- Kerr
2- Lynch (kick straighter and could of had 4-5)
1- Waters

Didnt give morton a vote mainly because he only played 1/2 a game of good footy IMO.

[Embers]

5. Chris Judd
4. Quinten Lynch (down the centre my boy)
3. Daniel Kerr
2. Beau Waters
1. Brett Jones

[daddy_4_eyes]

5. Judd
4. Hansen
3. Lynch
2. Kerr
1. Stenglein

[A Living God]

My votes, my choice, are you Gunnar in disguise? ;)

I thought Glass did a good job on their skipper, especially the passages of play when Melbourne kicked a few in a row.
Each to his own, apperantly i'm the only person thought staker deserved votes for his efforts despite kicking 1.5.

[pauljam]

5 - Juddy
4 - Lynchy QQQQ
3 - Kerr
2 - Stinga
1 - Hansen

lots of others put in very good efforts. Hopefully the kicking will come good as the season progresses. Good effort from Mitch to get 3 goals!!! Stakes played a pearler, just wich he could have snagged a couple more :-) BJones was great as well

[eaglerock]

5.judd
4.kerr
3.lynch
2.stinger
1.hansen

[Ruddiger]

5. Judd
4. Lynch
3. Hansen
2. Glass
1. Stenglein

[midorigreenwood]

5) Chris Judd
4) Quentin Lynch
3) Ashley Hansen
2) Daniel Kerr
1) David Wirrpanda

I wish the Brownlow had a 5 - 1 system.....seriously Judd was so BOG its not funny....deserves more than a measly 3 votes.

[bassmanx]

5. Judd
4. Hansen
3. Lynch
2. Kerr
1. Wirra

Honourable mentions to Glass, Stinger, Mitch and Rosa.

[Genesis67]

5: C. Judd
4: T. Stenglein
3: A. Hansen
2: D. Kerr
1. B. Staker

Honorable mentions to Brett Jones, TBU, Wirrpanda, Matt Rosa and Mitch Morton.

[Emerald]

5 - Chris Judd
4 - Daniel Kerr
3 - Quentin Lynch
2 - Ash Hansen
1 - Tyson Stenglein

[Embley]

10 Judd
4 Hansen
3 Kerr
2 Lynch
1 Morton

Honourables to: Wirrpanda, Stenglein, Braun, Hunter


Johnstone was quality for the Demons..

[happy_eagle]

5. judd
4. lynch
3. kerr
2.hansen
1. cox

[lyall]

5 - Judd
4 - Lynch
3 - Waters
2 - B. Jones
1 - Stenglein

[EagleMan87]

5. Judd - duh
4. Lynch - His best game of the year, easily
3. Bones - Spent time on Neitz and didn't concede a goal all day. Also excellent run out of defence. A furphy for AA selection.
2. Hansen - His leading was awesome, and despite only one goal was a big part of our win.
1. Stenglein - Always great, always overlooked, should be vice captain.

Unlucky - Rosa, he's pretty mecurial when he wants to be;) , Waters, Glass.

[peterss]

5. Judd
4. Lynch
3. Stenglein
2. Hansen
1. Morton

[The Made Guy]

Here they are.

5. C Judd
4. Q Lynch
3. D Kerr
2. A Hansen
1. T Stenglein

[The Made Guy]

apperantly i'm the only person thought staker deserved votes for his efforts

I thought about giving him 1, but gee he can be a lair sometimes. Did it a couple times today and was made to look foolish.

[West Coast 06]

5: C. Judd
4: T. Stenglein
3: A. Hansen
2: D. Kerr
1. B. Staker
I'll go with those also.

I thought the rucks were great today. Coxy did some great tap work and Seaby was good around the ground today.

[larrikin]

5 - Judd
4 - Kerr
3 - Lynch
2 - Stenglein
1 - Bones

[Bestbird]

5. Judd - In a class of his own today
4. Kerr - Was heavily targeted by the taggers yet a dominant display
3. Lynch - 5.7 speaks volumes for his workrate as a FF, more kicking practice
2. Stenglien - Another great game by Stinger
1. Hansen - Another good display, getting more consitant

[Magnum27]

5. Judd
4.Kerr
3.Lynch
2.Hurn
1.Steinglein

[JKCeagle]

5. Judd - must be leading the Brownlow after this performance, having a ridiculous year, each of his goals was jump-out-of-your-seat material (anyone YouTube'd them? :) )
4. Hansen - his clean hands and work ethic always impresses
3. Lynch - his wastefulness really irritated me, but hey it was still his best game of '07
2. Kerr - big possessions but not as damaging as Judd, great game nonetheless...finally got the report we all knew was coming, gotta be more careful than that Daniel :(
1. Stenglein - quietly efficient as usual

[JKCeagle]

I thought about giving him 1, but gee he can be a lair sometimes. Did it a couple times today and was made to look foolish.

Staker suffers from occasional bouts of "Marty Mattner Syndrome", which presents as unwise attempts to take on tackles/players that he really shouldn't.

[Fletchers Girl]

5. Judd
4. Kerr
3. Stinger
2. Hurn
1. Lynch

[Kempie]

5. Judd
4. Kerr
3. Lynch
2. Stenglein
1. Morton

I could be wrong though :)

[nearlyblonde]

5. Judd
4. Q
3. Kerr
2. Stenglein
1. Staker

[eagleskickass]

5. Juddy
4. Q
3. Stinger
2. Hansen
1. Morton

[Sharpy]

5.Judd
4.Q
3. Kerr
2.Hansen
1. Stinger

[Isandula]

5. Judd
4. Kerr
3. Stenglein
2. Lynch
1. Hansen

[Stenglein's a Champ!]

Judd
Lynch
Stenglein
Kerr
Hansen

[Toshowyouwhy]

5. Judd: Do I need a reason
4. Kerr: much the same
3: B.Jones: Off half back as good as anyone
2: Lynch: If he could kick the easier ones he'd be a superstar.
1: Morton: Looked dangerous, top effort

[hawkeye23]

5. Judd
4. Kerr - too bad he lost the Brownlow for this year :(
3. Lynch
2. Stenglein
1. Bones

[jod23]

5 - Judd
4 - Lynch
3 - Kerr
2 - Stenglein
1 - Hansen

[Keyser Soze]

5 Judd
4 Stenglein
3 Kerr
2 Lynch
1 Hansen

[wce_all_da_way]

5. Judd
4. Lynch
3. Hansen
2. Kerr
1. Stenglein

Keep forgetting to vote until late in the week, always think that I have but that's only BF medal :o

[Frizzo]

5. Judd
4. Lynch
3. Kerr
2. Glass
1. Stenglein

[Isandula]

Now this is really depressing seeing these voting threads from early on, I miss the old Judd :( Injuries really came on in leaps and bounds since this game :mad: